[b]
Partnership against poverty
Ngurah Swajaya
Jakarta
Indonesian media continuously present bleak reports on
malnourishment cases and outbreak of diseases in a number of
provinces ranging from severe malnutrition known as "busung
lapar" to the bird flu.
From January to April 2005 alone, malnutrition cases of child
under five-years old in Central Java amounted to almost 6,000
with 25 fatal victims. The number dramatically increased to reach
almost 9,000 malnutrition cases in June 2005. 90 percent of those
cases are closely related to extreme poverty of their parents.
These are examples as suggested by Prof. Jeffrey Sach in his
Millennium Project Report as "pockets of poverty" that exist
within countries or regions despite the fact of the overall
progress achieved to reach the targets of the Millennium
Development Goals/MDGs.
In preparation towards the largest gathering of world's
leaders at the United Nations in New York to review the
implementation of Millennium Declaration next September,
ministers of the Asia and the Pacific countries will gather in
Jakarta this week to attend a meeting on implementing the MDGs:
The Way Forward to 2015.
The meeting will provide a forum for an exchange experiences
and lessons learnt on challenges and opportunities to implement
MDGs and design common strategy to develop partnership and
cooperation. Why the meeting is organized? Asia Pacific is the
region that has registered a massive and unprecedented reduction
in poverty by the UN Secretary General in his recent report.
Over the past 15 years, the number of poor people in the
region has been drastically reduced. However, the number of poor
who live under a dollar a day in this region remains the largest
compared to other regions. Two-third of almost one billion poor
people in the world live in Asia and the Pacific.
The region's recorded rapid economic growth helped achieving
such progress. Thus, the overall implementation of MDGs still
reflect mix picture of both significant progress and missed
opportunities. Sustained growth in China and accelerated growth
in India, the two most populous countries in the world, are the
main reasons for the decline of the number of extreme poor in the
region.
Despite the success stories and encouraging report on the
overall progress to reduce extreme poverty in the region, a lot
more need to be done in the region in particular at the
respective national level. As to the cases of China, India and
Indonesia with their significant achievement in eradicating
poverty, however, disturbing cases of extreme poverty,
malnutrition, hunger, lack of access to basic health services,
lack of access to education still occur.
These cases happened not only in rural areas but also in big
metropolitan cities like Jakarta. The achievement of reaching the
MDGs target also varied at the sub regional levels in Asia and
the pacific. The United Nations reported that Southern Asia is
the sub-region that left behind in achieving MDGs goals,
particularly in eradicating hunger and malnutrition. The other
sub regions are relatively doing well in most of MDGs targets.
Achieving the targets by 2015, therefore, require extra
efforts by countries in the region. Dramatic scale-up effort is
critical to promote enrollment in primary education, reducing
child mortality due to malnutrition and poverty and addressing
the spread of preventable diseases. On environmental
sustainability, the region is still lacking behind compared to
other regions.
Lack of access to water and basic sanitation and affordable
energy, deforestation, air pollution requires serious action by
countries in the region.
On global partnership for the development, the level of
official development assistance (ODA) from developed countries
recovered from its decline in the 1990s to reach its record high
of US$79 billion in 2004. In addition, donors have also pledged
to raise assistance at the global level by an additional of $20
billion by 2006.
Although the increase is significant, however, the amount is
still insufficient to finance the achievement of the MDGs. Even
if the commitments pledged by donors to implement ODA is expected
to exceed 100 billion by 2010, this amount is still fall short of
the amount of financial resources as widely considered necessary
to achieve MDGs.
In this context, promoting the potential of international
trade and foreign investment is critical. Implementing an open,
rule-based, predictable, non-discriminatory trading and financial
system should complement the 0.7 percent ODA target.
Remittances sent home by migrant workers totaling an amount of
$34 billion in the year 2000 is also potential to finance the
achievement of MDGs. Micro credit initiative as launched by the
UN this year should be followed up by concrete action in
mobilizing the potential of millions of micro entrepreneurs.
As emphasized by the Millennium Declaration, one of the most
important requirements for achieving the MDGs is good governance.
