Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Amnesty: Military Trial in Andrie Yunus Case Lacks Legitimacy Without Victim's Presence

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Amnesty: Military Trial in Andrie Yunus Case Lacks Legitimacy Without Victim's Presence
Image: Media Indonesia

The Executive Director of Amnesty International Indonesia, Usman Hamid, has criticised the military judicial process in the case involving the acid attack on KontraS activist, Andrie Yunus. According to Usman, the victim had expressed refusal to follow the military justice mechanism from the outset. However, legal authorities are deemed to have only highlighted the importance of the victim’s involvement after the trial had progressed through several sessions.

“The importance of the victim’s role was only realised when the trial began. How can you bring a case in the name of a victim when the victim’s stance is such (refusal)?” Usman stated during a broadcast on Bambang Widjojanto’s YouTube channel on Monday (18/5).

He emphasised that without the voluntary participation of the victim, the legitimacy of the military prosecutor or the court to act in the public interest is questionable. “There is none (no legitimacy),” he added.

Usman also touched upon the discourse regarding the application of restorative justice principles in this case. He argued that such an approach should provide space for the victim to exercise their ‘right to refuse’ a trial process deemed unfair.

He revealed that the victim and their legal counsel are currently pursuing legal steps by writing to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court to request a legal opinion regarding the ongoing military trial process. “That is what the victim’s side and their legal counsel are working towards—writing to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court to declare a right to refuse the military trial process and seeking a legal opinion from the Supreme Court,” he explained.

In addition to questioning the victim’s position, Usman also noted jurisdictional issues in the handling of the case. He argued that the acid attack, which occurred in a public space, should be examined through the civil court system rather than the military court.

He noted that the incident on Jalan Talang, Central Jakarta, has caused public unrest and was recorded by various CCTV cameras belonging to residents and security authorities. “It happened on Jalan Talang, in Central Jakarta, in a community environment; the public saw it via CCTV, as did security authorities, traffic police, and private citizens. All of these parties are part of the general public who are affected,” he said.

Furthermore, Usman lamented that the relevant officials did not decide from the beginning that the case should be handled by the civil courts. In his view, the interests of civil society are the most impacted by this case. “The party most disadvantaged is the general public. People passing through there are now afraid; people passing by at night are afraid. Therefore, from the start, the Minister of Defence, the Minister of Law and Human Rights, and the Attorney General should have determined that this belongs in the civil courts,” he concluded.

More from 18 May 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/amnesty-military-trial-in-andrie-yunus-case-lacks-legitimacy-without-victims-presence-1780910047)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/891346/amnesty-sidang-militer-kasus-andrie-yunus-kehilangan-legitimasi-tanpa-kehadiran-korban), translated from Indonesian
Print