Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Back to the future?

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Back to the future?

Although the counting of votes cast in the April 5 legislative
election has still to be completed -- only 99 percent of the
votes had been manually counted as of last weekend -- a number of
patterns have already emerged that spell both good and bad for
the future of democracy in Indonesia.

First, the good. As many analysts have been able to observe,
the Indonesian electorate proved itself to be a good deal smarter
than many political leaders had expected or anticipated. Among
the political parties that learned this lesson the hard way was
the Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle (PDI-P) which, with
19.4 percent of votes garnered compared with 33.7 percent in
1999, is now certain to end up with fewer seats in the House of
Representatives. Degraded to second rank with "only" 104 seats
secured compared with the Golkar Party's 117 seats in the House,
the party is now compelled to acknowledge, belatedly, that
Indonesians have had enough of corruption and bad governance, and
that they hanker for change.

Ironically, it was this same reason that catapulted the
Prosperous Justice Party, which had capitalized on its reputation
for being populist and incorruptible, from a party with no more
than 1.36 percent of the vote won in 1999, to one with a
respectable 7.19 percent in the just-concluded legislative
election. More or less the same can be said for the Democratic
Party, led by former coordinating minister for political and
security affairs Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono. For a newly born party
it is doing quite well, with 7.54 percent of the vote. Surely,
all of this -- plus the orderly and relatively violence-free
elections and postelection procedures -- attest to the
intelligence of the Indonesian electorate.

Unfortunately, the final results, as indicated by the 99
percent of votes already counted so far, also show that a heavy
fragmentation of the Indonesian electorate will continue to
prevail in the coming five years, with no less than 24 political
parties of a variety of ideological and religious factions vying
for influence. It seems that almost six decades of national
independence have done little to erase those factional
differences.

By and large, however, to judge by the outcome of the April 5
legislative election, politicians of a conservative, non-radical
breed can be expected to maintain control of the process of
democratization, although the "progressive" camp may well see its
powers broadened by the support of stronger, urban-based, better-
educated Indonesians, represented by the Prosperous Justice
Party, the Democratic Party and the like.

Some analysts predict that, in the coming five years, the
political rivalry between the two major groupings in Indonesian
politics -- the Islamists on the one hand and the nationalists on
the other -- will be pushed more and more into the background by
such day-to-day matters as better employment and better
investment opportunities, improved political and economic
stability and the eradication of corruption. On the other hand,
analysts foresee a marginalization of the reformists as
represented at present by various non-governmental organizations,
student and professional groups.

One major problem that faces the reformists, it seems, is that
no clear line has ever been drawn to differentiate the new era of
democratic reform from the former eras of authoritarianism,
embodied by both President Sukarno in his later years and
President Soeharto from 1967 to 1998. The task of defining this
distinction thus falls on the shoulders of the elected power
holders and legislators. The question that must be asked, and
answered, is: What is the direction of democracy in Indonesia?

The recently held legislative election, welcome as it may be
as an exercise in democracy, has brought a number of pitfalls for
the nation. First is the possibility of a return to militarism
through the very process of democracy. If that happens, then it
will be far from imaginary that democracy, in its true substance,
will at best be replaced by democracy in name only. The process
of democratic reform could not only become stagnant, but even be
put into reverse gear.

At present there are those among our politicians who advocate
a return to the Constitution of 1945, which was instrumental to
the establishment of authoritarianism in this country. Where
Indonesian democracy will go in the next five years will
therefore depend very much on how Indonesians will vote in the
May 5 presidential election. Let us hope that the same wisdom and
intelligence that has guided voters through the legislative
elections will once again lead this nation in making its choice
in the upcoming presidential election.

More from 5 May 2004 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/back-to-the-future-1447893297-1490544)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print