A Trail of Rulings on Gibran’s Education Records
A series of court rulings has brought to light disputes over the diploma and education equivalency certificate held by Indonesian Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka.
The cases have been heard by the State Administrative Court (PTUN), the High State Administrative Court (PT TUN), the Supreme Court and the Constitutional Court.
The latest ruling was issued by the Supreme Court on Friday (30 October). It granted an appeal filed by claimant HM Subhan, also known as Subhan Palal, concerning the validity of Gibran’s senior high school equivalency certificate.
Challenges to the validity of Gibran’s education records have followed several legal routes. Here is a summary:
Central Jakarta District Court ruling
Subhan initially filed a civil lawsuit at the Central Jakarta District Court in August 2025, challenging the validity of the senior high school diploma Gibran used to meet the requirements for standing as a vice-presidential candidate in the 2024 election.
In December 2025, the court ruled that it did not have jurisdiction to hear Subhan’s civil claim against Gibran Rakabuming Raka and the General Elections Commission (KPU). The judges upheld the defendants’ preliminary objections.
“After checking the ruling, I found that it upholds the defendants’ objections, declares that the District Court has no jurisdiction to hear the case and orders the claimant to pay the costs,” Central Jakarta District Court spokesman Sunoto said on Monday (22 December).
Sunoto said proceedings at the court had concluded, leaving the claimant free to pursue other legal avenues.
Jakarta State Administrative Court rejects claim
After his case was dismissed at the Central Jakarta District Court, Subhan filed a claim with the Jakarta State Administrative Court (PTUN).
Subhan sued the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education for issuing Gibran’s education equivalency certificate.
His claim sought, among other things, a ruling that the certificate, No. 9149/D.D1/KS/2019, issued in Jakarta on 6 August 2019 by the Directorate General of Primary and Secondary Education, was invalid and void. He also asked the court to order the certificate’s withdrawal and destruction, and to require the defendant to pay the legal costs.
The Jakarta PTUN again rejected his claim. In May 2026, it declared the case inadmissible, or niet ontvankelijke verklaard (NO).
Separately, Mercy Sihombing, represented by lawyer Denny Indrayana, also filed a claim at the Jakarta PTUN challenging the validity of Gibran’s education records. Among other things, she sought the cancellation of his equivalency certificate, which was used to meet the requirements for his 2024 presidential election candidacy.
On Thursday (29 October), Indrayana withdrew the claim, saying the Education Ministry had not provided any evidence underpinning the issuance of Gibran’s certificate.
Proceedings continue at the Jakarta High State Administrative Court
Subhan pursued the case on appeal at the Jakarta High State Administrative Court (PT TUN).
However, on 12 August 2026, the PT TUN upheld the PTUN’s ruling. Subhan’s claim was therefore not granted at the appeal stage.
Constitutional Court ruling
While Subhan’s case was proceeding through the administrative courts, he, Indrayana and other applicants brought a challenge over the results of the 2024 presidential election to the Constitutional Court (MK).
The 12 applicants questioned whether Gibran met the education requirements to run as a vice-presidential candidate. They brought the case before the MK because it concerned the 2024 election results, whereas the administrative-court proceedings concerned the validity of his education documents.
On 6 October 2026, the MK declared the applicants’ petition inadmissible, or niet ontvankelijke verklaard (NO), because they did not have legal standing as candidates in the election.
Although it did not accept the petition, the MK said it had found no convincing evidence that Gibran held a foreign diploma, certificate or degree equivalent to senior high school or its equivalent. The court said Gibran had shown only a certificate of attendance.
Supreme Court grants appeal
Some time after the MK announced its ruling, the Supreme Court granted Subhan’s appeal. Subhan had continued his case beyond the Jakarta PT TUN and pursued it at the Supreme Court while proceedings were under way at the MK.
The Supreme Court ruled that Gibran’s senior high school equivalency certificate, which was a requirement for his candidacy in the 2024 presidential election, was invalid.
The ruling was issued on Friday (30 October) under case number 742 K/TUN/2026.
“Appeal granted. The judex facti ruling is overturned. The court adjudicates the case itself: the claimant’s claim is granted in full,” the Supreme Court’s website quoted the ruling as saying on Friday (30 October).
The panel was chaired by Yulius, with Maftuh Effendi and Hari Sugiharto as members.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/a-trail-of-rulings-on-gibrans-education-records-1793595214)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261102094450-12-1422181/jejak-putusan-putusan-terkait-persoalan-riwayat-pendidikan-gibran), translated from Indonesian