Badung Regency Government Said to Have Strong Grounds to Defend Public Interest
The discrepancy in the number of telecommunications tower sites within the cooperation between the Badung Regency Government and PT BTS—increasing from 49 sites in the initial agreement to more than 200 sites during its development—is considered a potential legal issue to be tested during the cassation process in the Supreme Court.
Criminal Law Observer Suparji Ahmad stated that this difference must be examined regarding the boundaries of the object and the scope of rights actually granted through the cooperation agreement. If the initial agreement only granted development or operational rights for 49 sites, then the increase to over 200 sites must have a clear contractual basis.
“The principle of pacta sunt servanda requires that agreements be executed as law for the parties involved. However, the consequence also works in reverse: rights and obligations should not be unilaterally expanded beyond the agreed object,” Suparji told reporters on Thursday (17/9).
According to him, it is essential to ensure the legal basis for the addition of these sites, including the local government’s approval and the compensation mechanism, should the expansion of the cooperation scope provide additional economic benefits to the private party.
This is particularly relevant as the High Court of Bali, through Decision Number 200/PDT/2026/PT DPS dated 20 August 2026, declared the cooperation agreement between the Badung Regency Government and BTS on 7 May 2007 to be valid and binding. The ruling also extended the cooperation until 7 May 2047.
“Furthermore, the appeal decision indeed states that the 2007 agreement is valid and binding and extends the cooperation for 20 years,” he added.
Suparji noted that the legal status of towers located outside the initial 49 sites must also be investigated based on the basis of their construction and operation. If the number of sites subsequently grew to more than 200, he argued, it must be proven whether such an addition was permitted in the original agreement, obtained the consent of all parties, or constituted an expansion of the object beyond the agreement.
“In principle, any changes affecting the object, volume, operational rights, duration, or the economic value of the cooperation should be formalised in a contract amendment or addendum agreed upon by the parties, provided that the mechanism complies with applicable regulations,” he explained.
Therefore, the existence of the 2007 agreement cannot automatically serve as a basis to assume that all additional sites have obtained legitimacy. The legal basis for every change must still be proven. “It is inaccurate to assume that all additions automatically gain legitimacy simply because an initial agreement exists,” said Suparji.
According to Suparji, the increased scope of cooperation is also related to the balance of economic benefits between the local government and the private sector. If the addition of sites provides additional rights or economic benefits to the private party through the use of local government assets, space, facilities, or authority, then the aspect of compensation must be addressed.
“In principle, yes, if the addition results in additional rights or economic benefits for the private party by utilising local government assets, space, facilities, or authority,” he said.
He assessed that the change from 49 to more than 200 sites is a material change that warrants evaluation, including from the perspective of the balance of performance and counter-performance, as well as the potential revenue that the local government should receive. “The logic is simple: if the value and scope of utilisation increase materially from 49 to more than 200 sites, then the balance of performance and counter-performance must be re-evaluated,” said Suparji.
Nevertheless, Suparji cautioned that these issues should not be immediately concluded as regional financial losses or acts of corruption. If there are allegations of using space, assets, permits, or operational rights outside the contract scope without proper payment or compensation, such allegations must first be proven concretely.
“It has potential, but it does not automatically mean that regional financial loss or corruption has occurred,” he clarified.
He noted that allegations of regional financial loss must be supported by concrete, real, and accountable calculations. Thus, a distinction must be made between contractual violations, civil losses, regional financial losses, and allegations of criminal acts.
“To state that there is a regional financial loss legally, there must be a concrete, real, and accountable calculation,” he said.
Suparji believes the issue of 49 sites versus more than 200 sites can be used by the Badung Regency Government as one of the arguments in the cassation. However, this argument must be framed as a matter of legal application, rather than merely asking the Supreme Court to re-evaluate the facts. “It can, as long as it is constructed as a matter of legal application and not merely asking the Supreme Court to re-examine the facts,” he said.
According to him, cassation is essentially not a third examination of facts. Therefore, the Badung Regency Government needs to demonstrate specifically whether the lower courts applied the law correctly regarding the object and scope of the agreement.
One point that can be tested is whether the consequence of extending the cooperation until 2047 adequately considered the boundaries of the agreement’s object, the substantial changes in its implementation, and the economic consequences for the local government.
“The Regency Government can question whether the judex facti was correct in granting the consequence of extending the contract until 2047 without adequately considering the boundaries of the object, the scope of rights, substantial changes in the implementation of the agreement, and the economic consequences for the local government,” concluded Suparji.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/badung-regency-government-said-to-have-strong-grounds-to-defend-public-interest-1789660349)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/nusantara/934691/pemkab-badung-disebut-miliki-modal-kuat-perjuangkan-kepentingan-publik), translated from Indonesian