Back to basics in monetary policy
Back to basics in monetary policy
This is the second of two articles on monetary policy by
Tubagus Feridhanusetyawan, senior economist and head of economic
affairs at the Centre for Strategic and International Studies
(CSIS) in Jakarta.
JAKARTA (JP): Those who are against tighter money policy may
argue that a higher interest rate would not effectively reduce
inflationary pressure because imported inflation continues to
dominate. Under these circumstances, sharp increases in the
interest rate could be costly for the real sector, and if the
interest rate is too high, it may lead to possible contractions
in the real sector, which could crowd out efforts reduce
inflation.
When the interest rate is facing a glass ceiling, the effort
to support the currency is through direct policy action in the
currency market. One method is to increase capital inflow by
demanding exporters put their foreign currency earnings in
domestic banks.
This would not be effective because with the collapse of the
domestic banking system, many exporters are using offshore trade-
financing services. In addition, institutional and legal
frameworks are not effective or solid enough to prevent the
under-invoicing and over-invoicing of exports and imports.
In the absence of capital inflow, a desperate action to
restrict the demand for foreign currency is to control capital
outflow. In other words, if the supply of foreign reserves could
not be increased, then the demand has to be restricted.
Here comes the controversial argument for capital control. The
measure to control capital outflow is seen as the second-best, or
even third-best, solution when the relationship between interest
rates and exchange rates is less sensitive.
With some sort of capital control, domestic interest rates
could be kept lower, relative to international rates without
creating heavy pressure that would lead to rupiah depreciation.
Those who believe in capital control argue that there are various
types of controls that can be implemented, from strictly
monitoring spot transactions, taxing currency transactions, to
strictly banning the purchase of foreign currencies.
While capital control seem to be attractive on paper, it is
still not the best solution. The best solution is to revive
confidence in the economy and encourage capital inflow.
Restricting outflow is definitely not a substitute for that. Some
argue that what Indonesia needs are three conditions: stable
politics, credible economic reforms and some sort of capital
control.
Once we have the first two, we do not need the third one.
While capital control may be able to put the trash under the
carpet in the short-term, its implementation would not solve the
problem without having stable political conditions and credible
economic reforms.
The implementation of any form of capital control is another
problematic issue. The biggest problem that Indonesia is facing
today is the absence of legal and institutional frameworks to
ensure that things are done correctly. Placing restrictions on
transactions would not work because the market would find a way
to get around them.
We have had some examples already. The ban of one forward
currency market overseas led to the development of a domestic
non-delivery forward market within only two weeks. Another
example is the blunder performed by the government in setting
different prices for diesel fuels in the market, which led to a
shortage of diesel fuels at gas stations, the creation of a black
market and other illegal transactions.
No-one could guarantee the absence of a black currency market
with the implementation of capital control or restrictions on
currency transactions. Therefore, the credibility of any capital
control is really questionable.
Let's go back to basics.
While the daily movement of the rupiah could constantly feed
daily political news, the short and medium-term movement of the
rupiah still depends on monetary fundamentals. So the monetary
authority should focus on the core monetary fundamentals, which
is the growth of base money.
Furthermore, Bank Indonesia should focus only on inflation.
The central bank's officials have said that they are more
interested in targeting core inflation, which actually opens the
possibility for blaming the government for higher inflation due
to the increase in some administered prices.
Or perhaps the bank has prepared another excuse for its
possible failure in maintaining single digit inflation this year.
Again, Bank Indonesia should be responsible for the control of
overall inflation, not core inflation, and in return it should be
given total independence in implementing its monetary policies.
Bank Indonesia officials have done their job in monitoring the
monetary targets, but again, the increases in the interest rate
have been too small, too late. This is not a new phenomenon
though, because it seems that they have been watching many other
things rather than just the growth of base money.
It remains to be seen whether base money growth of around 10
percent this year can be achieved, and the answer depends on Bank
Indonesia's independence.
Bank Indonesia has been constantly fighting for its
independence, and a real test case for its independence now is
whether the bank's officials can determine interest rates or
money growth without any intervention. Consistency with the
principal of independence in conducting monetary policy would
lead the monetary authority to be the one to blame if the
monetary indicator gets out of control.
Higher interest rates are surely not without their risks.
Further bank closures, mergers and a second round of
recapitalization are all possible, and these are not simple
matters. Because of the weak legal system, the breakdown of
institutional frameworks, ineffective banking restructuring and
the large government budget deficit, further bank closures and
recapitalization would be extremely complex.
If we could risk higher interest rates, of course there is
still another policy option to sacrifice the money growth, to
maintain a low rupiah, and to allow for higher inflation. But can
anyone guarantee that higher inflation and a lower rupiah would
not lead to another round of bank recapitalization next year?
The effectiveness of monetary policies would also depend upon
the success of bank restructuring. Solid banks would sustain a
high interest rate environment and an efficient banking operation
would reduce monetary operation costs.
Because the domestic credit market has collapsed, commercial
banks have been investing in large amounts of Bank Indonesia
short-term promissory notes (SBIs) to survive, and, as a result,
the increase in SBI rates may have to be high enough to give
commercial banks an incentive to increase their deposit rates and
absorb any excess liquidity in the market.
Therefore, as long as the domestic banking system is weak and
the progress of bank restructuring is slow, monetary policy will
always be constrained.
Today's underlying problem is a lack of confidence in the
government, in economic reform, and in the country in general,
which have led to continuing net capital outflows. Anything that
can solve these problems, that can bring back capital inflows in
any form, would be the best solution.
The temptation to put currency or capital controls in place
remains high, especially when the current or even the future
government fails to show credibility, to bring back confidence
and to attract significant capital inflows. But one must remember
that implementing capital controls would never be the best
solution.
The lack of institutional and legal frameworks would require
the policy action to be designed as simply as possible. From the
monetary side, just focus on the growth of money, be consistent,
and let the market adjust and find its own way.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/back-to-basics-in-monetary-policy-1447893297-1106058)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post