Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Assessing the Domino Effect of the MSCI Threat

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Finance
Assessing the Domino Effect of the MSCI Threat
Image: CNBC Indonesia

The commotion over a potential downgrade by Morgan Stanley Capital International (MSCI) seems to have faded, eclipsed by the issue of several police generals allegedly tapping President Prabowo Subianto’s communications. This should not cause the Indonesia Stock Exchange (IDX) and the Financial Services Authority (OJK) to let their guard down. The issue remains a serious challenge for IDX’s management.

The threat of an MSCI downgrade is relevant to the ideas of Eugene Fama, the University of Chicago economist who won the 2013 Nobel Prize in Economics. Fama developed the Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH) and helped pioneer index funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs).

The EMH approach, formulated in the 1970s, holds that share prices move randomly and reflect all available information. As a result, long-term returns for investors tend towards the market average.

An efficient market does not allow investors to seek out undervalued shares in pursuit of abnormal returns, because share prices always reflect companies’ fundamental value. This is also known as the strong-form EMH.

Capital markets and economic growth

There are several ways in which efficient capital markets affect economic growth. First, a well-functioning capital market improves the allocation and mobilisation of capital, which is a source of economic growth.

This is consistent with research by Ishak Demir of the World Federation of Exchanges (WFE), published in 2025, which found a positive relationship between the ratio of stock-market capitalisation to gross domestic product (GDP) and economic growth.

Second, efficient capital markets give companies access to financing, increase investment for business expansion, accelerate innovation and boost productivity growth. This supports economic growth and the creation of new jobs.

Third, efficient capital markets help investors mitigate risk through international portfolio diversification, by investing across markets and in different types of financial assets. Capital consequently flows to companies with the best prospects and performance, which then drive economic growth.

Fourth, experience in developed countries shows that share prices signal the health and prospects of listed companies. Efficiency in the stock market therefore gives investors an accurate signal about where to place their capital, directing it towards the best-performing companies and making them prime movers of economic growth.

The opposite has often occurred: coordinated trading has sent market participants misleading signals about companies’ actual condition. Company owners coordinate with investors to buy and sell shares in so-called “pump-and-dump” stocks, making them unusually active and pushing up their prices.

In line with the concept of herding behaviour, rising share prices prompt retail investors to buy the same company’s shares, driving prices even higher. At a certain level, affiliated investors collectively sell their holdings, causing prices to fall sharply.

This traps retail investors in the shares, leaving them able to sell only at a lower price. They may have to cut their losses by selling below the purchase price.

Demir’s 2025 study, which examined 37 countries, including Indonesia, over the past two decades, found a two-way relationship between the ratio of stock-market capitalisation to GDP and economic growth in developed countries.

In low- and middle-income countries, by contrast, the relationship runs in one direction: an increase in the market-capitalisation ratio affects economic growth, but economic growth does not lead to higher stock-market capitalisation. The study attributes this to the limited depth of financial markets in low- and middle-income countries.

Over the long term, increased market capitalisation directly affects economic growth across all country groups: low-income, middle-income and developed economies. The effect is greater in developed countries than in low- and middle-income countries.

The research also found that a 10 per cent increase in the ratio of stock-market capitalisation to GDP raises economic growth by 0.028 per cent over the long term. Conversely, a 1.0 per cent increase in economic growth raises the ratio of stock-market capitalisation to GDP by 4.0 per cent over the long term.

In line with the MSCI warning, the Jakarta Composite Index (JCI) plunged by as much as 8.01 per cent at the start of morning trading, prompting the IDX to impose a temporary trading halt. The JCI later closed down about 11.57 per cent in a single day.

Before MSCI issued its warning, Indonesia’s stock-market capitalisation stood at around Rp16,640 trillion on 19 January 2026. At the same time, the JCI reached a record high of about 9,133 points.

However, as foreign outflows from the Indonesian capital market continued, compounded by the threat that MSCI would downgrade Indonesia from emerging-market to standalone-market status, market capitalisation fell by around 44.08 per cent from its position at the end of 2025 (year to date).

In line with Demir’s empirical findings, a 44.08 per cent decline in Indonesia’s stock-market capitalisation from January to October 2026 would slow long-term economic growth by 0.123 per cent. The effect would not be immediate, but would occur after a time lag.

The MSCI downgrade threat has directly prompted foreign capital outflows from the IDX, reflected in foreign net selling of Rp3.34 trillion on the regular market.

If MSCI’s threat is carried out, potential foreign outflows from the IDX could reach around US$4.8 billion in passive funds, including ETFs directly affiliated with MSCI. A further US$15 billion in active funds could also be reversed out of the market, bringing the potential total outflow to US$19.8 billion.

The domino effect and possible solutions

A domino effect from foreign capital leaving the IDX could put pressure on the rupiah against the US dollar. The process would begin with large-scale foreign share sales on the IDX, followed by the conversion of rupiah proceeds into US dollars, putting the rupiah under pressure. The exchange rate could then fall to an all-time low of around Rp22,000–Rp25,000 per US dollar.

The next implication would be imported inflation. Many food commodities with a significant weighting in the Consumer Price Index (CPI) are imported, including beef, live cattle, garlic, industrial sugar, soya beans, wheat, onions, egg powder for the food industry and industrial salt, among others.

A weaker rupiah would also push up the prices of non-food imports, including fuel. Pressure on fuel prices would be greater because Brent crude was trading at US$102.85 a barrel on 2 November 2026.

What, then, can the OJK and IDX do to address the potential domino effect of the MSCI downgrade threat on economic growth?

First, they should consistently implement the change to the free-float requirement, raising it from 7.5 to 15 per cent. This would increase liquidity in Indonesia’s capital market, making it easier for investors to enter and exit the IDX, lowering trading costs and improving the investment climate. The availability of substantial capital would then support economic growth.

Second, they should implement rules requiring transparency of beneficial owners and public disclosure of shareholdings of at least 1.0 per cent, down from the previous threshold of 5.0 per cent. This would reduce high shareholding concentration (HSC) and make sham transactions or coordinated trading—so-called “pump-and-dump” activity—more difficult.

Third, enforcing capital-market law would improve the IDX’s efficiency and its ability to facilitate portfolio diversification and risk-sharing. This would help investors reduce portfolio volatility and minimise investment risk, supporting more efficient capital allocation and, in turn, economic growth.

Fourth, capital-market reform would improve trading efficiency on the IDX and lift the JCI. Through the wealth-effect channel, rising share prices would stimulate consumption as expectations of higher income improve. Increased consumption would boost aggregate demand and, in turn, economic growth.

Ultimately, the threat of an MSCI downgrade is not the end of everything, but a stark warning to regulators and listed companies to put their house in order. With the final decision due in June 2027, the real test for Indonesia’s capital market is not how it rebuts criticism, but whether it consistently upholds transparency and protects investor confidence.

More from 10 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/assessing-the-domino-effect-of-the-msci-threat-1794282665)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20261110094833-14-783786/menakar-efek-domino-ancaman-msci), translated from Indonesian
Print