A Bureaucratic Culture of ‘Looking Busy’ Is Not Enough
“State officials are the frontline of public service.”
We may often hear this phrase. Yet behind its simple wording lies a much deeper meaning: how the state is present in people’s lives and how they experience it.
In everyday life, people encounter the state most often through officials who provide services, implement government programmes, manage policies and make decisions that directly affect the public. It is undeniable, therefore, that the quality of the civil service ultimately determines the quality of the state’s presence, including whether the government’s priority programmes are successfully delivered.
Two years have now passed since President Prabowo Subianto took his oath of office on 20 October 2024. Two years is certainly not a short time. During this period, the government has faced various challenges, from global economic uncertainty and shifts in the geopolitical landscape to a range of domestic issues requiring policy responses that are swift, precise and measured.
Two years in office is also enough time to begin assessing how a political vision is translated into public policy. A government’s success is measured not simply by the number of programmes it formulates, but by its ability to turn its political agenda into policies with a clear direction, budgetary support, implementation mechanisms and an impact that people can feel.
A Bureaucracy That Delivers
At every stage of public policymaking, civil servants occupy an irreplaceable position. When a government priority is formulated, it is supported by a lengthy technical process: planning, drafting regulations, budgeting, coordination between agencies, programme implementation, oversight and evaluation.
Even after a policy has been adopted, the bureaucracy’s work is not over. Officials must ensure that it is genuinely implemented and benefits the public.
There is a saying in the bureaucracy worth keeping in mind: “It is not enough for something to be sent; it must be ensured that it is delivered.” This principle makes clear that civil servants must not become trapped in a culture of busyness—repeated meetings, piles of reports and seemingly endless administrative procedures—without ensuring tangible results.
The bureaucracy does not need officials who merely look busy, but people who do the work, solve problems and make a difference. Government success is not measured by how many activities are carried out or how thick the reports are, but by whether policies are implemented, services improve and people genuinely benefit.
Every priority programme must move beyond documents, reports and administrative indicators. It must reach communities, deliver benefits, create multiplier effects for the economy, open up opportunities and ultimately contribute to improved welfare.
In other words, the measure of bureaucratic success is not simply whether a programme has been carried out, but whether it works and brings change to people’s lives.
From central government to local administrations, civil servants work across all areas of public service. They are present in schools, community health centres, hospitals, village and sub-district offices, administrative service agencies and other institutions that deal directly with the public. They also serve on the frontline of disaster recovery and provide assistance to affected communities. It is in these settings that state policy takes its most tangible form.
Appreciation for civil servants is therefore not merely recognition that they fulfil their duties as government employees. It is also an acknowledgement of the bureaucracy’s role as one of the foundations of state capacity. Without a professional bureaucracy, development plans risk being undermined by a gap between policy on paper and implementation on the ground.
But that appreciation must also be accompanied by higher expectations. Civil servants must do more than work hard: the bureaucracy must work intelligently, with clear measures, accountability and adaptability. Every government programme needs to be supported by data-based planning, rational budgeting, effective coordination and open evaluation of its results and impact.
The large number of civil servants also underscores the importance of building a bureaucracy that is not only large in numerical terms, but strong in capacity and quality. As at 30 June 2026, there were 6,776,871 active civil servants working in central and regional government institutions.
Of that total, 3,480,108, or about 51 per cent, were permanent civil servants (PNS); 2,076,163, or about 31 per cent, were government employees on employment agreements (PPPK); and 1,220,600, or about 18 per cent, were part-time PPPK employees (BKN, 2026).
This composition also shows that Indonesia’s bureaucracy is largely based in the regions. Some 5,325,615 civil servants, or around 79 per cent, work for regional government institutions, while 1,451,256, or around 21 per cent, work for central government.
These figures should be read not merely as employment statistics, but as an indication of the scale of the state’s workforce operating every day across the regions and engaging directly with the public.
With such a large civil service, the relevant question is no longer simply how many officials the state employs, but how much impact they can generate. The state needs officials who are not merely present on paper, but who have the competence, integrity and performance orientation to translate government policy into tangible public services.
This is where meritocracy becomes an important instrument. The merit system must ensure that competence, performance, integrity and track record are the primary criteria for managing civil servants’ careers. This gives the bureaucracy a better chance of putting the right people in the right positions, particularly in roles that shape the quality of public policy and its implementation.
