Academic Warns Against Ambiguous Norms in Asset Forfeiture Bill
Criminal Law Lecturer at Wahid Hasyim University, Mahrus Ali, has asked Commission III of the Indonesian House of Representatives (DPR RI) and the government to formulate clear norms in the Asset Forfeiture Bill (RUU Perampasan Aset). According to him, ambiguous legal norms carry a significant risk of triggering misinterpretation by law enforcement officers (APH) and even prompting judicial review petitions to the Constitutional Court (MK).
Mahrus considers one indicator of success in the formulation of the Asset Forfeiture Bill to be whether the law is able to withstand challenges through judicial review at the Constitutional Court once it is enacted.
“I propose that these terms be reinforced and their scope limited,” said Mahrus Ali during a public hearing (RDPU) with Commission III of the DPR RI in Senayan, Jakarta, on Wednesday (26/8/2026).
Mahrus proposed concrete steps for the DPR and the government to avoid using the phrase “sufficiently clear” in the elucidation section of the bill. He suggested that every article with the potential to create grey areas be defined in depth and explicitly.
He cited the formulation of Article 603 of the new Criminal Code (KUHP), which was previously challenged at the Constitutional Court due to the unclear authority of the institution responsible for auditing state losses. This lack of clarity arose because the elucidation did not directly state whether the auditor in question was the Supreme Audit Agency (BPK) or the Financial and Development Supervisory Agency (BPKP).
Emphasising technical details in the elucidation is considered important so that law enforcers do not have room to interpret regulations unilaterally in the field. With explicit explanations for each article, the Asset Forfeiture Bill is expected to provide legal certainty while also offering legal protection for the public.
“Perhaps it is somewhat extreme, but if necessary the explanation should be made explicit. Not merely ‘sufficiently clear, sufficiently clear’. If the norm is somewhat grey, it should be explained technically so that law enforcement officers have a standard guideline and the Constitutional Court already has a reference point when a judicial review petition is filed,” he explained.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/academic-warns-against-ambiguous-norms-in-asset-forfeiture-bill-1787761213)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/926296/akademisi-ingatkan-norma-ruu-perampasan-aset-jangan-abu-abu), translated from Indonesian