ASN Salaries Are a Physiological Need and Highly Sensitive to Mismanagement
ASN Salaries Are a Physiological Need and Highly Sensitive to Mismanagement
The Psychological Position of Salaries in the Eyes of Civil Servants
The proposal to move payroll payments for state civil servants (ASN) from regional development banks (BPDs) to the state-owned Himbara banking group once unsettled BPD directors’ and commissioners’ meetings. The new circumstances will require BPDs to change their business mindset promptly.
BPDs have generally taken three approaches to the proposal. The first is to close ranks through the Regional Banks Association (Asbanda). Meetings have been held and calculations detailed, while commissioners and directors have sought to make their case to the House of Representatives (DPR) or regulators such as the Financial Services Authority (OJK), arguing that the move could destabilise BPDs and drain their funds.
The second approach is to remain calm and wait and see, recalculating how much of the ASN payroll sits in bank accounts, what proportion supports sound lending, and how the change might affect the banks’ management of high-cost funds.
The third is uncertainty about what to do. Not all directors have the access or willingness to act to forestall the policy proposal. They are aware of it, but prefer to stay quiet while urging divisions and branches to value and make good use of what they currently have. Some have also issued individual public statements calling for the proposal to be cancelled.
There is no denying that BPD directors are generally uneasy, as the change could erode a source of funding that has long provided them with fresh liquidity. Before that debate had even run its course, another proposal confused bankers: that ASN salaries—payments highly sensitive to timing and service quality—would be distributed through Merah Putih Village/Urban-Village Cooperatives, many of which are not yet adequately equipped in terms of human resources, financial governance or experience managing ASN payroll.
Monthly salaries are an extremely sensitive matter. In Abraham Maslow’s theoretical framework, an ASN’s salary is a fundamental human and employment need. For lower- and middle-grade civil servants, the needs of individuals and their families are paramount. These include self-actualisation, or at least esteem needs, and any disruption can cause psychological distress.
Sociologically and in today’s political context, this sensitivity may intersect with public anxieties over fuel shortages in some areas, peatland fires and the often-fierce activity on social media, which can target anyone indiscriminately.
The reliability of payment, punctuality, accuracy and ease of receiving salaries are fundamental—more so than the monthly salary itself. Many civil servants live on tight budgets and face monthly bills, so payments must not be off by even hours or days, let alone arrive late. A transfer of the system takes time and requires technology; it cannot be achieved simply through approval from superiors or legislation that may not reflect social realities.
Policy Is a Virtue: Implementation Requires Professionalism
Many proposals are circulating at the Ministry of Finance and other ministries involved in managing funds from the state budget (APBN), including salaries. Directors often hear about these developments only after the fact. They may have to treat the information as mere discussion, but if regulations are enacted, public unease could fuel local tensions and wider concern.
Running a modern bank requires a range of strong capabilities, substantial experience and expertise across several fields. Banking governance is not just about accounting, nor merely about lending and short-term profits, as many people assume.
BPDs should become the hubs of regional digital-payment ecosystems, covering everything from local taxes and levies to traditional-market transactions. By controlling the circulation of regional funds, they can prevent the transfer of payroll accounts from automatically draining their liquidity.
A bank leader’s role, alongside implementing strategic programmes, is to keep the institution moving forward and help it recover amid economic uncertainty. A company’s direction is guided and driven by its corporate plan, but that plan is meaningless if it does not contribute to results.
The president director must be able to steer the ship and navigate it out of a storm. A corporate plan will become ailing at its core if the board cannot mitigate risks and respond to rapid, unpredictable change.
Banking regulations, regional economic conditions and the business environment are changing rapidly and bringing substantial risks. As a member of a BPD advisory body, the author believes BPD directors must not simply continue with business as usual. They need to become an agile, capable team that can identify opportunities, manage risks and work harder.
Based on years of observation, Indonesia’s 27 BPDs are entering a high-risk era in which they must manage their internal potential while responding quickly to unforeseen external challenges.
Rapid, complex and unpredictable cyber developments, successive changes to banking regulations, constraints on state finances and fragility in the global economy all demand that bank leaders act swiftly and carefully.
New Policies Require Strategic Assessment
In recent years, BPDs have generally struggled to secure low-cost deposits from local governments. One contributing factor is the country’s unsatisfactory fiscal capacity, with spending tending to exceed revenue. Rising debt burdens are also evident in the 2025 state budget and the 2026 budget year.
For regional banks to survive, grow sustainably and remain viable, they need competitiveness and the strength to withstand increasingly serious threats and risks. Economic uncertainty and the management of public finances also require close attention, particularly as shifting new rules place a greater burden on directors to remain alert to regulation.
Implementation of the most important elements of the 2026 Financial Sector Development and Strengthening Law (UU P2SK) is not yet complete, while the Financial Services Authority is already seeking to revise the law in at least 17 areas. The stated aims are to strengthen governance and financial-system stability and support growth in the real sector. In practice, however, implementation will require coordination within BPDs and across their wider ecosystems.
