Australian Government Proposes Users Be Able to Choose Their Own Social Media Algorithms
Every Australian citizen will be able to choose whether they want their social media content to be presented via algorithms or not. This is being proposed by the Australian Government with the aim of giving the public more power in the digital world.
The Labor Party will pursue an opt-in/opt-out system. Platforms such as TikTok, Instagram, or Facebook would be required to send push notifications to account holders asking them to decide whether they wish to receive recommended content.
This social media algorithm regulation is part of the proposed ‘Digital Duty of Care’ bill, which shifts responsibility to big tech companies to proactively reduce the risk of harm, with the threat of fines exceeding AU$100 million for non-compliance. For children, the proposed obligations include issues such as bullying, pornography, misogyny, and eating disorders, while for adults, the focus is on crime, violence, and threats.
The bill, released for initial consultation this week, would allow the Australian Government to mandate that platforms provide Australians with the choice to view algorithmically recommended content or only display accounts they follow.
Australian Communications Minister Anika Wells stated that the public will be able to make this choice ‘many times’ if they change their minds. “The reality is many people will choose to use algorithms,” she said. “That is their choice. We respect that choice.”
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese stated that the new ‘My Feed, My Way’ initiative does not mean social media content is controlled by the government. “This gives control to the people,” said PM Albanese. “It puts the choice back into the hands of Australians when they are online.”
‘Some users may not like it’
As the Australian Parliament considers new rules regarding algorithms, Instagram head Adam Mosseri has warned that most users would not like what they see without algorithms. Adam responded indirectly to the government’s proposal during a rare press session on Thursday (10/09).
The event aimed to promote the new short series ‘Algo Confessions’ and the ‘Your Algorithm’ feature on Meta’s platform, which will allow users to view and even modify their algorithms.
A Meta spokesperson told journalists that Adam would not comment on the Australian government’s proposal, but he did share his views on chronological home feeds. Referring to Meta’s experience in other countries, he stated, “the average user experience becomes much worse.”
“If you switch to a chronological view, your feed will eventually be flooded with content from companies, brands, and publishers,” he said. “Content creators will be drowned out, and content from your friends will be even further submerged.”
The reason, according to Adam, is that the best way to reach an audience in a chronological view is to post content more frequently, and businesses have the capacity to post more often than regular content creators. Although he did not mention specific figures, he stated that engagement levels eventually drop by up to 50 percent.
“You miss out on much more content… and spend far less time on the platform,” he said.
For those designing these rules in Australia, the goal is for users to spend less time on social media platforms like Instagram. However, Adam emphasised that user satisfaction also declines. “We ask users every day how satisfied they are with the experience they are getting. Whether overall, ‘are you satisfied?’ or through specific questions, ‘is this worth your time?’, those numbers plummet quite sharply.”
“So, there is an interesting difference between what an individual might want and what happens when that is applied to an entire community.”
Adam stated he assumes only a “handful of very enthusiastic people” who truly want to exit the algorithm system are a minority.
Algorithm regulation in other countries
Something users rarely realise is that the option for a chronological timeline view is actually already available on Instagram globally, including in Australia. On Instagram, users can tap the Instagram logo at the top to access a drop-down menu providing a “following” setting. If this option is selected, the user’s timeline changes to a series of posts from accounts they follow in reverse chronological order, without algorithmic recommendations.
However, unlike in the Netherlands, the feed reverts to using algorithms when users close and reopen the app.
Since 2023, the European Union has implemented regulations across its 27 member states requiring large platforms like Instagram to provide users with the option for a chronological feed view. Under these rules, the choice must be easily accessible to users, rather than hidden within settings menus that many might not find.
Furthermore, in October 2025, a Dutch court took a further step by ordering platforms to provide a chronological feed as the default setting.
Pros and Cons of the government proposal
Shadow Communications Minister from the opposition, Sarah Henderson, said the opposition will review the details but feels confident that the proposed rules could be an “absolute threat to freedom of speech.” “This gives unlimited authority to the ministry to create regulations…”
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/australian-government-proposes-users-be-able-to-choose-their-own-social-media-algorithms-1789110408)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/abc-australia/d-8658263/pemerintah-australia-usulkan-pengguna-medsos-bisa-pilih-algoritma-sendiri), translated from Indonesian