Combating corruption, social justice, access to information,
democratization and promotion of human rights including
responsive and accountable government are also crucial in this
regard.
The ministerial gathering organized in Jakarta this week
should be able to consolidate countries in Asia and the Pacific
to comprehensively assess where they are in achieving MDGs. The
meeting is also expected to develop concrete partnership and
cooperation to utilize the potentials of the region. It is also
expected to come up with an outcome as the region's contribution
to the high-level plenary meeting of the heads of states in New
York.
The writer is the acting director for the UN Economic
Development and Environmental Affairs at the Ministry of Foreign
Affairs.
2. Alpha -- The "Death penalty" of religious pluralism can lead
to self-
1 x 30
The ban on religious pluralism
Alpha Amirrachman
Jakarta
A friend who is currently attending an international
conference at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) in
the U.S. sent an email. He wrote about his experience in walking
along a corridor called an Infinity Corridor which not only
functions to connect MIT's buildings but also to display a
metaphor of the long journey of prominent intellectuals in
reaching what is deemed as an "eternity".
One of the buildings being connected by the corridor is Mike
Myer Building, named after a Jewish-American entrepreneur who
built this building as a center for the study of theoretical and
applied physics. The front building is filled with pictures of
outstanding scientists such as Newtown, Faraday, Maxwell,
Rutherford and others. Under the pictures it reads a noble
acknowledgment of those scientists' earnest devotion to mankind's
civilization.
However, what made him deeply astounded and proud was the
inclusion of the pictures of Al-Hazen and Al-Jabir with their
Arabic distinct style of long beard and dress side-by-side with
other scientists. This, as the friend wrote, manifests an honest
recognition in the West that Islamic civilization has
considerably taken a role in contributing to the development of
mankind and that its contribution has also been a major
foundation of the advancement of science in Western countries.
He said that we should feel indebted that much invaluable
knowledge inherited from the golden age of Islam has been "saved"
and nurtured by the West for the enhancement of modern
civilization. At tat time leaders in the Islamic world had been
so preoccupied with amassing power, money or collecting harems,
and pampering their ego with repressive style of governance which
virtually banned free thinking and effectively halted human
civilization.
If the West had been narrow-minded, they would never publicly
admit the contribution of Muslim scholars, nor would they
gracefully display their pictures in their respected research
institution, my friend wrote.
Jurgen Habermas in Religion and Rationality: Essays on Reason,
God, and Modernity writes when reviewing Theunissen's position on
Hegel's proposition: "In such a relation one partner is not the
limit of the other's freedom, but the very condition of other's
successful selfhood. And the communicative freedom of one
individual cannot be complete without the realized freedom of all
others."
This is also the essence of "pluralism", which is irrefutably
entrenched in our diverse societies, and was also a vivid fact of
life during the era of Prophet Muhammad in Medina where people
from many different faiths lived in mutual-coexistence and with
respect of each other roles, both at individual and collective
level.
Therefore, when we discard "pluralism" on the simplistic
ground that this idea comes from the West, we don't only reject
the very fact of our societies, but also begin to deny the
existence of others, and start erecting the perilously divisive
wall between "we" and "they".
Consequently, we are steadily inserting awareness into our
psyche that we will only complete our existence and perform our
self-actualization over the subordination or even "disappearance"
of others.
What would come if this standpoint is being pedagogically
nurtured in our education institutions, particularly in religious
affiliated ones? It would come an authoritarian society that
would in due course rob the very rights of not only other groups,
but also of its own members, as we all can learn from the
Ahmadiyah's case not long ago.
More regrettably, at a time when this nation needs collective
efforts to escape ourselves from the present multi-dimensional
crisis, this seed of self-destruction of own societies which has
often been too easily translated into violent acts is now
developing before our very eyes more rapidly than ever.
Therefore, when another colleague asked for my comment on the
controversial fatwa (edict) issued by the conservative state-
sanctioned MUI (Indonesian Ulema Council) which among others
ruled that "religious pluralism" is against Islam because of it
alleged campaign for the "relative truth" -- thus
institutionalizing this seed of self-destruction -- I could only
sadly replied, "My deepest condolence for the 'death penalty' of
pluralism in our country. It is perhaps timely to throw the
bhinneka tunggal ika sloan (unity in diversity) into a rubbish
bin!"