The launch of the 2026–2030 Roadmap for the Development and Strengthening of Indonesia’s Banking Sector (RP3I) aims to create a healthier, more resilient, innovative, competitive and inclusive banking industry. It will require measurable implementation frameworks and discipline in carrying out the new vision.
Regional banks are institutions with extensive networks and multiple layers of oversight. Their ecosystems are more complicated than those of state-owned enterprises, as their stakeholders and shareholders are generally closer to them than to national banks or Himbara.
BPDs typically operate within one province or a group of provinces. Opening too many conventional branches risks creating operational costs, financial risks and strategic burdens. Their scale and business development are therefore not nationwide.
Alongside the 2026 amendment to the UU P2SK, proposed changes to at least 10 other laws—including the Criminal Code and legislation related to energy and minerals—make the landscape increasingly complicated.
There is, however, a positive prospect: after bankers have faced legal consequences over flawed business decisions and strategies, fairer regulations are needed. Professionals should have clear boundaries distinguishing deliberate self-enrichment through reckless decisions from legitimate professional work intended to improve a company’s performance.
The revision therefore includes elements of law enforcement and restorative justice. Without fair protection, many professionals may become paralysed by the risk of criminal punishment if a policy proves mistaken or a business incurs a loss. Yet when a company is strong, makes a contribution and performs well, few institutions offer recognition. The changes also concern the relevant institutions and the key pillars of banking: Bank Indonesia (BI), the OJK and the Deposit Insurance Corporation (LPS), whose respective roles and responsibilities should be strengthened.
Operationally, 90 per cent of BPDs are expected to go digital, or at least strengthen their applications. As commissioners, we have experienced a dark period when our digital defences were breached. Awareness, resilience, available hardware and software, internal human resources and security systems must therefore be embedded and ready, enabling BPDs at least to counter the ever-growing threat of digital financial crime.
Banking and finance are moving in several directions. One compass point is the influence of capital markets and crypto-assets. The shifting interests and stakes between issuers and investors in the trading of long-term financial instruments such as shares and bonds are a growing concern, with all the risks they entail.
The UU P2SK amendment also addresses digital crypto-financial institutions, which have become a reality in international banking and finance. BPD personnel are only now becoming familiar with crypto, which has come to their doorstep and, in some cases, entered directors’ offices uninvited.
The digitisation of recorded value using distributed-ledger technology such as blockchain is regarded in Indonesia as both an opportunity and a threat. BPDs must be robust and resilient, and able to recover quickly from any setback through sound decisions.
Growing, Deepening Risks
There is no doubt that from 2026 to 2028, before campaigning begins for the 2029 presidential election, BPD operations could face growing political risks. Banks must contend not only with traditional risks such as credit and liquidity, but also with new complexities driven by digital transformation, expanded product authority and tighter legal compliance.
Emerging banking risks that must be mitigated include cyber threats, digital resilience and operational resilience. A fragile external environment also requires compliance directors to address legal risks. BPDs must become more alert to bank recovery and resolution risks, reputational risks arising from illegal activity, and credit risks affecting small and medium-sized enterprises and the real sector.
“Resilience is the ability to cope with adversity, adapt to challenges, and bounce back from difficult experiences.” Resilience is the strength to withstand attacks. “People can survive the most challenging ordeals—some even thrive—and yet they may be unaware or unclear exactly how they got through the challenges they faced” (Neenan, 2018).
In any conditions, including a rapidly changing environment, improved competitiveness is essential for BPDs to survive and grow sustainably. Competitiveness means being able to perform better than peers or rivals and become a champion among them. The banking market is open, fast-changing and intensely competitive, with business accelerating rapidly (M. Mas’ud, 2026).
The proposal to pay ASN salaries through Himbara should be reconsidered, as ASN payroll deposits are a fundamental source of funding for regional banks’ survival. Moving them to Himbara could create volatile and unpredictable monetary and political conditions, while the limited strategic expertise of regional banking remains one of the challenges.
The government must also fairly assess whether institutions selected to distribute ASN salaries are ready. It should consider their governance, technical capacity, financial-technology maturity and ability to reach all accounts listed in civil-service records.
The proposal to make payments through Merah Putih Village/Urban-Village Cooperatives should be reconsidered and cancelled. If the paying institutions lack solidity, professionalism, experience or effective two-way communication and rapid-response systems, because their systems are not yet robust, problems could arise without control. A payment delay could quickly provoke civil servants’ anger towards the state.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/asn-salaries-are-a-physiological-need-and-highly-sensitive-to-mismanagement-1792417845)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20261019182034-14-777627/gaji-asn-physiological-need-sangat-sensitif-terhadap-mis-management), translated from Indonesian