Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

91 Percent of Consumers Claim They Are Never Involved in Policy Discussions

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Economy
91 Percent of Consumers Claim They Are Never Involved in Policy Discussions
Image: Media Indonesia

A majority of tobacco product consumers claim they have never been involved in the discussion of policies that directly affect them. This finding emerged amidst the drafting of the Draft Ministerial Regulation of Health (RPMK) concerning Health Warnings and Information on Tobacco Products and Electronic Cigarettes, which includes plans to implement plain packaging.

A survey conducted by Pakta Konsumen involving 1,760 respondents showed that 91% of cigarette consumers stated they have never been invited to discuss or provide opinions during the regulatory drafting process for tobacco products. Furthermore, 78.6% of respondents felt that their rights as consumers have not been fulfilled.

The Chairman of Pakta Konsumen, Ary Fatanen, assessed that this situation indicates consumers are still being positioned as mere objects of policy, despite numbering approximately 69 million people, or nearly one-third of Indonesia’s population. “We want the aspirations and voices of cigarette consumers to be heard by the government. So far, consumers have made a significant contribution to state revenue, yet they feel they have no space to express opinions regarding policies that directly impact them,” he said.

According to Ary, the government needs to consider the broader impact before implementing plain packaging policies. He expressed concern that plain packaging would make it increasingly difficult for consumers to distinguish between legal and illegal products. Rather than reducing smoking rates, an increase in the consumption of illegal products would be more dangerous for health. “Consumers cannot differentiate between legal and illegal products, so they will simply choose the cheapest option. This has the potential to be dangerous for consumers because the product composition is unclear,” he noted.

A similar view was expressed by Legal Expert from Sebelas Maret University, Ayub Torlem Satrio Kusumo. He stated that community involvement is a fundamental principle in the formation of legislation. He emphasised that the public should not merely be passive objects of policy, especially when regulations directly impact the social and economic lives of the community.

“The government must consider the social, economic, and cultural aspects of society. Regulation is indeed necessary, but it must not ignore the groups that are directly affected,” he added.

Ayub also reminded that Law Number 8 of 1999 concerning Consumer Protection guarantees the right of the public to obtain accurate, clear, and honest information regarding the products they consume. Therefore, the government needs to ensure that plain packaging policies do not diminish the consumer’s right to recognise the products they use.

Opposition to plain packaging for cigarettes continues to emerge from various community groups. In Temanggung, hundreds of tobacco farmers even held a joint prayer as part of the Khoul Ki Ageng Makukuhan and Kirab Pikukuh Syuro traditions to express their aspiration for the government to review the derivative regulations of Government Regulation (PP) Number 28 of 2024 regarding Health.

The Village Head of Wonosari, who is also the General Chairman of the Indonesian Tobacco Farmers Association (APTI), Agus Parmuji, stated that the greatest concern for farmers currently is the potential decline in tobacco absorption if the government proceeds with several restrictive policies contained in the derivative regulations of PP 28/2024.

“The result will certainly have a social impact on farmers and workers. When the uniformity of cigarette packaging is enforced, it is equivalent to killing production creativity. It will certainly further slow down the absorption of harvests,” he said.

Agus assessed that this condition would directly impact the livelihoods of farmers, as the tobacco industry has long been the primary absorber of harvests. A reduction in demand from the industry would not only affect farmers’ incomes but also potentially disrupt the tobacco economic chain involving farm labourers, processing entrepreneurs, and supporting sectors.

This is because the national tobacco sector is being pressured by various regulations, such as the plain packaging rule, nicotine and tar limits, and the prohibition of certain additives, which could halt production processes. In addition to farmers, all these regulations threaten the workforce in this labour-intensive sector with job losses.

Unsurprisingly, strong opposition has also come from labour unions. The Chairman of the Regional Leadership of the Tobacco, Food, and Beverage Workers Federation–SPSI of the Special Region of Yogyakarta (PD FSP RTMM-SPSI DIY), Waljid Budi Lestarianto, assessed that plain packaging could threaten the livelihoods of millions of workers who depend on income from the tobacco industry. According to him, the policy would not only affect tobacco companies but could also pressure the livelihoods of rolling labourers, factory workers, tobacco and clove farmers, and other supporting entrepreneurs who are part of the tobacco industry chain.

He believes that if the policy weakens the legal tobacco industry, companies may engage in efficiency measures resulting in workforce reductions, particularly in the labour-intensive Kretek Hand-Rolled Cigarette (SKT) sector.

Therefore, Waljid emphasised that the drafting of the RPMK should not only consider health aspects but also account for its impact on job protection and the sustainability of the livelihoods of millions of workers and their families who depend on the tobacco industry. The majority of the tobacco sector’s workforce has limited educational profiles, making mitigation in this labour-intensive sector crucial to find solutions before these regulations are ratified.

“We firmly reject the plan to implement packaging uniformity that will be regulated in the draft ministerial regulation of health,” he added.

More from 30 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/91-percent-of-consumers-claim-they-are-never-involved-in-policy-discussions-1782831019)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/ekonomi/905989/91-persen-konsumen-mengaku-tak-pernah-dilibatkan-dalam-pembahasan-kebijakan), translated from Indonesian
Print