Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

[b]

Does ASEAN really care
about its people's pain?

Ati Nurbaiti
Staff Writer
The Jakarta Post
Sanur
Bali

The town of Nunukan in East Kalimantan has recently witnessed
waves of illegal workers pouring into its borders, a scene
provoking both lessons in law enforcement and indignity on the
part of Indonesians. At least 67 workers and their children
reportedly died of exhaustion and malnutrition, leading to sharp
criticism from Indonesians and also the Philippines whose workers
are also being deported for lack of documents. Some parents have
had to decide to leave children with strangers for fear of not
being able to feed them. The workers had been too troublesome,
Kuala Lumpur had been lenient enough and now it is taking action.

Amid the suffering of thousands who might nevertheless return
in the absence of jobs in their own country, the Association of
Southeast Asian Nations can only look on. Next year the whole
affair may be repeated all over again. But labor policies are
those of Malaysia and ASEAN must observe its "non intervention"
principle.

No one likes to interfere with their neighbors, says Sukumbhan
Paribatra, a member of Thailand's parliament. In a gentle manner
harking of young high ranking Thai officials who seem to share
less of the "old boys club" code among ASEAN leaders, Paribatra
said "there are times when problems affect neighbors," when ASEAN
leaders must speak up. Evoking "ASEAN solidarity" in the current
migrant labor issue, a participant at last week's ASEAN People's
Assembly said, "what does this do to friendship among neighbors?"

ASEAN does recognize the need to act when problems transgress
national borders. Since 1997, it encouraged the conduct of free
and fair elections in Cambodia. As its Secretary General Rodolfo
C. Severino Jr. said, "ASEAN has felt compelled to get involved
in Cambodia ... not out of a desire to interfere in a neighbor's
internal affairs, but because of the regional repercussions of
developments in that neighbor."

Yet regarding the recurring haze problem, Malaysians and
Singaporeans can only hope that the winds do not blow their way.
It has become so severe that residents of Palangkaraya in Central
Kalimantan now reportedly face starvation as the air and land
routes on which they depend on for food supplies is disrupted.

In 1997 Malaysians and Singaporeans shared the suffering of
Indonesians, missing work days and school days given the health
hazards posed by the haze. ASEAN did its utmost and ministers
agreed on a Regional Haze Action Plan.

But Jakarta's commitment is far from clear; residents in Riau
and Kalimantan have largely been left to cope by themselves. No
wonder the observation that many of over 500 million of ASEAN's
entire population do not know about it let alone all the work it
has done. "Ask the people what ASEAN is and what the impact has
had on their lives, and they don't know," former foreign minister
Ali Alatas said.

Instead, the regional body has long been known "as a club of
dictators," says scholar Carolina G. Hernandez, President of the
the Institute of Strategic and International Studies (ISIS) in
Manila. Says Paribatra, the problem is "the difficulty to
sustain political will" among ASEAN leaders, to act on its own
fine agreements and declarations.

Given so many internal problems of governments when ASEAN was
formed in 1967, leaders "may have been forced" to focus on good
relations among themselves, says Alatas. But well ahead of its
35th anniversary this year, he added that it had been a "long
felt need" to bring ASEAN closer to its people.

If leaders were golfing together and managed to solve problems
then of course this would be good thing, says Malaysian activist
Debbie Stothard. But if the excuse is that the leaders must focus
on national stability even in times when it was believed that
stability was a requisite to economic growth -- "they have a
twisted understanding of security," says Stothard.

A common understanding of security, she said, is "when people
are reasonably satisfied and feel they can negotiate (with
government people), and (conditions where) people won't leave
their country in such large numbers."

But instead governments in ASEAN's history have displayed
mistrust in their own people, arresting potential dissidents for
instance. In the end, Stothard says, ASEAN and its leaders seem
to be clinging to a naive "ASEAN way" without significantly
resolving problems while their people must try on their own to
seek improvement; Hernandez cites the prodemocracy movements in
Indonesia "and even Myanmar".

Stothard, who coordinates the Alternative Network of ASEAN
(Altsean) advocating for the people of Burma (Myanmar), is among
a few activists who sees some hope of ASEAN becoming more
effective through the circle of scholars close to it. Exasperated
with how removed the regional body was from its population, the
think tanks, such as ISIS and the Jakarta-based Center for
International and Strategic Studies, following up on an idea from
Thailand, developed the first ASEAN People's Assembly in Batam in
2000, and the second last week in Bali.

