Appealing to the Supreme Court, Nadiem’s Legal Team Identifies Five Alleged Errors in Appeal Ruling
JAKARTA — The legal team for Nadiem Anwar Makarim officially filed a cassation appeal with the Supreme Court through the Central Jakarta District Court registrar on 16 October 2026. The appeal challenges Jakarta’s High Court Decision No. 41/Pid.Sus-TPK/2026/PT DKI in the Ministry of Education, Culture, Research and Technology’s Chromebook procurement case.
The appellate ruling sentenced Nadiem to nine years in prison, imposed a fine of Rp1 billion (with 140 days’ imprisonment in lieu of payment), and ordered him to pay Rp548 billion in compensation (with six years’ imprisonment in lieu of payment). Nadiem’s legal team says the ruling contains five errors in the application of the law.
First, the appeal ruling took too broad a view of the causal link to state losses, which it said arose from overpriced laptops. Under Presidential Regulation No. 16/2018, procurement is carried out by the Commitment-Making Officer, Procurement Officer and Working Group, while prices are set by principals in the electronic catalogue. The court nevertheless held Nadiem responsible, reasoning that the procurement would not have taken place without his policy.
“With this logic, any official who makes policy could be prosecuted over prices set by another party,” Nadiem’s lawyer, Ari Yusuf Amir, said on Saturday (17 October 2026).
Second, the appeal ruling did not establish that Nadiem had conspired or shared an intention to benefit Google. The court acknowledged that Nadiem was not directly involved in the technical aspects of procurement, but still found that he had acted jointly to benefit Google.
“The ruling does not explain how the parties shared an intention to benefit Google,” Ari said.
Third, the appeal ruling ordered compensation without evidence of assets obtained through corruption. The High Court said there was no proof that Rp809.6 billion had come from the procurement. The court of first instance also found that Nadiem had not enriched himself. Nevertheless, the state loss of Rp1.57 trillion was apportioned as follows: 35 per cent to Nadiem, 50 per cent to Google and 15 per cent to vendors, even though Google had never been examined and no trial evidence showed that it benefited.
“This ruling contradicts Article 18(1)(b) of the Anti-Corruption Law, which stipulates that compensation may only be ordered up to the value of assets actually enjoyed by the convicted person,” Ari said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/appealing-to-the-supreme-court-nadiems-legal-team-identifies-five-alleged-errors-in-appeal-ruling-1792230637)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/tn1oem487/ajukan-kasasi-ke-ma-kubu-nadiem-ungkap-lima-poin-yang-dianggap-keliru-dalam-putusan-banding), translated from Indonesian