Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

As Interest Rates Move, Islamic Banks Remain Agile Without Crossing the Line

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Banking
As Interest Rates Move, Islamic Banks Remain Agile Without Crossing the Line
Image: CNBC Indonesia

On 21 October 2026, Bank Indonesia (BI) kept the BI-Rate at 5.75 per cent but raised the Deposit Facility rate to 5.00 per cent. The reserve requirement for Islamic banks was also eased in stages, to 6.5 per cent from November and 5.5 per cent from December 2026.

The benchmark rate remained unchanged, but liquidity conditions and market return benchmarks shifted. Do these changes affect Islamic banks, whose contracts do not involve interest? The answer is yes, through the market.

However, economic effects do not automatically give banks the legal right to change customers’ obligations. Conventional banks can pass interest-rate increases on to borrowers with floating-rate loans.

Islamic banks cannot do so under contracts whose prices have already been fixed, and must not. The scope for adjustment depends on the nature of the contract: what has been finalised, what may be reviewed, and who bears the risk.

That is where Islamic banks’ strength lies: responding to market changes while preserving contractual certainty and fairness for all parties. They address interest-rate movements through disciplined risk management, not by unilaterally changing customers’ obligations.

Market pressures, contractual limits

Islamic and conventional banks operate in interconnected markets. When returns on monetary instruments or deposit rates rise, some depositors’ expectations also shift. Meanwhile, income from existing financing may not change immediately.

The pressure comes through three channels. First, changes in market return benchmarks. Second, competition to retain customer funds. Third, the pricing of new financing, which continues to take market conditions into account.

Islamic banking literature refers to this competitive pressure as displaced commercial risk. Its impact is not uniform, however, as it depends on a bank’s funding structure, customer profile and portfolio.

This does not mean Islamic banks are slow to respond. Short-term liquidity placements and the pricing of new financing can be adjusted from day one. On the funding side, profit-sharing returns on mudharabah deposits move in line with the bank’s actual income in each period, while the profit-sharing ratio for new placements can be reset to reflect market conditions.

Only obligations already agreed remain unchanged. Islamic banks can move quickly in new transactions, not by rewriting old contracts. But agility does not mean pursuing higher returns at any cost. Financing that appears promising may carry greater business risk.

Banks must remain competitive without relaxing prudential standards. This is where economics meets contract law. The doctrine of pacta sunt servanda, reflected in Article 1338(1) and (3) of the Indonesian Civil Code, states that valid agreements bind the parties and must be performed in good faith.

Islamic law affirms the same principle in a hadith also cited by the National Sharia Council of the Indonesian Ulema Council (DSN-MUI) in its fatwas: “Muslims are bound by their conditions, except a condition that makes what is unlawful lawful or what is lawful unlawful” (reported by al-Tirmidhi and Ibn Majah).

The exception is equally important: a condition that makes what is unlawful lawful is not binding, even if agreed. Market changes therefore do not justify unilateral alterations to obligations, and a clause allowing an increase to a murabahah debt remains invalid even if written into the contract.

The asset side: moving in line with the nature of each contract

For murabahah, the limit is clear: an agreed sale price cannot be increased merely because market returns rise. DSN-MUI Fatwa No. 04/2000 on Murabahah and No. 48/2005 on Rescheduling Murabahah Receivables affirm price certainty and prohibit increasing the outstanding amount through rescheduling. There is scope to adapt new financing, whose pricing can transparently take costs, risks and market conditions into account.

New prices can move; old promises must be honoured. In ijarah, flexibility lies in reviewing the ujrah, or lease payment. DSN-MUI Fatwa No. 56/2007 allows this for subsequent periods, using a clear formula agreed in the contract.

A review also requires strong indications that one party is suffering a loss; an interest-rate rise is not an automatic trigger. Customers must therefore understand the timing, calculation basis and effect on their payments.

Clauses allowing for both decreases and increases should be developed to ensure balanced adjustments. Meanwhile, under mudharabah and musyarakah, returns follow business performance rather than a promise of fixed profit.

