Advocate proposes Asset Forfeiture Bill regulate recovery for wrongful seizure victims
Jakarta (ANTARA) - The Chairman of the Indonesian Advocates Association (Peradin), Firman Wijaya, has proposed that the Asset Forfeiture Bill also include provisions on restitution for victims of wrongful seizure.
According to him, deliberations on the Asset Forfeiture Bill should not only focus on the authority of the state, but should also place the public or parties targeted by asset forfeiture as subjects whose rights are protected.
“If asset forfeiture is preliminary in nature — a process preceding the judicial process — then there must be a balance in its procedural law or legal remedies,” Firman said during a meeting with Commission III of the House of Representatives (DPR RI) in Jakarta on Tuesday.
He explained that in the concept of state administrative law, there is a principle known as onrechtmatige overheidsdaad, or unlawful acts by those in power, including through law enforcement officials.
In Firman’s view, this principle should serve as the basis for the Asset Forfeiture Bill to create a balance between the state authorities empowered to carry out asset forfeiture and the civil and privacy rights of the public.
On the other hand, reflecting on judicial practice, he assessed that objection, appeal and cassation mechanisms tend to be ineffective in restoring the losses claimed by victims of misapplied legal remedies.
He therefore proposed that the asset forfeiture instrument also regulate, proportionally, the legal remedies available to the public, particularly in cases where seizures are carried out in error.
“So there should be a remedy for wrongful seizure,” said Firman.
Beyond restitution mechanisms for wrongful seizures, he also emphasised the need for comprehensive consideration before carrying out any seizure.
According to him, the ultimate legal burden remains on the state: the applicant must prove the existence of an underlying criminal act and a substantial link between the asset and the criminal act through valid evidence, transaction analysis, income profiling, and tracing the flow of benefits.
He said the Asset Forfeiture Bill must uphold the principles of equality before the law and fair legal certainty, protection of person and property, the right to ownership, and limitations on rights established by law.
Accordingly, forfeiture can be justified for the public interest and law enforcement, but only through predictable laws, legitimate aims, fair procedures, and proportionate actions.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/advocate-proposes-asset-forfeiture-bill-regulate-recovery-for-wrongful-seizure-victims-1785840995)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5679383/advokat-usul-ruu-perampasan-aset-atur-pemulihan-korban-salah-sita), translated from Indonesian