Amnesty Indonesia Criticises West Java Governor's Bounty Contest for Street Criminals
Amnesty International Indonesia has criticised a bounty scheme for residents who catch street robbers (begal), announced by West Java Governor Dedi Mulyadi and supported by the West Java Regional Police Chief, Inspector General Pipit Rismanto.
Executive Director of Amnesty International Indonesia, Usman Hamid, said the scheme risks legitimising vigilante action in the field.
According to him, the Governor and the West Java Police Chief must not shirk their responsibility for maintaining security and public order by asking the public to take part in tackling street robberies.
He said the Governor and Police Chief should instead focus on their actual duties: adding patrols, installing integrated CCTV, improving street lighting in robbery-prone areas, accelerating responses to reports, and thoroughly investigating networks that receive stolen goods.
“That is the job of the Governor and the Police Chief. There is no need for a bounty. The police’s advice that residents ‘may act firmly as long as no one dies’ is legally nonsensical,” Usman said in a written statement received on Thursday evening (23 July).
In his view, the logic of ‘security through bounties’ has been tested in many countries, and the results are always the same: increased violence and declining public trust.
He noted that in many countries, street crime has fallen drastically not because residents were told to take the law into their own hands, but because of investment in public transport, education and accountable community policing.
“Vigilante action can trigger serious human rights violations, including violence with fatal consequences, and violate the right to be free from torture and cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment,” he said.
Usman said street robbery is a crime often involving sharp weapons that has claimed lives among the public, including police officers.
In his assessment, involving civilians who are not equipped with security skills or special training is risky.
“The public certainly has the right to protect themselves and others from real and immediate threats. However, enforcing security and the rule of law remains the responsibility of authorised officers trained to respond to such situations,” he said.
He said the directive also contradicts the basic principles of community policing (Polmas).
Usman explained that the philosophy of Polmas emphasises preventive collaboration to identify and solve security problems together, not permitting residents to carry out executions or directly punish perpetrators.
Police regulations
Usman cited Indonesian National Police Regulation Number 1 of 2021 on Community Policing (Polmas), which regulates elements of Polmas such as detecting and identifying problems of security and public order.
“The regulation positions the community as a partner in preventing and identifying security problems, not as a party taking over the function of law enforcement,” he said.
Dedi Mulyadi had earlier explained his reasons for announcing the bounty for residents who manage to catch perpetrators of street robbery, pickpocketing, bag-snatching and other street crime.
He said the cash rewards were deliberately prepared as an incentive to make residents more active in safeguarding their neighbourhoods, not to encourage vigilante action.
Dedi stressed that rewards of Rp5 million to Rp50 million would only be given to residents who meet strict conditions. Perpetrators must be handed over to the police alive and subsequently named suspects by law enforcement.
West Java Police Chief Inspector General Pipit Rismano welcomed the bounty scheme positively.
Pipit judged that the Governor’s scheme serves as motivation for residents to participate in jointly maintaining public security and order (kamtibmas).
“Yes, we welcome it. This shows that the Governor also has the desire to motivate all residents to participate in maintaining kamtibmas,” Pipit told reporters in the Arcamanik area of Bandung, West Java, on Friday (24 July).
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/amnesty-indonesia-criticises-west-java-governors-bounty-contest-for-street-criminals-1784888416)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260724154225-12-1384561/amnesty-indonesia-kritik-sayembara-begal-demul-di-jabar), translated from Indonesian