An independent judiciary?
An independent judiciary?
After a delay of almost a year, the Supreme Court on Tuesday
announced its final ruling in the more than two-year-old dispute
between Megawati Soekarnoputri, the ousted leader of the
Indonesian Democratic Party (PDI), on one side, and her
government-backed political rivals within the party and the
government on the other. However, those who had hoped that a
Supreme Court decision would put a speedy end to this prolonged
and enervating battle of wills between the two factions no doubt
feel disappointed.
To summarize the case in a nutshell: Megawati was ousted and
replaced as the party's chairperson by her political rival
Soerjadi in a congress held in Medan, North Sumatra, in June
1996. Though Soerjadi's leadership won the immediate recognition
of the government, Megawati and her masses of supporters
throughout the country have stubbornly continued to refuse to
accept the decision, maintaining that the 1996 party congress in
Medan was engineered by the government and pushed through in
violation of the party's statutes.
Megawati supporters sued the Soerjadi leadership in hundreds
of court battles throughout the country and in many cases
actually won. A lawsuit filed by Megawati supporters in the
Central Jakarta District Court, however, failed to yield a
decision: The court decided it had no authority to try the case
-- a decision which was later overturned by the Jakarta High
Court. The Supreme Court ruling issued on Tuesday upholds the
High Court decision -- but only to the extent that it authorizes
the district court to try the case against the Soerjadi faction.
It cannot try the lawsuit against the government, which Megawati
has accused of engineering her ouster through the Medan congress.
It is not surprising that this split decision coming from the
Supreme Court drew considerable criticism as soon as it was
announced. Even to many lawyers the decision appears to be
confusing. The Supreme Court apparently based its ruling as far
as Megawati's lawsuit against the government is concerned on
jurisprudence provided by similar court decisions in 1955, 1960
and 1971. Court verdicts in those cases were based on the
principle that courts of justice have no authority to judge
government policies. In the view of some jurists and legal
experts, however, such a consideration is glaringly outdated. Not
only is it out of step with the spirit of the times -- which
promotes democratic reform -- it is clearly unjust, since a law
issued in 1985 empowers the government to interfere in the
affairs of political parties, and hence, legal means must be
provided to settle disputes.
Be that as it may, however one looks at it, what this most
recent Supreme Court ruling seems to indicate is that the ideal
of an independent judiciary as mandated by the Constitution is
still some distance away in this country. Clearly, this is a flaw
that our legal experts, politicians and legislators have to try
to overcome without delay. To build a democratic society based on
the principle of equal justice for all -- without exception -- an
independent judiciary is an absolute necessity. Clearly, the task
that lies before us is not an easy one, but it is one that has to
be undertaken or all the talk about reform and democratization
will be meaningless.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/an-independent-judiciary-1447893297-1402367)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post