Agriculture Minister Explains How Food Mafia Defrauds Consumers
JAKARTA - Minister of Agriculture Andi Amran Sulaiman has clarified the controversy circulating in society regarding President Prabowo Subianto’s statement about a rice milling company alleged to be raking in Rp 2 trillion per month.
According to Amran, the figure does not represent normal profit from milling operations, but rather an estimate of the value of alleged fraud against consumers through the sale of premium rice that does not meet the quality standards set by the government.
Amran stressed that the public must not get caught up in the size of the Rp 2 trillion figure, but must understand the substance of the problem the government is uncovering.
“Do not shift the issue from fraud to the issue of one mill earning Rp 2 trillion. Do not focus on the calculation, focus on the crime. This is not business profit, this is fraud,” Amran said on Thursday (30/7/2026).
Amran explained that the alleged fraud came to light after the Ministry of Agriculture tested 212 brands of premium rice on the market. The results showed that around 86 per cent of samples failed to meet premium rice quality standards.
One of the main findings was the high broken rice content, which should be a maximum of 14.5 per cent under the regulations, but in a number of samples reached more than 40 per cent, even approaching 60 per cent. Nevertheless, the products were still marketed as premium rice and sold at premium prices.
According to Amran, this practice is the same as selling 18-carat gold while claiming it is 24-carat gold. Consumers pay a premium price, but the quality of the goods received does not match what was promised. For this reason, the government views the practice as a form of fraud that must be processed legally.
Basis of the Loss Calculation
Amran explained the basis of the calculation that produced the estimated loss of around Rp 98 trillion per year. The calculation starts from the total national premium rice production, which reaches about 39.75 per cent of total national rice production, equivalent to around 12.2 million tonnes each year. Of that amount, monitoring results showed that around 86 per cent is suspected of failing to meet premium quality standards, so the volume is estimated at around 10.5 million tonnes.
Next, the Ministry of Agriculture calculated the difference in economic value paid by the public. Rice whose quality falls below premium standards is estimated to be worth around Rp 8,000 per kilogram, but it is sold as premium rice at around Rp 17,300 per kilogram. Thus, there is a price difference of around Rp 9,300 per kilogram, or around Rp 9.3 million per tonne.
When that price difference is multiplied by the estimated volume of rice suspected of failing to meet premium standards, the potential loss to the public reaches around Rp 97.7 trillion, rounded to around Rp 98 trillion to Rp 99 trillion in a single year.
“Of the total loss of around Rp 98 trillion, there is one company that, according to our calculations, is worth around Rp 2.08 trillion per month. But do not stop at that number. What must be pursued is the fraud, the corrupt actors, and the mafia,” said Minister Amran.
Amran emphasised that the Rp 2 trillion figure was not calculated based on the production capacity of a single rice milling unit, as debated by some parties. The value is an estimate of the alleged profit obtained by one corporation from the practice of selling rice that does not meet quality standards. Therefore, according to Amran, the government’s concern is not the size of business profits, but the alleged quality manipulation that harms the public.
“It is not the factory’s profit that we are questioning. What we are questioning is the fraud. The goods sold do not match the quality that the public is paying for. This is what we have reported to the Food Task Force,” he said.
Amran added that all laboratory test results along with the calculations have been submitted to the National Police’s Food Task Force to be processed in accordance with the law. According to him, the government will continue to crack down on food mafia practices that harm farmers, consumers, and the state, in line with President Prabowo Subianto’s directive to create a food trade system that is fair, transparent, and aligned with the interests of the people.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/agriculture-minister-explains-how-food-mafia-defrauds-consumers-1785401637)
Originally published by Republika (https://ekonomi.republika.co.id/berita/tizad3368/mentan-jelaskan-cara-mafia-pangan-merampok), translated from Indonesian