Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Assessing the Cost of Japan's Warship Acquisition Offer

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Defence
Assessing the Cost of Japan's Warship Acquisition Offer
Image: CNBC Indonesia

Meetings between Japanese Defence Minister Shinjiro Koizumi and Indonesian Defence Minister Sjafrie Sjamsoeddin have been notably frequent in the first half of this year. After visiting Tokyo on 16 April 2026 to meet Shinjiro, Sjafrie hosted his Japanese counterpart in Bali and Jakarta on 3-4 May 2026, where they signed a Defence Cooperation Agreement. Subsequently, on 5 June 2026, Indonesia’s top defence official again visited Shinjiro in Tokyo to further discuss bilateral defence cooperation. Less than two weeks after Sjafrie’s trip to Japan, Shinjiro returned to Jakarta to meet Sjafrie and President Prabowo Subianto on 12 June 2026.

For the past decade, Japan has failed to offer defence equipment to Indonesia due to several reasons, such as high prices or equipment that did not meet Indonesia’s requirements. At the start of this decade, Tokyo was again unsuccessful in marketing the Mogami-class frigate to Jakarta because its price was not competitive compared to similar European-built warships.

Several months ago, Japan revised its defence equipment export policy, dividing export products into two groups: first, weapons such as combat systems and vehicles, and second, non-weapons such as radar. Armed with this policy, Japan is relaunching a charm offensive to market defence products with an emphasis on surface warships.

The offer of defence equipment to Indonesia is also accompanied by a planned policy change regarding defence trade affairs in Indonesia. According to the plan, starting January 2027, a position akin to an Armament Attaché will be established at the Japanese Embassy in Jakarta to handle various matters related to Japan’s defence trade with the accredited country. This new post is similar to the Chief of the U.S. Military Group at the United States Embassy in Jakarta and the Armament Attaché at the French Embassy in Jakarta. Previously, defence trade matters were handled by the Japanese Defence Attaché, a task full of challenges considering the performance of Japan’s defence product marketing campaigns in Indonesia since 2020.

Regarding Japan’s offer to export frigates and/or destroyers to Indonesia, it should be approached with caution, as there remain a number of technical matters that Jakarta, as a prospective buyer, needs to examine in depth. As is known, Japan is a new player in the international defence market and needs to adapt to market conditions. On the other hand, Indonesia must also understand the rules of the defence trade adopted by Japan, as these rules may not necessarily be the same as similar regulations adopted by other countries that have long engaged in commerce with Indonesia. There are several notes that should be considered concerning Japan’s offer to export warships to Indonesia.

To date, there is no clear information regarding the configuration of the warships being offered by Japan to Indonesia, whether for the Mogami-class frigate or the Asagiri-class destroyer. The issue of warship configuration is directly linked to Japan’s arms export policy and is not merely a technical matter from an engineering perspective. The fundamental question for the Mogami-class frigate offer is whether Japan will only sell the 4,000 to 5,000-tonne warship in hull form only, or complete with Japanese-made weapon systems and electronics. Can Japan apply the same export policy for the Mogami-class frigate to Australia when selling a similar warship to Indonesia?

Referring to the offer at the start of this decade, Japan’s export policy for the Mogami-class frigate to Indonesia was for the hull only. This condition is detrimental to Indonesia because it is not granted access to Japanese defence technology, even for an export variant. The price of a Japanese-built hull alone is already nearly equivalent to the price of a complete European-built frigate, requiring Indonesia to spend an additional cost of approximately US$500 million per warship unit to equip the Mogami-class frigate hull. There is also the possibility of Indonesia purchasing weapon systems and electronics of questionable reliability for the warship, in addition to potential subsystem integration issues.

As for the offer of used Asagiri-class destroyers, it can be confirmed that if Indonesia agrees to acquire these warships, the only remaining armament will be a 76 mm calibre cannon, as the surface-to-surface and surface-to-air missiles will certainly be removed. The reason is that both types of guided missiles are manufactured by the United States, so permission from the United States is required if Indonesia wishes to use these weapons. Can the destroyer perform its basic function armed only with a 76 mm cannon? Will the presence of the used destroyer be able to create a deterrent effect for Indonesia with only an Italian-made cannon?

In the Indonesian context, the idea of equipping the Asagiri-class destroyer with the acquisition of electronic systems and missiles from other countries needs to be anticipated. If such an idea is realised, would such an investment be commensurate with the remaining service life of the used warship? It is common knowledge that the procurement of used warships can become a gateway to unproductive spending activities for various reasons. According to a rough calculation, a minimum investment of approximately US$300 million per warship unit is required to equip a used Japanese-built destroyer with several types of missiles, and there will be additional costs.

More from 17 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/assessing-the-cost-of-japans-warship-acquisition-offer-1781671927)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20260617105139-14-743290/menakar-biaya-tawaran-akuisisi-kapal-perang-dari-jepang), translated from Indonesian
Print