An Unsubstantiated Accusation or a Serious Issue? Trump vs El-Sayed in Michigan
JAKARTA — US President Donald Trump has again accused Michigan Democratic Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed of being a member of the Muslim Brotherhood. The allegation, made ahead of the US midterm elections, has sparked debate about claims of family ties between El-Sayed and the Egyptian Islamist organisation. El-Sayed denies any connection to the Muslim Brotherhood and says the issue is being used deliberately to attack his religious identity.
Trump made the accusation at a luncheon in the White House Rose Garden on Thursday, 15 October 2026. Forbes reported that day that Trump said he was entirely certain El-Sayed had links to the Muslim Brotherhood, although he offered no evidence that the Democratic politician was a member.
“He is Muslim Brotherhood, 100 per cent,” Trump said, according to Fox News on Thursday, 15 October 2026. Trump also questioned whether El-Sayed should be allowed to sit on the Senate Intelligence Committee if he wins the upcoming election.
“What if he becomes a member of the Senate Intelligence Committee? What do you think? That man is 100 per cent Muslim Brotherhood,” Trump said. The US president also called El-Sayed a fraud and said he wanted to visit Michigan to expose what he described as the Senate candidate’s lies.
El-Sayed, whose full name is Abdulrahman Mohamed El-Sayed, has repeatedly rejected the allegations. The 42-year-old Democrat says he has never been a member of, or had any organisational relationship with, the Muslim Brotherhood.
Old posts fuel controversy
The debate over El-Sayed’s alleged ties to the Muslim Brotherhood resurfaced after old social media posts by his half-sister, Eman Abdelhadi, circulated online. The posts discussed their mother’s activities in the Muslim Brotherhood movement in Egypt during the 1970s.
Fox News reported on Thursday, 15 October 2026, that Abdelhadi had written in 2012 about a conversation with her mother. In the post, Abdelhadi said their mother had been involved in Muslim Brotherhood activities while she was a university student.
“I just had an incredible conversation with my mother about her activities in the Muslim Brotherhood in the early 1970s when she was in college,” Abdelhadi wrote.
In another post from the same year, Abdelhadi said her family had long-standing ties to the Muslim Brotherhood. However, she also criticised the organisation’s political approach, which she said was often misguided and damaging.
The posts have since been used in political attacks against El-Sayed. Mike Rogers, a former Republican member of the US House of Representatives and his rival in the Michigan Senate race, also raised the issue in a campaign advert.
Forbes reported on Thursday, 15 October 2026, that Rogers called on El-Sayed to explain to Michigan residents his family’s alleged links to an organisation designated as a terrorist group by the US government. Rogers said the issue concerned the honesty of a candidate for public office.
“Abdul should be honest with the people of Michigan about his and his family’s ties to terrorism,” Rogers wrote on X while promoting his campaign advert.
However, the existence of his half-sister’s posts does not in itself prove that El-Sayed is a member of the Muslim Brotherhood. Forbes described Trump’s claim about El-Sayed’s membership as unsubstantiated, while El-Sayed has consistently denied it.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/an-unsubstantiated-accusation-or-a-serious-issue-trump-vs-el-sayed-in-michigan-1792104626)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/tmyyzd451/tuduhan-tanpa-bukti-atau-isu-serius-trump-vs-elsayed-di-michigan), translated from Indonesian