Although there have been so many non government organizations
and networks on various issues in the region, "they are all
talking among themselves, ASEAN is also talking by itself,"
Hernandez said. The Assembly aims for specific networks linking
ASEAN to these networks.

Because ASEAN has long projected an image which is aloof,
wouldn't it be best to accept that people's organizations must do
the work on the ground while leaders can just focus on avoiding
tension among themselves?

The drawback of ASEAN remaining ineffective, says Danny Yatim,
an activist on HIV/AIDS issues, is that people's initiatives will
never have nation wide, let alone regional, impact.

Apart from HIV/AIDS, trafficking of people, drugs and weapons
are still among threats to Southeast Asians, and wide income gap
remains within and among member countries. These are among issues
of "human security" which ASEAN has long been called on to
address. However participants in the People's Assembly reiterated
concerns how in the trend of "falling over each other" to win the
favor of the United States, ASEAN governments have since Sept. 11
found it increasingly convenient to sacrifice civil liberties,
drawing thin lines between dissidents, rebels and terrorists.

Many expectations of ASEAN are "unrealistic", says Severino,
whose term ends at the end of the year; many do not acknowledge
the progress made, its relatively young history and the hardships
surrounding its birth. "Either people expect too much or don't
think ASEAN is important," Severino said.

But people do need ASEAN and tall expectations are inevitable.

Since Sept. 11, for instance, scores of handicraft exporters
in East Java had to reschedule deliveries or stop exporting
altogether, given the suspicion of smuggling and fears of
anthrax, said Alam Surya Putra of the Association for Small Scale
Business (Pupuk).

"ASEAN needs to focus more on enhancing local economies," Alam
said. "So far ASEAN (member countries) has favored growth and
hence large industries."

At least Southeast Asians would expect, says Stothard, ASEAN's
engagement in more efforts in human security -- "instead of this
kind of situation where ASEAN acts to prolong conflict and
political instability by failing to respond" to situations where
threats are posed by neighboring countries.

In a desperate bid to direct ASEAN into a "community of caring
societies," as outlined in its Vision 2020, the recommendations
of the People's Assembly in Sanur, Bali will be submitted to
ASEAN Secretariat ahead of its next November summit in Phnom
Penh, Cambodia this year.

The recommendations which stress on the "human security"
agenda reflects the demand that ASEAN and its leaders actually
listen and take care of the needs of their people.

2. LA06 -- Bush's environmental anti-policy
1 X 30

Bush's environmental anti-policy

Robert Gottlieb
Occidental College
Newsday Daily
New York

George W. Bush might like the great outdoors of the Texas
plains, wear cowboy boots and proclaim himself a friend of the
environment, but there isn't an environmental law or regulation
he wouldn't mind abolishing or minimizing.

Unlike his father, and even unlike Ronald Reagan and Richard
Nixon before him, George W. has, from his first days in office,
been seeking to undercut environmental policy constraints for
industries such as oil, automotive and timber. An administration
buzzword has been deregulation (although a bit less so since the
California deregulation-induced energy crisis last year), but the
intent is anti-regulation.

Another common Bush refrain is that industry knows best. But
that also might have been downplayed a bit in the wake of recent
corporate scandals, including those in the oil and
telecommunications industries. Still, faith in industry remains a
core belief of Bush, Vice President Dick Cheney and others who
have helped craft what could be considered this administration's
environmental anti-policy.

Bush has taken this approach despite a continuing and very
powerful pro-environment sentiment in nearly all regions of the
country and among diverse constituencies. But activists, given
their own long-standing internal debates about the direction of
the environmental movement, have not always been able to respond
effectively.

The current debate about forest fires is illustrative.
Although couched in language about fire prevention, the new Bush
strategy to thin million of acres of forest over the next decade
in places such as Oregon and California is a classic anti-policy
approach. It does this in part by seeking to bypass the review
process in the granddaddy of environmental laws and original
cornerstone of environmental policy, the National Environmental
Policy Act, which Nixon signed in 1970.

Bush says he wants to deal with the problem of forest fires by
allowing the timber industry, without environmental review, to
cut and log "dead wood" to reduce fuel for fires. But critics
contend that, although some thinning strategies could have
benefits, Bush is using fears about uncontrolled fires to provide
an opportunity for expanded logging by companies that want to
bypass environmental regulations such as reviews and appeals.

Because the issue has been framed in part as "fire
prevention," environmentalists have at times been on the
defensive, not able to fully demonstrate that the Bush approach
is designed to skirt environmental policies on behalf of a
desired outcome for industry.

