Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

A Moral Obligation to Protect the People from Rice Price and Quality Manipulation

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Agriculture
A Moral Obligation to Protect the People from Rice Price and Quality Manipulation
Image: detikcom

Rice quality can still be manipulated. Even state regulators have yet to protect citizens from the manipulation of the quality of rice, the staple food for around 98 per cent of households in Indonesia. The never-ending fraud in rice trade governance is also proof of the regulator’s failure to prevent public losses caused by price manipulation. That failure has caused food sector subsidies to miss their target.

Providing and serving rice of decent quality, hygienic and at a fair price must be understood and accepted as a moral obligation of the state regulator. Rice is the staple food for nearly 290 million people in this country. Rice consumption in Indonesia is among the highest in the world, reaching around 186 kg per capita per year. Protecting this staple food from quality and price manipulation must be accepted as an absolute obligation. Therefore, the food mafia must not be given access to carry out manipulation.

However, the management of rice procurement and trade, which seems never to have been effective, always presents problems. On the very first day of September 2026, at a hearing with Commission IV of the House of Representatives (DPR), the Head of the National Food Agency (Bapanas), who is also Minister of Agriculture Amran Sulaiman, revealed findings about fortified rice that does not meet standards. Fortified rice is ordinary rice to which micronutrients, such as essential vitamins and minerals, have been added and processed with food technology so that its nutritional content is more complete.

According to the Minister, results from four laboratories showed that more than 90 per cent of fortified rice did not meet standards. Monitoring of fortified rice also found that 27 out of 28 brands examined were declared non-compliant (TMS, or Tidak Memenuhi Syarat). It does not stop there: the food mafia has also manipulated the selling price to the public.

Bapanas recorded that non-compliant fortified rice reached an average price of Rp 23,385 per kg, while the comparison rice price was Rp 13,689 per kg — a difference of around Rp 9,695 per kg. So rice that should have sold at around Rp 13,500–Rp 14,000 per kg was instead found at far higher prices because of the fortification label. According to the Minister, from these findings, potential consumer losses are estimated at Rp 89.19 trillion, assuming rice consumption of 9.2 million tonnes per year.

A day after the Minister revealed the findings on fortified rice, another rice problem emerged. Trade Minister Budi Santoso on Wednesday (2/9) asked Bulog to immediately supply rice to the modern retail network because of a scarcity of 5 kg rice packs in the first week of September. To address the shortage, the Ministry of Trade has been coordinating with Bulog and retail associations.

Not only experts or food observers, but ordinary people too are puzzled, because problems surrounding rice seem endless. The issues that surface are always the same, like repeats: from the unclear market mechanism for setting farmers’ unhusked rice prices, fluctuating rice prices, scarcity, adulterated rice cases, violations of quality standards and the highest retail price (HET) rules, to other forms of fraud and manipulation.

Beyond harming the public in their position as consumers, many other parties also suffer the consequences of this chain of problems. Farmers’ welfare has not improved. Losses are also borne by various players in the supply chain, such as rice mill owners, businesses and workers in logistics channels, and traders. All these consequences are real, driven by the operations of the food mafia.

The recurring problems surrounding rice that harm the public could in fact be reduced or minimised. The rice procurement and governance process involves a number of state institutions: Bapanas, whose primary task is policy regulation; Perum Bulog (State Logistics Agency), which functions as the logistics implementing operator. Bapanas and Bulog are further reinforced by the Coordinating Ministry for Food, the Ministry of Agriculture, the Ministry of Trade, and the National Police’s Food Task Force (Satgas Pangan).

In carrying out their primary duties and functions as regulators, none of these institutions may stop fighting the food mafia. Stories and narratives about the food mafia’s operations are nothing new. As rent-seekers, the food mafia never stops seeking new methods to manipulate rice prices and quality. It is evident that after the manipulation or adulteration of premium rice was fought, another method emerged: fortified rice. Even the permits for fortified rice were manipulated, as it turns out most of it does not meet requirements.

Eliminating the food mafia is a necessity because the main aim is to safeguard food sector subsidies. Food subsidy allocations must not be allowed to keep missing their target. Manipulation by the food mafia not only harms the public, but also disrupts the state’s goal of providing food sector subsidies. As the main foodstuff, rice production is supported by several state subsidy components, ranging from fertiliser, electricity and fuel subsidies, to seeds, tractors and irrigation.

In 2026, for example, the government allocated around Rp 164.4 trillion in food sector subsidies, up from Rp 139.4 trillion in 2025. Of that amount, according to Minister Amran, the subsidies attached to the circulation of fortified rice are estimated to reach Rp 56 trillion.

To Commission IV of the DPR, the Minister assured that the findings would be followed up. Bapanas is compiling laboratory test results, completing evidence and data, and finishing the administrative process before handing over all examination results to the Food Task Force. Administrative sanctions in the form of revoking distribution permits are also being prepared for producers proven to have violated the rules.

Indonesia has achieved rice self-sufficiency and even exports rice. In 2026, Indonesia has a rice production surplus of around 3.67 million tonnes — from a projected total production of 34.7 million tonnes — with domestic consumption needs of around 31.1 million tonnes. Ideally, rice for the people’s needs should be free of problems.

In reality, the food mafia still moves freely to manipulate. The findings of non-compliant fortified rice prove that the state regulator has yet to protect citizens from manipulation of rice quality and price by the food mafia. Administrative sanctions alone may not necessarily be effective in fighting the food mafia.

Bambang Soesatyo, Member of the DPR RI and Postgraduate (Doctoral) Lecturer in Law at Borobudur University, Jayabaya University and the Defence University (Unhan).

More from 7 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/a-moral-obligation-to-protect-the-people-from-rice-price-and-quality-manipulation-1788756952)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/kolom/d-8651799/kewajiban-moral-lindungi-rakyat-dari-manipulasi-harga-dan-mutu-beras), translated from Indonesian
Print