A Collision That Remains in the Memory: Two Aircraft Collided Mid-Air After a Misunderstanding
One aircraft collision will remain etched in the memory of people in Germany: the 2002 mid-air crash in the skies over Überlingen.
According to the official investigation by the German Federal Bureau of Aircraft Accident Investigation (BFU), the collision occurred at 21:35 local time on 1 July 2002, north of Überlingen, near Lake Constance (Bodensee), Germany.
The aircraft involved were a Tupolev TU154M passenger charter flight from Moscow, Russia, to Barcelona, Spain, and a Boeing B757-200 cargo flight from Bergamo, Italy, to Brussels, Belgium.
Both aircraft were flying under instrument flight rules (IFR) and were under the control of the Swiss air traffic control centre, ACC Zurich, at cruising altitude FL 360 (about 36,000 feet).
Initially, they were converging on perpendicular crossing paths at the same altitude. The collision-avoidance systems in both cockpits (TCAS) then issued initial alerts. The Zurich air traffic controller only realised the risk of a collision later and issued an emergency instruction for the TU154M crew to descend to FL 350. The instruction was misunderstood.
It was already too late. The aircraft collided at an altitude of 34,890 feet. The Boeing’s vertical tail struck the Tupolev’s left wing and fuselage. The Tupolev broke apart in mid-air, while the Boeing lost control of its tail and plunged into a forested area near Überlingen.
The crash claimed 71 lives. There were no survivors aboard either aircraft.
The 69 people killed on the Tupolev comprised nine crew members and 60 passengers. The two fatalities aboard the Boeing B757-200 were its cargo pilots.
Causes of the crash
The BFU’s official report divided the causes into direct and systemic factors.
The direct cause was that the Zurich air traffic controller was late in recognising the risk of a conflict between the aircraft. The instruction for the TU154M to descend was issued when a safe separation between the aircraft could no longer be guaranteed.
The TU154M crew chose to follow the air traffic control instruction to descend and continued descending even though the cockpit’s TCAS system instructed them to climb.
The second cause was systemic: the integration of the TCAS II system into international aviation had not been fully completed.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/a-collision-that-remains-in-the-memory-two-aircraft-collided-mid-air-after-a-misunderstanding-1791719506)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8702382/melekat-di-ingatan-2-pesawat-tabrakan-di-udara-gara-gara-salah-paham), translated from Indonesian