More than previous presidents who challenged or disputed a
particular environmental law or regulation, Bush is the complete
industry man. He likes to say that he thinks and acts like a CEO;
in fact, his approach toward environmental issues extends beyond
a single problem area to seek a more blanket approach that
reduces or eliminates government intervention or review. Whether
global warming, automobile fuel efficiency or occupational health
and safety, Bush is most comfortable in articulating a government
role that is the least onerous from a CEO's perspective.

Bush has been willing to defy and, in some cases, duke it out
with environmentalists. His father, who cast himself in the
Theodore Roosevelt mold of an environmental-oriented Republican,
did not always agree with environmentalists, but the senior Bush
nevertheless sought to define himself as pro-environment. In
complex negotiations with environmentalists and Congress, he
signed off on some important legislation, notably the Clean Air
Act amendments of 1990.

Nixon also sought to fend off environmental criticism, despite
some sharp disagreements over legislation such as the Clean Water
Act. Largely for political reasons, Nixon tried to pre-empt the
environmental issue, declaring the need to "make peace with
nature" and promote the notion that American know-how and
technology could solve problems.

Even Reagan and those in his administration, including former
Secretary of the Interior James Watt, were not able to pull off a
blanket anti-environmental approach, despite their often hothouse
anti-environmental rhetoric. The key to the Reaganite approach
was fiscal -- using strategies such as cost-benefit analysis and
budgetary review by the Office of Management and Budget to soften
or undermine environmental laws and regulations. Nevertheless,
significant environmental legislation was enacted during the
Reagan years, addressing issues including hazardous waste, safe
drinking water and the public's right to know what companies are
polluting their communities and workplaces.

Part of the success of the environmental movement during the
years of the Nixon, Reagan and the senior Bush administrations
had to do not only with timing, but with the ability of
environmentalists to frame the nature of the debate. During the
Nixon years, environmental issues became a powerful new political
factor, given the enormous public attention, widespread problems
and strong grass-roots character of protest.

During the Reagan years, the use of anti-environmental
rhetoric often backfired, as activists were largely able to
define issues such as hazardous waste or right-to-know
regulations as community concerns.

During the senior Bush administration, the debate was often
framed as how best to accomplish environmental goals (through
incentives as opposed to regulation, for example), rather than
pitting industry, jobs or communities against the environment, as
his son has at times sought to do.

Today, environmental groups are caught in a bind between their
historical defense of an environmental policy system that they
helped create and their need to re-establish roots in communities
and workplaces so that they can expand the way issues are
defined.

Since the early 1980s, there has been tension between two
cultures among environmentalists -- one focuses on national and
global issues, emphasizing policy and lobbying, while the other
focuses on communities, growing out of grass-roots concerns.

The tension has been compounded by the rise of an
environmental justice movement that accuses the larger groups of
failing to address the unequal distribution of risks and hazards
in low-income communities. Still, these justice groups also often
tend to focus on a single issue or a problem in a single
community, without the capacity to translate those concerns into
a broader policy approach.

By the time George W. Bush took office, many groups, both
policy-oriented mainstream organizations and more grass-roots-
oriented groups, seemed to have lost some direction and sense of
purpose, necessitating an issue-by-issue, often defensive
response.

That might have begun to change. Among environmentalists,
efforts to broaden environmental agendas and create a more
appealing and community-directed vision are taking shape. In Los
Angeles, for example, coalitions among the community-based
environmental justice groups, some of the larger mainstream
environmental groups and other community advocates have formed
around issues including urban parks and open space, fast food in
schools and transportation and affordable housing. In New York
City, a grass-roots group known as Just Food has been able to
combine environmental, health, nutrition, transportation and
poverty issues as part of its organizing approach, breaking out
of the traditional definitions that have often pigeon-holed
groups and issues.

When environmental groups and their issues become rooted in
communities and workplaces, their ability to challenge Bush's
industry bias is likely to be strengthened. Instead of framing an
issue by pitting communities against environmentalists -- as we
see happening in the forest-thinning debate -- an issue can be
reframed as advocates together challenging their industry (and
government) antagonists. Right now, Bush feeds off criticism of
environmentalists as divorced from community concerns, arguing
that they care more for forest preservation than houses being
burned down from fire.

If a marriage between community and environmental advocates
can be further strengthened, Bush's vulnerability around
environmental issues might well become one of his biggest
problems during his next two years in office.

More from 6 September 2002 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/b-1447899208-1225478)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print