The ability to respond to the market depends on selecting partners carefully, transparent reporting and business monitoring. Risk-sharing is no substitute for prudence; it is a reason to apply it more rigorously.

These differences between contract types should guide the use of additional liquidity generated by the easing of reserve requirements. Funds need to be deployed with regard to business viability, maturity matching and customers’ withdrawal needs.

That allows banks to act swiftly without being tempted simply to chase volume. New financing can be adjusted to market conditions and its risks carefully managed, while existing agreements continue to be honoured.

The funding side: clarifying rights and risks

The same discipline applies to deposit-taking. The distinction between “cheap” and “expensive” funds, based on the logic of interest costs, should no longer be the primary way of looking at funding. Islamic fund management must start from the nature of the contract: customers’ rights, repayment obligations, return mechanisms and the allocation of risk.

For mudharabah funds, where expected returns move with the market, DSN-MUI Fatwa No. 87/DSN-MUI/XII/2012 provides for income smoothing. The mechanism was developed specifically to address the risk of withdrawals when returns are considered uncompetitive.

Financial Services Authority Regulation (POJK) No. 4 of 2026 on the Management of Islamic Banking Investment Products provides important direction: investment products must be managed and recorded separately from deposits, including their underlying assets and the calculation of returns.

This separation is not merely an accounting exercise; it clarifies the legal relationship: which funds are deposits, which are investments, and what risks customers have agreed to bear. Bringing investors who understand the risks together with business financing could be developed as a business model.

However, the regulation does not mean that all profit-sharing financing must be funded solely through investment products. Choices must continue to take account of regulations, customer profiles and banks’ management capacity.

The POJK also requires good governance and prudential principles, assessment of whether products are suitable for customers’ profiles (Article 6(2)), and consumer protection and disclosure (Article 10). Explaining risks must not end with the signing of a form.

Customers need to understand potential returns, possible losses and whether their product is covered by deposit insurance. Willingness to bear investment risk is not consent to bear the consequences of a manager’s negligence. This is where risk-sharing acquires meaning: not as a way to shift the entire burden to customers, but as a means of clarifying each party’s responsibilities.

From rules to day-to-day decisions

When markets move, what is tested is not only a bank’s ability to price accurately, but also how it honours agreements. This issue can be viewed through Lawrence M. Friedman’s theory of legal systems in The Legal System: A Social Science Perspective (1975): the way contractual substance, supervisory structures and legal culture together shape banks’ responses to market pressure.

In Islamic banking, the substance includes regulations, fatwas and contractual clauses. The structure includes regulators, Sharia Supervisory Boards and internal oversight. Legal culture is reflected in daily decisions: whether pricing formulas are explained, adjustments follow the agreement, and complaints are handled appropriately.

All three must work together: well-drafted clauses lose their meaning if practice differs. The transition period for investment products under POJK No. 4/2026 should be used to bring these three elements into alignment.

The OJK has given existing products time to adjust, no later than two years after the regulation comes into force and/or until the end of the contract term. Changes to record-keeping must go hand in hand with risk disclosure and supervisory readiness, rather than stopping at administrative compliance.

Guardrails are not barriers

Islamic banks respond to interest-rate changes through mechanisms suited to the nature of each contract: agreed murabahah prices are honoured, ujrah can be reviewed within permitted limits, and investment risk is clearly shared with those who choose to bear it.

Success should therefore be measured not simply by matching the returns of conventional banks, but by remaining competitive through a response that is swift, appropriate and accountable. With adequate Islamic liquidity instruments, clear contractual clauses and effective supervision, banks can adjust new transactions, manage liquidity and maintain stable funding without repudiating existing agreements.

Islamic banks do not have to choose between agility and compliance. Contractual guardrails clarify the scope for action, allowing decisions to be made without sacrificing customers’ rights and trust. That is their strength: making legal discipline and Islamic principles a foundation for action, not a reason to fall behind. God knows best.

More from 25 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/as-interest-rates-move-islamic-banks-remain-agile-without-crossing-the-line-1792932691)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20261025185130-14-779270/saat-suku-bunga-bergerak-bank-syariah-tetap-lincah-tak-langgar-pagar), translated from Indonesian
Print