Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Ade Kuswara Kunang Case: Two Experts Assess It Was Not a Sting Operation, but Purely a Debt Matter

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Ade Kuswara Kunang Case: Two Experts Assess It Was Not a Sting Operation, but Purely a Debt Matter
Image: Media Indonesia

A new development has emerged in the case of Ade Kuswara Kunang being heard at the Bandung Corruption Court (Tipikor).

Two experts presented by the legal advisory team expressed the view that the case ensnaring suspended Bekasi Regent Ade Kuswara Kunang and his father, HM Kunang alias Abah Kunang, does not meet the characteristics of a sting operation (OTT).

Both also questioned whether the elements of bribery in the charges had been satisfied, as the matter was purely a case of borrowing and lending, or a debtor-creditor relationship.

These opinions were presented at a hearing held at the Corruption Court of the Bandung District Court, presided over by Chief Judge Novian Saputra.

The legal advisory team presented two expert witnesses: Professor Dr Chairul Huda, a criminal law expert from Universitas Muhammadiyah Jakarta, and Professor Dr Y Sogar Simamora, an expert in civil law and the procurement of goods and services from Universitas Airlangga.

NO AUTHORITY YET

Before the panel of judges, Chairul Huda assessed that the prosecution’s charge construct portrayed the case as though it were the result of a sting operation. However, the facts revealed at trial showed a different situation.

In a bribery case, he explained, there must be a direct link between the giving of money and the official authority of the recipient.

According to Chairul Huda, such a link was not evident in this case because Ade Kuswara Kunang was deemed not yet to have the authority to determine the winner of a goods and services procurement tender.

In addition, he highlighted the fact that the giver and recipient of the money were secured at different locations.

In his view, a sting operation in a bribery case typically occurs when the handover of money takes place with the giver and recipient present at the same location.

Based on the facts of the trial, this condition was not found, and therefore the case cannot be categorised as a sting operation.

Chairul Huda also stated that seized evidence items do not automatically become valid evidence when linked to the application of Article 12A or Article 12B of the Corruption Eradication Law.

BRIBERY ELEMENTS

Meanwhile, Professor Sogar Simamora asked the panel of judges to carefully assess the validity of the loan agreement that forms part of the case. What must be proven is whether there is a strong link between the lending transaction and the goods and services procurement process.

If such a link cannot be firmly proven, he said, then the bribery element is not satisfied.

Responding to the testimony, the head of the legal advisory team for Ade Kuswara Kunang and HM Kunang, Yunaniar SH MH, accompanied by Buche Sipahutar SH, considered the testimony of the two experts to further strengthen the defence’s position.

According to Yunaniar, the legal relationship between her clients and Sarjan was a civil relationship in the form of a debt or loan, not the criminal act of bribery.

“Payment of the loan has been made in instalments,” she explained on Tuesday (14/7).

The legal advisory team then summarised five key points from the experts’ opinions, which they considered to support the defence.

“Evidence obtained in a manner contrary to the law cannot be used as the basis for conviction; the application of Articles 12A and 12B of the Corruption Law must take into account the principles of lex posterior derogat legi priori and lex mitior where there are provisions more favourable to the defendants,” Yunaniar explained.

They argued that neither Ade Kuswara Kunang nor HM Kunang possessed the authority to determine the winners of government projects. Moreover, the allegation of a directive to rig the projects was deemed not to satisfy the legal elements because the defendants had no binding authority in the procurement process.

On the other hand, the relationship between the defendants and the party who provided the money was assessed as a civil legal relationship in the form of a loan.

The panel of judges has scheduled the next hearing for Monday, 20 July 2026, with an examination agenda.

More from 14 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/ade-kuswara-kunang-case-two-experts-assess-it-was-not-a-sting-operation-but-purely-a-debt-matter-1784044237)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/jabar/berita/910963/kasus-ade-kuswara-kunang-dua-ahli-menilai-bukan-ott-murni-utang-piutang), translated from Indonesian
Print