Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Analysis by Ustazah Irena Handono: Who Benefits from the Sunni-Shia Conflict?

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Analysis by Ustazah Irena Handono: Who Benefits from the Sunni-Shia Conflict?
Image: Media Indonesia

The conflict between Sunni and Shia is often seen as an endless theological dispute. However, examining history and global political dynamics reveals that this narrative of division is far more complex than mere differences in worship practices. Ustazah Irena Handono dissects this phenomenon by highlighting its historical roots, the influence of major figures, and the parties who reap benefits from the strife.

Long before polarisation intensified, there was a time when Sunni and Shia scholars respected and inspired one another. One central figure in this bridge of thought was Sayyid Qutub, a great scholar of the Sunni Hanafi school who was active in Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood. Sayyid Qutub’s thoughts on jihad against ruler tyranny and the concept of a modern Islamic society had a wide influence, transcending sectarian boundaries. His monumental work, Ma’alim Fi Al-Thariq, was even translated into Persian and became an important reference for Shia revolutionary figures such as Ali Syariati and Ayatollah Khomeini in the lead-up to the Iranian Revolution. During that era, the ummah’s main focus was fighting imperialism and building a just Islamic civilisation. The Rector of Al-Azhar, Sheikh Mahmud Shaltut, even issued a historic fatwa declaring the Shia Ja’fari school a legally valid Islamic school of jurisprudence.

The schism we witness today began to solidify after the 1979 Iranian Revolution. This shift in the power map triggered an existential rivalry between two major powers in the Middle East: Iran, which emerged as a revolutionary Shia state with the concept of Wilayatul Faqih opposing secularism and Western influence, and Saudi Arabia, which adheres to a monarchy system with a strategic partnership with the West, particularly the United States. According to developing analyses, this tension is no longer purely about faith, but rather a struggle for geopolitical influence and power ideology. Unifying fatwas like the one issued by Sheikh Mahmud Shaltut are often sidelined for the sake of each country’s political stability.

In every conflict, there are always parties who benefit. Ustazah Irena Handono identifies four main actors who profit from the Sunni-Shia division. The solution to this tangled mess is to return to the spirit of the predecessors. Muslims need to encourage honest and deep inter-sect dialogue and not allow blind fanaticism to be used as a tool by practical political interests. Emulating the synergy of thought between figures like Sayyid Qutub and Ali Syariati in fighting tyranny is a first step to realising that the common enemy of the ummah is not jurisprudential differences, but injustice and modern colonisation that harm all elements of the nation regardless of sect.

More from 10 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/analysis-by-ustazah-irena-handono-who-benefits-from-the-sunni-shia-conflict-1781106765)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/internasional/899169/analisis-ustazah-irena-handono-siapa-diuntungkan-dari-konflik-suni-syiah), translated from Indonesian
Print