Amnesty: Death Penalty for Corruptors Not a Deterrent, Government Should Focus on Asset Forfeiture Bill
Amnesty International Indonesia considers the death penalty not an effective solution for eradicating corruption or other criminal offences in the country. The government is urged to shift its focus to accelerating the passage of the Asset Forfeiture Bill (RUU Perampasan Aset).
The statement was made in response to Law Minister Supratman Andi Agtas, who said the death penalty can still be imposed on convicts, including in corruption cases.
Amnesty International Indonesia’s Media Manager, Haeril Halim, stressed that the Law Minister’s view is not in line with the direction of national legal reform. “The Law Minister’s statement contradicts the direction of national criminal law politics,” Haeril said in his statement on Wednesday (12/8).
Haeril assessed that the claim that the death penalty provides a deterrent effect for corruptors is not supported by strong evidence at all. Referring to a Transparency International study, countries that still carry out executions, such as China, Vietnam, and Iran, have not experienced significant improvement in their corruption eradication rankings.
Moreover, he regretted the Law Minister’s statement, which he considered contrary to the stance of the country’s highest leader. “Furthermore, the President on 6 April 2025 stated his disagreement with the practice of the death penalty, on the grounds that the sanction is final and leaves no room for correction. We regret the minister’s statement,” he said.
Rather than triggering discourse on executions, Amnesty is encouraging the government and the House of Representatives (DPR) to prioritise the recovery of state losses from corruption through appropriate regulation.
“Instead of making statements about the death penalty for corruptors, the Law Minister would do well to encourage the House of Representatives to accelerate the passage of the Asset Forfeiture Bill and ensure meaningful public participation in the deliberation process,” Haeril stressed.
He added that the return of assets resulting from corruption to the state can only be strengthened if there is a solid legal basis for asset forfeiture.
Haeril also touched on international experience, where the abolition of the death penalty often stems from the political will of a country’s leader, not merely public consensus. He cited Mongolia and Mexico as examples of countries that successfully abolished the death penalty even though their societies were initially divided.
“Because of the political will of the highest leadership, countries such as Mongolia and Mexico have succeeded in following the global trend, where the majority of countries in the world have abolished the death penalty,” he said.
Amnesty also urged the Law Minister to push for the revision of at least 13 laws and regulations that still contain the threat of the death penalty. The existence of these provisions in the Corruption Eradication Law and the new Criminal Code is considered not to eliminate human rights violations.
“The Law Minister’s excuse that the death penalty is still regulated by the Corruption Eradication Law and the new Criminal Code does not at all negate the fact that execution is an absolute violation of the right to life,” Haeril said.
Historically, Haeril highlighted that the death penalty in Indonesia is a product of a discriminatory colonial system. The Netherlands abolished the death penalty for its own citizens in 1870 because it was considered cruel, yet imposed it on colonial subjects in Indonesia three years later.
“So, does the government still want to maintain this discriminatory and racist punishment inherited from the colonial government after 81 years of Indonesian independence?” he asked.
He reiterated that the death penalty has never addressed the root causes of crime in society. “The death penalty does not bring justice or resolve the root of the problem, but rather only creates more victims,” he concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/amnesty-death-penalty-for-corruptors-not-a-deterrent-government-should-focus-on-asset-forfeiture-bill-1786539117)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/921102/amnesty-hukuman-mati-koruptor-tak-bikin-jera-pemerintah-harus-fokus-ruu-perampasan-aset), translated from Indonesian