Academics Respond to DPR Proposal to Use Reading and Writing as Grounds for Sentence Reductions
Abdul Fickar Hadjar, an academic and criminal law expert from Trisakti University, has responded to a proposal suggesting that the literacy activities of inmates should serve as an indicator of successful rehabilitation in correctional institutions (lapas), including as a consideration for granting remission.
According to Abdul, the correctional system should not be solely oriented towards punishment. Instead, it should provide space for inmates to improve themselves and develop their abilities.
“In addition to religious lectures every Friday and Sunday, inmates are also given the opportunity to develop their interests, including writing. Therefore, I agree that literacy is one of the indicators of successful rehabilitation,” Abdul told reporters on Monday (5/10).
Abdul believes the idea aligns with the philosophy of the correctional system, which treats prisoners as inmates undergoing rehabilitation. He stated that activities within prisons should be directed towards a rehabilitative process so that inmates possess the necessary skills when they return to society.
“The system is called ‘pemasyarakatan’ (rehabilitation/socialisation) for a reason. Thus, the activity and spirit should not be about punishing, but more about rehabilitation. That is why they are referred to as inmates,” he said.
Abdul noted that the success of the correctional system on a broader scale should also be measured by the reduction in recidivism among former prisoners.
“Ideally, the function of a correctional institution is to rehumanise individuals. Therefore, the macro measure of success is the reduction in criminality committed by recidivists. This means there is a rehabilitation process taking place that continues even after they leave the institution,” he explained.
Consequently, Abdul stated that the productivity of inmates in literacy activities, including producing written works, is worthy of consideration in the granting of remission.
“It should be. In fact, productivity in writing, for example, could even become a dominant determining factor in remission,” he added.
However, Abdul continued, the implementation of such an indicator requires a clear and objective assessment mechanism. One way to achieve this would be by evaluating the actual literary works produced by inmates during their rehabilitation period.
Previously, the Chairman of Commission XIII of the Indonesian House of Representatives (DPR RI), Willy Aditya, proposed that literacy activities, such as reading and writing, could serve as an indicator of inmate rehabilitation and as a basis for considering sentence reductions.
This idea is aimed at strengthening the orientation of the correctional system, moving from merely serving a sentence to a rehabilitative process that encourages behavioural change and enhances the capacity of inmates.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/academics-respond-to-dpr-proposal-to-use-reading-and-writing-as-grounds-for-sentence-reductions-1791222741)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261005145618-12-1411818/akademisi-respons-usul-dpr-baca-dan-menulis-bisa-potong-masa-hukuman), translated from Indonesian