Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Asset Forfeiture Bill: Advocate Proposes Safeguards Against Wrongful Seizure

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Asset Forfeiture Bill: Advocate Proposes Safeguards Against Wrongful Seizure
Image: detikcom

The Chairman of the Indonesian Advocates Association (Peradin), Firman Wijaya, has proposed that the Asset Forfeiture Bill strictly regulate the measure of state losses that can serve as the basis for confiscation. Firman argued that seizure instruments must not be applied excessively and raised the issue of potential wrongful seizure.

He made the statement during a Hearing Meeting with House of Representatives Commission III discussing the Asset Forfeiture Bill at the Parliament Complex in Senayan, Jakarta, on Tuesday. According to him, the bill must explain in detail which assets can be seized, their value, and the reasons for the seizure.

“There needs to be a balance; as a general rule, the seizure instrument should not be abstract in describing the assets,” Firman said. “What kind of assets? What is their value? Then, what is the nexus of proportionality? Or are there other, less severe instruments available before seizure? Because the word ‘seizure’ already creates a spectre for social and business relations. This proportionality needs to be measured.”

He stated that the seizure method must be effective in reaching interested parties. He also noted the need for clear measures in determining which assets are to be forfeited. “During discussions on calculating state financial losses in this chamber, there was also consideration of the extent of the loss or the assets deemed necessary to forfeit. Can a potential loss approach be used, or is it better to require an actual loss? Because the impact, if it is still based on estimates, means that seizure and blocking cannot be measured,” he explained.

He cautioned that the seizure and blocking of assets could have a major impact on a person’s social life and business activities. Therefore, he argued, the seizure mechanism must be accompanied by effective official notification to the interested parties. According to him, the Asset Forfeiture Bill must also regulate legal remedies for citizens in the event of a wrongful seizure. He said victims of wrongful seizure should have access to a recovery mechanism.

“Today, we prefer to position the community or a person targeted for asset forfeiture. So, there must be a recovery effort for wrongful seizure,” he said. “In the concept of state administrative law or civil law, this is actually referred to as an OOD, Onrechtmatige Overheidsdaad, an unlawful act by the authorities, including through law enforcement.”

He assessed that such an instrument is necessary so that the Asset Forfeiture Bill maintains a balance between authority and the right to privacy. He requested that the instrument be placed proportionally. “There must be a balance in procedural law or legal remedies, because a swift objection to coercive measures, appeals, and cassation often means that once a ruling is handed down, it is very difficult to recover or mount a challenge or rebuttal if a wrongful seizure occurs. This is because in any transaction, there are calculations of interest, profits, losses, and losses due to negligence, reasonable legal costs, and an effective compensation forum,” he elaborated.

“This is why we need to emphasise observing several best practices or current judicial practices; there are now sorts of compensation and rehabilitation claims by citizens who are victims of wrongful legal efforts, whether an error in law or error in fact occurred in a legal process. When a compensation claim is filed, it seems very difficult to get that compensation paid,” he continued.

Firman suggested that asset seizure should still consider the conditions of each case proportionally. He argued that law enforcement officials need to consider if the asset to be seized is the sole place of residence. “Of course, reasonable consideration is needed, especially if there are persons with disabilities, families with children, and encumbrances, particularly those involving third parties acting in good faith,” he concluded.

More from 4 August 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/asset-forfeiture-bill-advocate-proposes-safeguards-against-wrongful-seizure-1785822804)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8603557/rapat-ruu-perampasan-aset-advokat-usulkan-ini-jika-terjadi-salah-sita), translated from Indonesian
Print