Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

A Suspicious Resemblance: Did Max Weber Plagiarise the Ideas of Muslim Scholar Al-Biruni?

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Anthropology
A Suspicious Resemblance: Did Max Weber Plagiarise the Ideas of Muslim Scholar Al-Biruni?
Image: Republika

When reviewing the history of social thought from Samarkand, we once argued that Abu Raihan al-Biruni deserved to be placed alongside Ibn Khaldun.

We also noted the striking affinity between al-Biruni’s method—which sought to understand other societies from within their own frame of meaning—and interpretive sociology (verstehende Soziologie), developed by Max Weber.

We did not, however, regard this affinity as evidence of direct influence, but rather as a methodological similarity reached by two thinkers who lived in different periods.

An article by Turkish sociologist Professor Mustafa Orçan, entitled Nidham Thabaqat ’India Abu Raihan Muhammad bin Ahmad al-Biruni Qabla Max Weber, takes the issue further.

Orçan compares al-Biruni’s and Weber’s views of India, particularly their accounts of the caste system.

The comparison raises an unsettling question that nevertheless needs to be asked: did Weber draw some of his ideas about India and its caste system from al-Biruni? If so, why did he never mention al-Biruni by name?

In an article for Al Jazeera, Turkish academic Yasin Aktay says that, on the basis of the information currently available, we cannot answer the question definitively with a “yes”.

Orçan does not present the matter as a proven case of plagiarism either. Nevertheless, the historical chronology, the various similarities in their thinking and the absence of any mention of al-Biruni make the question legitimate.

More from 13 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/a-suspicious-resemblance-did-max-weber-plagiarise-the-ideas-of-muslim-scholar-al-biruni-1791895904)
Originally published by Republika (https://khazanah.republika.co.id/berita/tmug1j320/kemiripan-yang-mencurigakan-benarkah-max-weber-plagiasi-ide-sarjana-muslim-albiruni), translated from Indonesian
Print