It should be noted that when a claim that one religious
teaching is the "most truthful" and others are "less-truthful" is
seen to be exclusively endorsed by the state, an undue tension
among believers is inevitable. Already some conscientious
citizens with clear mind have rejected this bigotry, but still
this can potentially hinder the spirit of inter-faith dialog and
multi-religious education and therefore serves as a conspicuous
example of the destructive excesses of deep intrusion into the
often volatile and theologically sensitive relations in religious
life.
In short, societies need enough rooms to act upon what they
perceive as religious or spiritual duties, and it is the prime
obligation of the state to ensure that they all have equally
spacious spheres, free from any form of barriers.
The writer is a researcher at at The Public Sphere Institute.
3. Star -- Corruption is way of life in India
1 x 30
Corruption is way of life in India
Coomi Kapoor
The Star
Asia News Network/Selangor, Malaysia
India's image as a corrupt nation stands doubly reinforced.
A recent study has concluded that a staggering sum of money
is paid annually by ordinary people in bribes for various public
services.
The sample survey, India Corruption Study -- 2005, was
commissioned by Transparency International.
Its findings make for very gloomy reading for anyone concerned
with good governance and honesty in public dealings.
Quite predictably, the uniformed police force heads the list
of the most corrupt public servants. Lower courts and land
revenue administration come next on the corruption chart. Public
hospitals too are hotbeds of corruption.
Kerala, a 100 percent literate state, is the least corrupt
among the 20 states surveyed. And not surprisingly, Bihar tops
the list of the most corrupt with the national capital New Delhi
coming somewhere in the middle at number 10.
Schools, believe it or not, emerged as the biggest sources of
corruption. A huge chunk of bribes every year goes to school
managements for securing admissions or to pass examinations.
Even in the recruitment of teachers and menial staff, school
managements are known to make illicit money.
Over 14,000 respondents were polled by the survey. Nearly two-
thirds said that they had experienced corruption first hand.
Over 30 percent felt that the incidence of corruption was on
the rise. But most of them were skeptical whether the evil could
be eradicated from the country.
The findings of the survey made headlines though no one was
surprised, as Indians seem to have become quite stoical about
corruption.
Of course, ordinary Indians hold their politicians guilty for
the spread of what a leading commentator recently called "Public
Enemy Number One".
The people at large have come to believe that all politicians
are corrupt or as they put it, is hamam mein sab nange (everyone
in the bathtub of politics is naked).
One may find it hard to believe that no politician in India
has been convicted of corruption, even though it is public
knowledge that all of them barring a rare exception or two have
made tonnes of money.
India's Railway Minister Laloo Prasad Yadav is the son of a
shepherd, but he and his wife, Rabri Devi, are accused in an
Rs8 billion (RM691 million) animal fodder scam.
Their trial has been on for more than a decade without an
apparent end.
Because politicians make money, the malaise infects all
branches of government. You have the police suppressing serious
criminal cases due to political patronage or bribes. In an
illustrative case, a couple of years ago a super-rich brat mowed
down eight unskilled workers under the wheels of his BMW.
The police connived with the defense allowing the boy to roam
free, certain in the knowledge that the case against him had been
"taken care of". His father even paid off the relatives of the
deceased to ensure they do not create trouble.
To sell or buy apiece of land, house or shop, you have to
grease many palms.
Corruption has been more or less institutionalized with the
rates of bribes duly fixed.
For instance, in Delhi and most other states, there is a 1
percent under-the-table charge on the entire value of the
transaction.
Corruption is pervasive in India. Spurious medicines,
adulterated petrol, diesel, edible oils, foodstuff, fake computer
software, you name it and the unscrupulous dealer has it.
Even a well-known pharmaceutical multinational was caught only
last week for selling medicines well past their expiry date.
The short-point is that the hydra-headed monster call
corruption holds sway over every facet of life in India.
Even respected professions such as the law and media are
tainted by this disease.
After all, lawyers and journalists too belong to the same
corrupt society, don't they?
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/b-1447899208-1167601)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post