Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

ABRI's dual function: Interference or assistance?

| Source: The Jakarta Post

ABRI's dual function: Interference or assistance?

By J. Soedjati Djiwandono

This is the first of three articles in a series on the dual
function of the Indonesian Armed Forces (ABRI).

JAKARTA (JP): The Indonesian Armed Forces (ABRI) play a dual
function which gives it both a socio-political role in the
country's affairs and responsibility for the nation's defense and
security.

ABRI has come to play a dominant role in the nation's socio-
political life as a result of their success in crushing an
attempted communist coup on September 30, 1965.

The military's rise to power did not follow the collapse of a
parliamentary system of government as in many other developing
nations, nor did it result from a coup d'etat ousting civilian
politicians from the seat of government.

In fact, under the New Order regime led by President Soeharto,
the Indonesian Armed Forces generally "co-opted" civilian
politicians and technocrats into a military-led government,
particularly those who had lectured and taught military officers
in the Army Staff and Command College.

The result was a government which lay somewhere between a
Western style democracy and a dictatorial military regime. This
situation arose, somewhat paradoxically, after the collapse of
the authoritarianism which characterized the so-called "guided
democracy" of president Sukarno, which he brought in to replace a
parliamentary system of government.

The original proponent of ABRI' s dwifungsi (dual function)
was Gen. (ret.) Abdul Haris Nasution. While Army chief of staff,
he said, in an off-the-cuff speech during a graduation ceremony
at the military academy in Magelang, Central Java, that the
position of the Indonesian National Army (TNI) was not like that
of an army in a Western country, where the military was solely an
"instrument of the government." Neither was it like that of the
armies in various Latin American countries, which at that time
monopolized political power. Instead, he said, the TNI was on a
par with other contemporary forces in society such as political
parties, and should fight shoulder to shoulder with these other
forces for the good of the people. Later on, an outstanding
lawyer from University of Indonesia called this concept the
army's "middle way".

It may be that the socio-political aspect of ABRI's dual
function explains why the New Order government became
increasingly authoritarian as time went on, or alternatively, the
military itself may have become a tool or even a victim of that
authoritarian tendency.

Whatever the case, it is clear that civil-military relations
and the role of the Armed Forces in Indonesia are pivotal to the
issue of democracy in the country.

There is no evidence that the idea propounded by Nasution had
been given any consideration during the Indonesian struggle for
independence. Nor was it developed immediately after the Armed
Forces were established. In a speech at the funeral of Gen.
Sudirman, the founder and first Commander-in-Chief of the
Indonesian Armed Forces, Prime Minister Mohammad Hatta said:

"Sudirman will be difficult to replace. For our Armed Forces,
this loss will only be overcome by strengthening their commitment
to the nation. Sow in your hearts those words so frequently
uttered by Lieutenant General Sudirman: 'The Armed Forces are the
tool of the state. The Armed Forces have no politics; the
politics of the Armed Forces is the politics of the state.'"

The late Gen. Sudirman's opinions notwithstanding, ABRI went
on to become deeply involved in politics through its Dwifungsi.

When Nasution first aired his views on the role the Indonesian
Armed Forces should play in society, the military had just
successfully restored its authority by crushing rebellions in
West Sumatra and North Sulawesi which had led to the declaration
of martial law.

Coincidentally, many members of the Armed Forces had just been
assigned to managerial positions in Dutch companies nationalized
in the confrontation with the Netherlands over West Papau New
Guinea, which was then just beginning.

Nasution also shared president Sukarno's disenchantment with
parliamentary democracy, if not for exactly the same reasons.

In fact, disappointment with the parliamentary system on the
part of the Armed Forces had grown even earlier. The military are
said by some to have masterminded the "October 17, 1952 Affair",
when a demonstration demanding the dissolution of parliament was
held outside the presidential palace.

This disillusionment gave rise to support for president
Sukarno's concept of "guided democracy", then in its fledgling
state, within the military's leadership. It is likely that
Nasution's "middle way" gave them the ideal opportunity to bring
this sentiment to bear on the nation's political landscape.

The same can be said for the presidential decree of July 5,
1959, which dissolved the Constituent Assembly and made president
Sukarno an executive president rather than a constitutional, and
thus mostly ceremonial head of state.

Sukarno then got the chance to put his concept of "guided
democracy" into practice, which in turn gave ABRI the opportunity
to play an increasingly dominant role in the nation's life. There
was thus a convergence of interests between Sukarno and the
military's leadership.

The Armed Forces opposition to liberal democracy also stemmed
from a military rejection of civilian supremacy that typically
characterizes a government of the sort that then came into
being.

During the period of parliamentary democracy in the 1950s,
ABRI was restricted to a role in defense and security and bore no
direct influence on socio-political and economic life in the
nation. Excluded from the process of political decision-making,
the Armed Forces came to feel that it was being manipulated and
exploited by the political parties of the time.

That was unacceptable to the ABRI leadership, who had fought
for national independence not only as professional soldiers, but
as an integral part of the national struggle for independence.
This they felt, entitled them to take part in subsequent
endeavors to reap the fruits of that newfound freedom.

The writer is a political observer who resides in Jakarta. The
above article is the summary of a chapter he wrote in a newly
published book entitled Civil-Military Relations: Building
Democracy and Regional Security in Latin America, Southern Asia,
and Central Europe. The book is published by Westview Press and
was edited by David R. Mares.

More from 8 September 1998 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/abris-dual-function-interference-or-assistance-1447893297-1377281)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print