Assessing the Recklessness of “America First” in the Indo-Pacific
Since the National Security Strategy (NSS) of November 2025 and the National Defense Strategy (NDS) 2026 were formally approved in Washington, DC, the illusion of multilateral cooperation in the Indo-Pacific has crumbled. US President Donald Trump has introduced the doctrine of Flexible Realism: transactional geopolitics aimed at unilateral gain, treating the domestic economy and defence as one. The region has become a key battleground, accounting for almost half of global GDP in purchasing-power-parity terms and a third of nominal GDP.
The new flat 19 per cent tariff on Indonesian products—secured through a US$33 billion Agreement on Reciprocal Trade (ART) on 19 February 2026—is concrete evidence of this approach. Using Section 301, the US pursued enforcement action based on the August 2026 report “The Great Transshipment Scam”.
China’s subsidised goods are alleged to have been rerouted through Malaysia, Vietnam and Indonesia to evade US tariffs. Under Executive Order 14411, customs intelligence uses the US Customs and Border Protection agency’s “Detective Border” AI system to conduct pre-clearance risk scoring. Importers are required to disclose their bills of materials, which must contain no components from Beijing; otherwise, containers are held at ports with no room for negotiation.
Taiwan’s position is even more precarious. The Pentagon, now using the name Department of War (DoW), has made Taiwan its highest operational priority in East Asia, aiming to secure the global semiconductor industry and lock down the Second Island Chain.
Trump, however, treats Taiwan like a customer being billed for security. Taipei is being pressured to raise military spending dramatically and forced to relocate TSMC’s advanced chip industry to Arizona to serve Washington’s self-interest.
This pragmatism has angered India. Japan and South Korea have acquiesced to pressure to raise military budgets to 5 per cent of GDP under a burden-sharing arrangement. Quad cooperation continues at a technical level: the partners have deployed maritime surveillance satellites under the Indo-Pacific Partnership for Maritime Domain Awareness (IPMDA) at the Indian Navy’s Information Fusion Centre to track shadow fleets, and held the 2026 Malabar exercise using autonomous underwater drones.
Yet the US’s unilateral decision in the middle of this year to drop “Indo” and rename its command US Pacific Command (USPACOM) was a blow to New Delhi. India is furious at feeling cast aside, compounded by H-1B visa restrictions on its technology workers and the threat of tariffs over Russian oil. It has therefore chosen to return to its longstanding doctrine of strategic autonomy.
The US is aggressively advancing its global financial architecture towards the Global South through four instruments: consolidating allies’ US$7 trillion in net foreign assets to counter China’s infrastructure; overhauling international development banks with US$1.5 trillion in assets to serve US interests; replacing traditional grants with strict trade conditions, including high-tech packages and defence purchases; and tying Global South national currencies to the US dollar to support America’s domestic capital markets while entrenching the dollar’s reserve-currency status indefinitely.
Amid this upheaval, Indonesia’s defence status was elevated to a Major Defense Cooperation Partnership (MDCP) following bilateral talks at the Pentagon last April. Jakarta has been offered asymmetric modernisation of maritime defence equipment and autonomous technology.
The Pentagon, however, is demanding that Jakarta grant its military aircraft overflight access. The government remains cautious, stressing that any commitment is non-binding and subject to domestic law. Sovereignty over Indonesian airspace and maritime areas—including during the Super Garuda Shield 2026 multinational exercise—is not for sale.
The US global strategy throughout 2026 is full of contradictions. It has lowered Asia’s priority in favour of the swift military operation Absolute Resolve in the Western Hemisphere, including the capture of Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro in January 2026. At the same time, its military has been alarmed by becoming trapped in a nine-month war against Iran, triggering a crushing Republican defeat in the 3 November 2026 midterm elections and calls to impeach Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth.
Ironically, US diplomats have opened direct channels with Beijing to divide spheres of influence. Trump and Xi Jinping agreed to launch a Super Intelligence (SI) Dialogue at their 25 September 2026 summit and to establish a dedicated AI hotline.
Behind closed doors, they have traded US$30 billion in reciprocal tariff cuts for a commitment to import large volumes of US coal. Security arrangements have advanced through a meeting of the Crisis Communications and Prevention Working Group on 2–3 November in Washington, involving DoW Director Cynthia “Xanthi” Carras and PLA Senior Colonel Wang Wei, to draft a memorandum of understanding on mitigating military risks.
Earlier, in August 2026 in Canada, PLA Eastern Theatre Command chief General Yang Zhibin and USPACOM commander Admiral Samuel Paparo aligned the operational boundaries of their combat fleets. Yet at the same time, Trump secured support from Persian Gulf states to establish technology-containment barriers using AI. The ring of chip sanctions and AI-powered underwater sensors in our vital straits is a warning bell.
Indonesia must radically overhaul its foreign policy by exploiting the economic openings in the ART. Section 3, on Digital Trade and Technology, prohibits Digital Services Taxes (DST) and risks eroding data sovereignty; these provisions should instead become leverage to compel Washington to provide concrete access to advanced technology transfers.
The military upgrade through the MDCP must be secured to accelerate self-reliance in autonomous underwater defence equipment for our strategic straits. Firmly rejecting pressure to grant overflight access is non-negotiable. ASEAN centrality must be upheld without sacrificing sovereignty. We must become self-reliant and tighten monitoring at our ports, or risk being trampled like a mouse between two fighting elephants in the global economic contest.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/assessing-the-recklessness-of-america-first-in-the-indo-pacific-1794300626)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20261110142220-14-783902/menakar-ugal-ugalan-america-first-di-indo-pasifik), translated from Indonesian