A New Chapter in Trump's Immigration Policy: Deportation via Terrorism Court
An estimated 4.5 million people have been deported from the United States since 1996. However, until this month, not a single case had involved the Alien Terrorist Removal Court (ATRC), a special court designed for the deportation of foreign nationals accused of involvement in terrorism.
Nazira Haji Zada, 47, originally from Afghanistan, resided in Texas and held permanent residency in the US. According to a statement released by the US Department of Homeland Security (DHS) on Wednesday (16/9), Zada has now returned to Afghanistan after admitting she falls under the category of a foreign national involved in terrorism and choosing not to appeal her deportation decision. Consequently, her permanent residency status in the US has ended.
“This historic case, which resulted in the immediate repatriation of the foreign national involved in terrorism to her home country, is a victory for national security and the rule of law,” said US Attorney General Todd Blanche.
However, Zada’s public defenders, Matthew Farley and Mary Manning Petras, previously stated that the case “should not be viewed as an admission of the legitimacy of this court.”
The ATRC was established as part of a series of anti-terrorism measures following the 1996 Oklahoma City bombing. The court is designed to handle non-US citizens facing terrorism-related allegations, particularly when the evidence in such cases is classified or pertains to national security.
Why has the ATRC never been used previously?
Hiroshi Motomura, a law professor at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), told DW that the Donald Trump administration appears to be using the ATRC as the latest instrument in its deportation policy.
“This is a very complex procedure. There are many other ways to remove someone from the US using the context of terrorism within the deportation process,” he said.
“From a very practical perspective, the non-use of this court for 30 years reflects the government’s view that ‘we do not need this court because we can essentially deport people without using it.’”
Prosecutors accused Zada of being the “matriarch” of a family in which two members—her son, Abdullah Haji Zada, and her son-in-law, Nasir Ahmad Tawhed—were found guilty of planning a mass shooting on Election Day 2024. Earlier this year, Blanche referred to the family as “ISIS sympathisers.”
For Motomura, an author and lecturer on immigration and citizenship, one of the primary differences between the ATRC and standard deportation mechanisms is that defendants in this process do not have the opportunity to view the evidence used against them. In some cases, their lawyers may be able to access such evidence.
Secrecy is inherent to the ATRC mechanism.
“I speculate, and I believe this speculation is well-founded, that this is someone against whom the government could not use terrorism charges or other reasons without disclosing evidence in court that they do not wish to reveal,” said Motomura.
In a statement released on Wednesday (16/9), the DHS stated it had provided Zada and her lawyers with “half a terabyte of documents,” but did not disclose the contents of those documents.
“So, they preferred to undergo a more complex procedure and disclose it privately to a judge, rather than making it potentially more open to the public,” said Motomura. “Because the procedures provided by this court do indeed require certain disclosures, but at the same time maintain confidentiality.”
The ATRC consists of five first-instance federal court judges selected by US Chief Justice John Roberts, appointed by President George W. Bush in 2005.
The government must first apply to the court and demonstrate probable cause that an individual meets the definition of a “foreign national involved in terrorism” under immigration law. The government must also explain why using standard deportation procedures could pose a risk to national security. In Zada’s case, this process took place in July.
Following this, a trial is held. In this process, the government only needs to prove its case based on a “preponderance of the evidence,” which is a lower standard of proof than is typically applied in such cases.
Zada’s decision to leave the US without undergoing a trial means the possibility of the government using the ATRC in the future remains uncertain. This is because a constitutional issue regarding the court has never been tested.
The issue of due process in the Constitution remains unresolved.
“Dragging a lawful permanent resident to court, but refusing to show them or their lawyers the evidence that will be used against them, is a clear violation of due process. We are confident that the Alien Terrorist Removal Court will be declared unconstitutional as soon as a judge is asked to handle the matter,” said Zada’s lawyer in a statement to the Washington Post.
One of the US Constitutional amendments states that the state shall not “deprive any person of life, liberty, or property without due process of law.” However, it remains unclear whether this provision applies to cases like Zada’s. According to Motomura, this ambiguity could pose a hurdle for the Trump administration.
“I am sure they are disappointed. I do not know for certain, but I would not be surprised if they are disappointed because this case was never tested in court regarding constitutional issues. Because that would have given them a different opportunity to limit the rights of people in the United States based on the US Constitution,” he said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/a-new-chapter-in-trumps-immigration-policy-deportation-via-terrorism-court-1789711154)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/dw/d-8668192/babak-baru-kebijakan-imigrasi-trump-deportasi-lewat-pengadilan-terorisme), translated from Indonesian