A Mirror from a Neighbouring Nation: Six Lessons in Hajj Fund Management
For four years, a document remained tightly sealed. On 29 July 2026, the Malaysian government finally released it: the report of the Royal Commission of Inquiry into the management of Lembaga Tabung Haji (LTH).
Formed in January 2022 and completed within the same year, the commission’s report was only published by the Department of Islamic Development Malaysia (JAKIM) four years later. For Indonesia, the nation with the largest number of Hajj pilgrims in the world and managed funds exceeding Rp 180 trillion, this report is more than just news from a neighbouring country. It serves as a mirror.
From an analysis of this report, combined with Indonesian Hajj regulations since 1969, binding court decisions, and academic literature on Hajj costs, six principles of best practices in Hajj fund management can be distilled. These principles are not formulated to praise or blame any specific institution, but rather to provide a testable framework.
Ultimately, the management of community funds is a matter of institutional design, not merely good intentions. The first lesson is structural. The Commission suggested that the management of Hajj fund investments should be separated into a distinct entity named “Dana Haji”, managed by a different institution and supervised by a securities authority, with a strict condition that active politicians are not permitted to be members.
Interestingly, without ever mentioning Indonesia, the report moves towards a path that Indonesia took over a decade ago, when Law Number 34 of 2014 transferred fund management to a separate public legal entity. While Malaysia proposes separation at the internal departmental level, Indonesia achieved it at the legal entity level, representing a higher degree of separation. However, the same report warns that the root of Tabung Haji’s problems does not lie in individual behaviour.
The root lies within the legislation itself. The Tabung Haji Act 1995 grants the minister the authority to dismiss board members without the obligation to state reasons, and this authority was indeed exercised twice in 2021.
Therefore, political insulation cannot merely rely on the commitment of sitting officials; it must be embedded in the norms. Every Hajj fund management law should be tested with one simple question: If the management position were eventually occupied by someone untrustworthy, which clause would stop them?
The next lesson lies in a technical paragraph that is easily overlooked. The Commission emphasised that the audit function and audit committee must be granted the power to access all financial documents of the Hajj Fund.
Indonesia’s framework is even multi-layered, ranging from internal supervision by the Supervisory Board and external audits by the Audit Board of the Republic of Indonesia (BPK-RI) to oversight by the House of Representatives (DPR). However, the lesson from Tabung Haji is not about the existence of these layers. The question is whether these layers possess real access power and whether it is actually utilised.
The most costly issue is the use of incorrect performance metrics. The report noted that in the 2017 financial year, fixed grants were distributed in large amounts even though basic performance did not support it. When public success is measured by the size of the benefits distributed, managers face permanent pressure to maintain distribution figures, even when fund sustainability demands otherwise.
Indonesia needs to read these findings as an early warning for itself, rather than just a story from across the border. Academic data shows that the proportion of benefits within the Hajj Operational Cost (BPIH) structure increased from approximately 39 per cent in 2015 to 49 per cent in 2019, and then to approximately 59 per cent in 2022. The direction of these three data points confirms one thing.
The balance between the benefits enjoyed by pilgrims currently departing and the rights of pilgrims still waiting is a question that must be answered with a measurement framework, not with intuition. The final two lessons pertain to professionalism and transparency.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/a-mirror-from-a-neighbouring-nation-six-lessons-in-hajj-fund-management-1789027609)
Originally published by Republika (https://analisis.republika.co.id/berita/tl4ztm430/cermin-dari-negeri-jiran-enam-pelajaran-pengelolaan-keuangan-haji), translated from Indonesian