Academic: NCB Mechanism in Asset Forfeiture Bill Should Be Limited
Jakarta (ANTARA) – Budiyono, a legal academic at the University of Lampung’s Faculty of Law, said non-conviction-based (NCB) asset forfeiture should be considered only on a limited basis in the Asset Forfeiture Bill, subject to clearly defined conditions.
He said there should be a strong factual link between the assets and a criminal offence, independent judicial oversight, and a genuine opportunity for affected parties to object and defend their rights.
“We need to distinguish asset forfeiture based on a criminal conviction from asset forfeiture without a conviction,” Budiyono said at a meeting with Commission III of the House of Representatives at the parliamentary complex in Jakarta on Tuesday.
He said the bill should explicitly set out five safeguards: judicial oversight of asset freezes and seizures; clear standards and burdens of proof; notice of the right to a defence and a fair opportunity to be heard; proportionality and measurable time limits; and legal remedies for the return of assets and compensation if state action is found to be unlawful.
He added that protections should also be provided for good-faith third parties and victims of crime.
Budiyono also welcomed the prospect of forfeiting assets derived from fraudulent investment schemes, saying such assets should be returned to victims rather than the state.
Victims have so far lacked certainty in cases such as fraud involving Hajj and Umrah travel services, while the assets have instead been handed over to the state rather than returned to them.
“This concerns human rights. We appreciate the progress of the Asset Forfeiture Bill, which may soon be passed by the House of Representatives,” he said.
Budiyono also warned that family ties or personal closeness to someone suspected of a crime must not, by themselves, serve as proof that a person knew of or was involved in the offence.
“Management of seized or forfeited assets must be transparent, accountable, properly recorded, fairly valued and auditable, so that it does not create new legal problems,” he said.
He said a strong rule-of-law state must not only be able to confiscate the proceeds of crime, but also ensure that every forfeiture is legally grounded, carried out through a fair process and accompanied by accountability.
“This would enable effective efforts to combat crime without sacrificing legal certainty, property rights and human dignity,” he added.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/academic-ncb-mechanism-in-asset-forfeiture-bill-should-be-limited-1793692482)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5828459/akademisi-mekanisme-ncb-harus-terbatas-dalam-ruu-perampasan-aset), translated from Indonesian