Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Academics Warn of Civilian Supremacy as Military Development Battalion Discourse Draws Scrutiny

| Source: VIVA.co.id Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Academics Warn of Civilian Supremacy as Military Development Battalion Discourse Draws Scrutiny
Image: VIVA.co.id

Muhammad Reza Syarifuddin Zaki, a Business Law lecturer at Binus University, has highlighted the massive expansion of the military into civilian spheres. He assessed that the formation of the Development Territorial Battalion (BTP), the involvement of soldiers in food affairs, and the placement of former military personnel in civilian institutions serve as a serious alarm for democracy and civilian supremacy in Indonesia.

This warning was delivered during a public discussion titled “The Storm of the Development Territorial Battalion: Citizen Rejection and the Direction of the Minister of Defence’s Policy” in Central Jakarta on Thursday, 4 June 2026.

According to Reza, the current developing situation indicates a distortion in the governance of national defence. He stated that the military is gradually no longer being positioned solely as a tool for national defence, but is instead beginning to enter civilian spaces that have traditionally been the domain of civil society and technocratic ministries.

“The public hopes for strong civilian supremacy. However, what is happening now is that civilian spaces are slowly being taken over by the military,” Reza said, as quoted on Friday, 5 June 2026.

He highlighted the involvement of soldiers in the food, agriculture, and regional development sectors, which is deemed to be moving further away from the primary function of the TNI (Indonesian National Armed Forces) as a tool for national defence.

“The state appears reluctant to build civilian capacity. Although we were promised 19 million jobs for the civilian population, what is actually being increased is military recruitment and the development of battalions,” he said.

According to him, this policy has the potential to usurp civilian job sectors that have traditionally been handled by technical ministries, such as the Ministry of Agriculture, the Ministry of Health, and the Ministry of Public Works.

“The question is, why must the state allocate large budgets to two institutions performing similar functions? Do these sectors not already have their own civil apparatus and professionals from the start?” he asked.

During the forum, Reza also touched upon alleged corruption cases within the National Nutrition Agency (BGN) involving several former military personnel. He assessed that this incident shatters the assumption that a military background automatically guarantees clean and transparent governance within civilian institutions.

He noted that the case should serve as an important reminder that the placement of military personnel in civilian positions does not inherently bring about better accountability.

Tags: berita

More from 5 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/academics-warn-of-civilian-supremacy-as-military-development-battalion-discourse-draws-scrutiny-1780620664)
Originally published by VIVA.co.id (https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/1903434-wacana-pembentukan-batalyon-pembangunan-disorot-akademisi-ingatkan-supremasi-sipil), translated from Indonesian
Print