Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

At Unsri Lecture, Judicial Commission Chief Discusses Dual Oversight of Judges

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Legal
At Unsri Lecture, Judicial Commission Chief Discusses Dual Oversight of Judges
Image: detikcom

The Faculty of Law at Sriwijaya University (Unsri) held a public lecture on the theme ‘The Judicial Commission as a Complement to Judicial Power in Realising Judicial Independence for Good Governance’. The lecture was delivered by Prof Abdul Chair Ramadhan, chairman of Indonesia’s Judicial Commission (KY).

According to a written statement received by detikcom on Thursday (29 October 2026), the lecture was opened by the dean of Unsri’s Faculty of Law, Prof Joni Emirzon. In his address, Joni encouraged students to make the most of the material presented by the KY chairman.

Also attending were Prof Andi Muhammad Asrun, head of the Commission’s judge recruitment division; Jonsi Afriantara, head of its general affairs bureau; R. Adha Pamekas, head of its planning and internal compliance bureau; and other KY officials.

In his presentation, Abdul Chair discussed the KY’s position and role within the concept of a state governed by the rule of law, including how it relates to the separation of powers and the independence of the judiciary and judges.

He also addressed what he called a critical problem: the dual oversight of judges by the KY and the Supreme Court (MA), which he said had led to disharmony and a lack of clear direction.

To assess the competing roles, Abdul Chair applied principles of fiqh, or Islamic jurisprudence, to determine which institution should have the dominant role. He presented the discussion in a way that students could readily understand.

He emphasised that the KY serves to complement judicial power. Although it is not itself an institution exercising judicial power, he said, it has a strategic and significant role in securing judicial independence.

“Ma la yatimmu al-wajibu illa bihi fahuwa wajib: if an obligatory matter requires another measure, that measure is also obligatory to fulfil the obligation,” Abdul Chair said.

He also used fiqh principles to explain how the dual oversight system could be resolved. The first was ‘Tasharruful imam ‘alarra’iyyah manuthun bil maslahah’, meaning that a leader’s policies or actions towards the public should be guided by the public interest.

“The public interest is the primary aim. This is consistent with the principle ‘Ad-ḍararu yuzal’ (harm must be removed) and the principle that ‘Dar’ul mafasid muqaddamun ‘ala jalbil mashalih’ (preventing harm takes precedence over securing benefits),” Prof Abdul Chair said.

“There is also the principle ‘Ad-Dhararu yudfau ‘ala qadril imkan’ (harm should be removed as far as possible, even if it cannot be eliminated entirely). Another principle states ‘Yutahammal dharar khas lidafa’ dharar ‘am’ (a specific harm or loss should be borne to avert a general harm or loss),” he added.

He said the KY’s duties and functions are intended to promote judicial independence. Achieving this, he said, requires oversight of judges, including—but not limited to—their rulings.

The second principle he cited was ‘Al wasilatu laha ahkamul maqashid’, or ‘Lil wasail hukmul maqashid’, which means that the ruling on a means is the same as the ruling on its objective.

“Ethical oversight of judges by the Judicial Commission is necessary as a means of realising judicial independence, both at the institutional level and for individual judges. It is clear that independence must be accompanied by accountability,” he said.

He described the KY’s presence as a way to balance judges’ independence with the requirement for accountability. The Commission’s oversight, he said, should help prevent judicial tyranny or abuse of power.

“This is the true significance of oversight by the Judicial Commission as a means of completing judicial power. Oversight, as a means, therefore carries the same ruling as the objective,” he said.

The third principle was ‘Al-khashu muqaddamun ‘ala al-‘am’, meaning that a specific provision takes precedence over a general one. Abdul Chair said a judge’s honour refers to the judge’s rulings.

“Honour is the first matter mentioned in Article 24B of the 1945 Constitution as something to be safeguarded and upheld. A judge’s conduct and behaviour, meanwhile, are general matters. Therefore, specific provisions must take precedence over general ones,” Prof Abdul Chair said.

“This principle is consistent with ‘lex specialis derogat legi generali’. The honour of judges, as it relates to their rulings, is specific and should therefore take precedence,” he added.

The fourth principle was ‘at-tabi’u tabi’un’, under which the status of a follower follows that of what it follows. This means that the follower has the same legal status as the thing it follows.

“The status applied to the principal also applies to what follows it. This principle is linked to the usul al-fiqh principle ‘Al-aqwa yuqoddamu ‘alal ‘adh-afi’ (the stronger evidence takes precedence over the weaker). It is consistent with the principle ‘lex superior derogat legi inferiori’,” he said.

Abdul Chair therefore concluded that the KY should have the dominant role in overseeing judges. He called for amendments to relevant legislation to strengthen ethical enforcement and eliminate the dual oversight system.

“Ultimately, the Judicial Commission serves as a counterbalance between independence and accountability. Judicial independence is an absolute requirement for good governance. The relationship between judicial independence and good governance is both causal and structural,” he said.

More from 29 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/at-unsri-lecture-judicial-commission-chief-discusses-dual-oversight-of-judges-1793235134)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8728766/isi-kuliah-umum-di-unsri-ketua-ky-bicara-soal-dualisme-pengawasan-hakim), translated from Indonesian
Print