Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Amendment to 1945 Constitution

Amendment to 1945 Constitution

From Jurnal Indonesia

The Strategic Alliance Forum (SAF) is a forum consisting of
researchers of the Indonesian Institute of Sciences (LIPI), NGO
activists and university elements who are conducting critical
study on the proposed amendment to the 1945 Constitution put
forward by ad hoc Committee II (PAH II) of the working body of
the People's Consultative Assembly (MPR).

Accordingly, SAF has conducted a thorough study on the
achievements of understanding on the finalization of PAH I of MPR
working body dated July 21 through July 23, 2000 concerning the
planned second amendment to the 1945 Constitution.

On the basis of the results of the critical study, the SAF
deems it necessary to put forward some of its thoughts pertaining
to the proposed amendment to the 1945 Constitution as follows:

1. In general, the SAF highly appreciates the PAH I of MPR
working body, which has completed the achievements of
understanding on the finalization of the planned second amendment
to the 1945 Constitution. However, the achievement of
understanding does not highly appreciate the substantial
participation and interests of the public. The reason for this
observation being that the achievements have never been discussed
again with the general public to obtain people's comments,
whereas in reality it is the people who have sovereignty.

2. The SAF has drawn the conclusion that PAH I did not use a
clear paradigm nor the framework of the theory of amendment to
the Constitution in preparing the planned amendment. Some of its
thoughts have a strong tendency to ignore reform demands.

3. The SAF discovered existing proposal elements which are
fundamentally contradictory to democratic principles. Not all MPR
members are elected directly by the people, for some of them are
appointed members. There is "discrimination" or at any rate it
does not give protection to the minority group, for example in
the chapter on human rights, the article on religion, no room is
given to spiritualism (belief in one God).

The SAF is of the opinion that the implementation of the
second stage of the momentum of amendment to the Constitution
should be carried out step by step. For this purpose, the
formulation of material that is pending and subject to revision
and postponement should be assigned to a state commission set up
by the MPR, the members of which should be independent and
nonpartisan.

One of the results of identifying the materials formulated by
the PAH II of MPR working body working body says "the
implementation of social and political functions of the
Indonesian Military and the abuse of the military as the
authority's apparatus during the sociopolitical order in
Indonesia since 1965 has brought about a deviation in the roles
of the military (TNI) and the police, which resulted in negative
development of democratic life. It is also mentioned in the
direction of policies: to remodel the Indonesian Armed Forces
into the Indonesian Military as the state apparatus whose role is
in the defense field, and the National Police (Polri) as the
state apparatus whose role is in the security field, as well as
returning the identity of TNI and Polri as part of the people".
Apparently the result of the identification is contradictory to
the formulation of the achievements of PAH I which precisely
confirms the role and position of TNI and Polri representatives
as MPR members.

ANAS SAIDI et al

The Strategic Alliance Forum

More from 12 August 2000 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/amendment-to-1945-constitution-1447893297-1305213)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print