Safeguarding Meritocracy in the Civil Service
Meritocracy is not simply a mechanism for deciding who occupies a particular post. It is a way for the state to ensure that public authority is entrusted to people with the capacity to exercise it.
The more competent officials there are in strategic positions, the greater the bureaucracy’s ability to move faster, renew organisations, respond to change and adapt to public needs. Conversely, when appointments are determined mainly by personal connections, vested interests or factors unrelated to competence, the bureaucracy risks losing its technical capacity.
Bureaucratic reform and meritocracy are therefore inseparable. If Asta Cita—the government’s eight-point programme—requires a state that can work effectively, the state must also give the widest possible scope to competence, integrity and performance within its bureaucracy. Ultimately, the quality of government depends not only on good policies, but also on who is entrusted with implementing them.
The experience of other countries is relevant here. Citing Sik Sumaedi, Research Professor at the BRIN Centre for Behavioural and Circular Economy Research, Singapore is often held up as an example of how meritocracy has been made an important part of building government capacity and supporting national development (Mahbubani, 2022).
In a different context, China has also developed what is known as a model of political meritocracy, which, among other things, emphasises the importance of appointing people with sufficient capacity and integrity to government positions (Zhiwei & Bell, 2024).
The experiences of Singapore and China cannot, of course, simply be copied in Indonesia. Each country has a different political history, system of government, institutional structure and social character. But one lesson is worth considering: development success is determined not only by political-system choices or economic-policy design, but also by the quality of the institutions and people that operate the system.
Good policies need institutions capable of implementing them. Strong institutions need officials with competence and integrity. Meanwhile, high-quality officials need a system that allows them to progress on the basis of performance and capacity, rather than personal connections or other unprofessional considerations.
When appointment processes do not adequately guarantee merit, the issue is not merely an individual civil servant’s career. The effects can spread to the institutional level. Decisions that are not sufficiently grounded in competence can affect the quality of planning, budget use, programme delivery and public services. At a certain point, civil-service management problems can become problems of state capacity.
Building meritocracy therefore requires more than enacting regulations. The state also needs a system that ensures the principle works in practice, from recruitment and placement to promotion, professional development and performance evaluation. Meritocracy must be a living mechanism within the bureaucracy, not merely a rule written into regulations.
Civil Servants, Asta Cita and Bureaucratic Reform
The first two years of President Prabowo Subianto’s administration offer an important lesson: the success of Asta Cita depends not only on the soundness of policy direction, but also on the capacity of the bureaucracy to turn it into practical action. Bureaucratic reform and a stronger corps of professional, reform-minded officials must therefore be an important part of the government’s agenda going forward.
In an article I wrote for Antara News on 23 October 2025, entitled “Establishing an Independent Oversight Body for the Civil-Service Merit System”, I discussed Constitutional Court Decision No. 121/PUU-XXII/2024. In that decision, the Constitutional Court ordered the Government and the House of Representatives to establish an independent body tasked with overseeing the implementation of the merit system and the conduct of civil servants, no later than two years after the ruling was handed down.
One important item on the bureaucratic reform agenda, therefore, is the prompt establishment of an independent body to oversee the merit system. Such a body would not merely be an institutional arrangement; it would be a means of ensuring that merit is applied consistently and transparently, free from interference that could undermine civil-service professionalism.
A strong merit system will give officials room to progress on the basis of competence, performance, integrity and track record. At the same time, it will provide oversight to ensure that appointments, career development and civil-service management remain focused on the public interest.
Ultimately, a reform-minded bureaucracy is not one that merely carries out orders quickly. It is one that implements policy professionally, accounts for the use of every power entrusted to it and remains oriented towards the public interest. This is where bureaucratic reform finds its meaning: building a civil service that does not merely complete programmes, but ensures that each programme is delivered and brings real benefits.
The first two years of the Prabowo administration provide an opportunity to continue strengthening this foundation. Asta Cita requires a competent, principled and adaptable bureaucracy that operates according to a merit system. Strong government is ultimately determined not only by strong political leadership, but also by the quality of the institutions and officials carrying out the state’s mandate.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/a-bureaucratic-culture-of-looking-busy-is-not-enough-1792932679)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20261025183216-14-779269/tidak-cukup-dengan-budaya-asal-sibuk-birokrasi), translated from Indonesian