A Direct Blow to Netanyahu: Iran Endures, Trump Reverses Course
A provisional agreement between the United States and Iran to end a war that has lasted nearly four months is assessed to not only shake Israel’s strategy towards Tehran but also potentially destroy the political foundation built by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu over several decades.
According to Reuters on Thursday (25/6/2025), several analysts, former US officials, and diplomats believe the greatest casualty of the US-Iran deal might not be Israel’s strategy against Iran, but rather Netanyahu’s political image as a leader capable of bending Washington’s policy to suit his interests regarding Iran.
For years, Netanyahu built his political identity on the claim that he was the only Israeli leader capable of maintaining strategic alignment between the US and Israel regarding Iran. By building close ties with the Republican Party, Netanyahu positioned himself as a figure who could influence US presidents across various administrations.
He consistently asserted that only sustained military pressure could restrain Tehran’s ambitions. At the height of his influence, diplomats even dubbed him the ‘American whisperer’—an Israeli leader who could simply pick up the phone to ensure Washington’s strategic calculations aligned with Israel’s interests. No other Israeli Prime Minister has addressed the US Congress as frequently or built such significant political capital within the American political system.
However, according to analysts, the provisional agreement reached by Washington and Tehran to end the war, which began via US and Israeli actions last February, indicates that this narrative has now reversed. Instead of shaping Washington’s policy towards Iran, Netanyahu is now seen as being forced to accept the policy direction determined by US President Donald Trump, who is increasingly pushing for a diplomatic resolution and viewing Israeli objections as an obstacle to be managed.
Within Israel, Netanyahu’s situation is also assessed to be becoming increasingly difficult. Former US official Dennis Ross stated that Netanyahu is now caught between President Trump, who wishes to end the conflict, and his domestic political base, which rejects various forms of concessions, particularly regarding Lebanon.
According to Ross, if Netanyahu chooses to withdraw from the conflict, he risks facing political backlash at home. Conversely, if he chooses to escalate, he faces the potential for direct confrontation with Washington.
A war that Netanyahu initially hoped would strengthen his legacy as a leader confronting Iran may instead be remembered as the conflict that dismantled one of his primary sources of political power. Internationally isolated, constrained by his closest allies, and facing an election this coming autumn, the political assets that have long sustained Netanyahu’s career are now being described as his greatest burden.
At the start of the war against Iran, Netanyahu promised an absolute victory. However, to date, he is judged to have failed to realise the collapse of the Iranian government system, failed to defeat Hezbollah in Lebanon, and has not yet been able to guarantee the safe return of Israeli citizens living in the northern regions of the country.
Netanyahu’s former advisor, Aviv Bushinsky, believes the impact of the deal is immense for the Prime Minister’s political position. “The US-Iran agreement is a severe blow to Netanyahu,” said Bushinsky. “He has not only lost the war against Iran, but he has also lost Trump as a friend. He is now not only internationally isolated but also trapped in a major dispute with Trump.”
In a press conference this month, Netanyahu described his relationship with Trump as that of two partners who “often agree and sometimes disagree.” He also claimed there has been a systematic campaign aimed at downplaying what he called Israel’s “great achievements” against Iran and its allied groups.
Meanwhile, a White House official asserted that the relationship between Trump and Netanyahu remains strong. The official stated that the Israeli military forces are an “extraordinary partner” in a war that has “destroyed the military capabilities of the Iranian regime.”
Analysts, however, assess that the divergence between Trump and Netanyahu is no longer merely a matter of personal relationship, but a clearer difference in strategic objectives. Trump is seeking to end US involvement in Middle Eastern conflicts, while Netanyahu continues to view sustained pressure on Iran and Hezbollah as vital for Israel’s security. Washington is known to have negotiated directly with Tehran, incorporating the Lebanon conflict into a broader negotiating framework and establishing mechanisms for ceasefire dispute resolution.
According to three regional diplomatic sources, these steps are increasingly sidelining Israel from several key decisions. The nation that previously viewed Netanyahu as an irreplaceable intermediary now, according to these sources, is beginning to see him as an obstacle to the agreements Washington wishes to maintain.
Trump has also openly criticised Israeli military operations in Lebanon on several occasions. US Vice President JD Vance even emphasised that the US-Israel relationship has certain limits. He warned critics of the deal in Israel not to “attack the only strong ally they still have in the world.”
Nevertheless, two Israeli officials familiar with Netanyahu’s views stated that the Prime Minister is not overly concerned that the comments from Trump and Vance will lead to concrete policy changes, such as delays in arms shipments to Israel, even as military operations in Lebanon continue. Trump himself has shown a willingness to set aside…
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/a-direct-blow-to-netanyahu-iran-endures-trump-reverses-course-1782348650)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20260625062620-4-745517/pukulan-telak-untuk-netanyahu-iran-bertahan-trump-berbalik-arah), translated from Indonesian