Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Appellate Court Reduces Nadiem Makarim's Restitution Fine to Rp 548 Billion

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Appellate Court Reduces Nadiem Makarim's Restitution Fine to Rp 548 Billion
Image: detikcom

The panel of judges at the Jakarta High Court has amended the restitution fine imposed on the former Minister of Education, Culture, Research, and Technology, Nadiem Makarim. The restitution amount has been reduced from Rp 809 billion to Rp 548 billion.

“The obligation is to pay restitution in the amount of Rp 548,761,031,950.86 (Rp 548 billion),” stated the judge while reading the appeal verdict at the Jakarta High Court on Thursday (24/09/202<0xC2>6).

Should the amount remain unpaid, Nadiem’s assets will be seized and auctioned. If the assets are insufficient, the penalty will be substituted with a six-year prison sentence. The judge added that any restitution already paid will be factored into the duration of the additional criminal sentence.

Reasons for Reducing the Restitution

The judges stated that the restitution is intended to recover state losses in this case, which total Rp 1,567,888,662,716.74 (Rp 1.5 trillion). These losses were incurred through the procurement of Chromebook laptops conducted by Nadiem alongside several other parties. The court emphasised that the recovery of state losses must not be imposed arbitrarily.

“The imposition of additional penalties must adhere to the principles of proportionality and individualisation of punishment, ensuring that responsibility does not exceed the defendant’s proven role in the criminal act,” the judge noted.

The court affirmed that Nadiem, as the minister during the project’s execution, was the primary actor and must be responsible for restoring the state’s finances to their original state. The court also stated that parties who gained illegal profits from the project causing the state losses must also be held accountable.

“The defendant, as the Minister of Education and the primary actor in the complicity of ICT procurement at the Ministry, must be responsible for restoring the state’s financial position to its original condition. Furthermore, benefiting parties such as Google, as well as principals, distributors, or cooperatives providing the Chromebook laptops, are also burdened with paying restitution proportionally,” the judge stated.

The court ruled that Nadiem is liable for 35% of the Rp 1.5 trillion loss due to his role as the primary actor. Meanwhile, distributors are burdened with 15% of the state losses.

“Google, as the beneficiary through the use of Chrome OS and CDM licences, is burdened with paying restitution amounting to 50% of the total state losses, minus the restitution paid by the accomplices,” the judge explained.

The court noted that defendants Mulyatsah and Ibrahim Arief have paid restitution amounts of Rp 2.2 billion and Rp 5 billion, respectively. The judge also mentioned payments from Harnowo amounting to Rp 300 million and Nia amounting to Rp 250 million.

Previously, the court also reduced Nadiem’s prison sentence from 10 years to 9 years. Nadiem remains subject to a fine of Rp 1 billion.

More from 24 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/appellate-court-reduces-nadiem-makarims-restitution-fine-to-rp-548-billion-1790233020)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8677030/hakim-banding-kurangi-hukuman-uang-pengganti-nadiem-jadi-rp-548-m), translated from Indonesian
Print