Are left-handed people really smarter? Here is the scientific explanation
Jakarta (ANTARA) - The notion that left-handed people are smarter than those who use their right hand has circulated for quite some time. Left-handed people are often associated with creativity, divergent thinking, and higher intelligence.
But is left-handedness actually linked to a person’s level of intelligence?
The answer turns out to be far from straightforward. A number of studies in fact show there is no strong evidence that left-handed people are generally more intelligent than those who are not left-handed.
Left-handedness and intelligence have no strong link
Left-handedness is a condition in which a person is more comfortable using their left hand for various activities. This hand preference relates to the process of brain development and the organisation of brain functions, but it does not automatically determine a person’s level of intelligence.
One systematic review and meta-analysis published in the journal Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews examined 36 studies involving more than 66,000 participants in total.
The results showed that most studies found no difference in IQ between left-handed and right-handed people. The meta-analysis did find statistically significant differences in some comparisons, but the effect sizes were so small that the overall difference in intelligence between the groups was considered negligible.
In other words, being left-handed is not a sign that a person necessarily has a higher IQ.
One reason for this may come from research attempting to link hand use with the way the brain works. Because brain functions are divided or specialised between the left and right hemispheres, hand preference is often seen as an indication of how a person’s brain operates.
The problem is that the relationship is not as simple as “left hand means the right brain is more dominant, and therefore smarter”.
Human cognitive ability is the result of many factors, including brain development, environment, education, experience, health, and opportunities to learn. A preference for using the left hand cannot be taken as a single measure of a person’s intelligence.
Another meta-analysis on the relationship between handedness and cognitive ability also found that when people were categorised simply by left or right hand preference, no consistent differences in cognitive ability were observed between the two groups.
What about creativity?
Another popular assumption is that left-handed people are more creative. This claim also needs to be viewed with caution.
There has indeed been research attempting to link handedness with various cognitive abilities, including spatial and verbal skills. However, the results have not always been consistent.
A meta-analysis involving hundreds of thousands of participants found no difference in verbal ability between left-handed and right-handed groups overall. The study in fact found a slight advantage for right-handed people in certain spatial abilities.
These findings suggest that the relationship between dominant hand and cognitive ability is far more complex than the assumption that left-handed people are automatically more creative or more intelligent.
It is worth remembering that intelligence itself is not just a matter of IQ scores. A person’s abilities can manifest in many forms, such as problem-solving, understanding information, critical thinking, communicating, learning, and adapting to new situations.
Therefore, a person cannot be judged smarter or less intelligent merely on the basis of whether they use their left or right hand.
In fact, research on crossed laterality — a condition in which preferences for hand, eye, foot, or other body parts do not fall on the same side — has also found no consistent relationship with intelligence or academic achievement.
So, are left-handed people really smarter?
There is not yet sufficient scientific evidence to claim that left-handed people are generally more intelligent than right-handed people.
Left-handedness is simply one of the natural variations found in humans and is not a measure of intelligence. There are highly intelligent left-handed people, just as there are right-handed people with high academic or cognitive abilities.
So, if left-handed people have long been said to be smarter, this assumption should not be accepted at face value. What matters more is looking at a person’s abilities as a whole, not at which hand they use most often.
Ultimately, being left-handed or right-handed is merely a physical preference — not a report card of a person’s intelligence.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/are-left-handed-people-really-smarter-here-is-the-scientific-explanation-1788749550)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5729152/benarkah-orang-kidal-lebih-cerdas-ini-penjelasan-ilmiahnya), translated from Indonesian