Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

A framework for East Timor's economic planning

| Source: The Jakarta Post

A framework for East Timor's economic planning

The following is the second of two articles on East Timor's
economic planning by C.G. Moghe (cmoghe@indosat.net.id), who has
worked in financial services in various countries for the last 30
years.

JAKARTA (JP): The only "leisure center" in Southeast Asia,
which can be considered competitive to Macau, is Genting Heights
in Malaysia.

Further development in Genting Heights may be difficult as a
result of imminent problems like religious inhibitions to
gambling and resistance by those who want the natural beauty to
be left undisturbed.

With this backdrop, East Timor can be really considered
fertile territory, for taking over from Macau, as the "playground
of the rich".

Main requirements would be proper infrastructure, security,
efficient police; and potential patrons among the non-Chinese
should be made to feel that they are on "neutral territory".
These are attributes which made Macau's success as a leisure
center.

The confluence of Chinese, Malay and Portuguese cultures, food
and lifestyle, would be a good draw for tourism dollars.

These centers, as big creators of jobs, will also provide the
backbone of the economic strength.

Thus East Timor could benefit from a modified "Macau Model."

Stanley Ho, a leading businessman and the present holder of
exclusive gaming licenses in Macau is said to be looking for
alternatives, since from the year 2001, the licenses will not be
exclusive anymore.

His forays in to the Philippines have not been very successful
and he can be a very useful "Uncle Ho" to revolutionize East
Timor (not in the Vietnamese style).

Under the Labuan Model, Singapore was launched as an
International Financial Center in the 1960s with the sole idea to
fill the time gap between the United States' West Coast and
Europe -- the basis of the success of Tokyo and Hong Kong -- for
conducting international money/exchange market transactions 24
hours a day.

Malaysia launched Labuan as a competitor for both Hong Kong
and Singapore (with attractive tax benefits thrown in) for the
same purpose of plugging a gap in the time zones.

Although Labuan has not really attained the same status as
Hong Kong or Singapore for various reasons, the idea to attract
some of the over flows from Hong Kong/Singapore in to a new
Center can still be a feasible proposition.

East Timor, after studying the shortcomings of Labuan, can
formulate its own plans to attract the "Gnomes of Hong Kong and
Singapore" to count their money (tax-free).

They can either be physically in East Timor (when they can
also enjoy the benefits of the Macau Model) or through a "Brass
Plate" office a la' Grand Cayman or Bahamas.

This will be however a very tricky model, considering the
stance now taken by the developed countries against the tax
havens, which are seen by the developing countries as
repositories for ill-gotten wealth such as drug money.

Under the "Free Zone" Model, the United Arab Emirates, as
well as Singapore, are countries with limited physical resources,
but with excellent port facilities.

Both chose to be a hub for the regional distribution of third
country products using their thriving ports as the nucleus for
several related activities.

Managing the port, coupled with the related warehousing,
transporting, and repackaging provided jobs, revenues and related
business spending, of much more stable nature compared to other
industries like oil, albeit on a somewhat smaller scale.

Provided the goods can enter and leave the country free from
the hassles of taxes and customs, such a redistribution center
can be successful.

Then there is the model of the "South Pacific Islands". Many
of the Islands have tried to distinguish themselves by offering
some thing unique and therefore saleable, including hi-tech
products such as choice web addresses, satellite transponders;
bandwidths or more mundane items like postal stamps for
philatelists.

Again the cultural mix in East Timor. Partly European and
partly Asian can be very attractive worldwide commodity, if
properly packaged.

The above models essentially aim for meeting the needs of
parties from outside East Timor so that they can boost its
economy and provide jobs.

The facility users may have several alternatives than coming
to East Timor. In the absence of such varied economic activities,
East Timor carries the same risks as Brunei, now seeking
alternatives to its over dependence on the oil industry.

Each of the above models calls for investment, trained
manpower and service orientation.

A clean administration, strong legal system and above all the
ability to generate confidence in the government, will add to the
desire of investors to develop and use these facilities, without
which none of these models can succeed.

Natural gas and oil reserves in the Timor Strait can be a
source for immense riches. It is however possible that the
balance of power between East Timor, Indonesia and Australia, who
together must decide on how to share the riches, may not be in
favor of East Timor.

The initial experience of many newcomers to the oil industry,
e.g. the Arab countries, Malaysia, was that they had to pay an
enormous price to learn the business from scratch, delaying
developments in other areas of their economy.

Careful integrated planning is therefore necessary for East
Timor to be an economic reality, although the country will very
soon be a political reality.

The Asians generally used to believe that the God already
provides for anyone brought in to this world.

With this in mind, East Timor may always look to members of
the United Nations, many of which acted as the nursemaid when the
referendum for integration or separation from Indonesia was in
progress -- who thus carry some responsibility for East Timor's
sustenance, at least for some time.

More from 22 February 2001 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/a-framework-for-east-timors-economic-planning-1447893297-1090873)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print