54-year-old makes so many songs that he beats Taylor Swift — then ends up in prison
JAKARTA, CNBC Indonesia — AI-generated songs have recorded far more streams than Taylor Swift’s music catalogue on streaming platforms. But the figures were not the result of musical popularity; they were caused by a streaming fraud scheme carried out by a man in the United States.
Michael Smith, a 54-year-old from North Carolina, has been sentenced to 18 months in prison after admitting that he used AI to create songs and manipulated music-streaming services to make millions of dollars.
The US Department of Justice (DOJ) described Smith as the first person in the country to face criminal charges for AI-assisted streaming fraud.
Smith ran the scheme undetected for seven years, from 2017 until his arrest in 2024.
He used fake email accounts and illegally obtained debit cards to create thousands of accounts across various platforms, including Amazon Music, Apple Music, Spotify and YouTube Music.
Smith then used software to deploy bots that repeatedly played songs he claimed to own. The DOJ said the songs had been generated using AI.
By the time he was arrested in 2024, Smith had produced hundreds of thousands of AI-generated songs. He directed billions of automated streams to those tracks to avoid raising suspicion, spreading the plays across the catalogue rather than concentrating them on a single song.
The scale of the manipulation was evident in April 2023. According to the DOJ, Smith’s fake songs received 80.9 million streams that month, while Taylor Swift’s entire music catalogue recorded just 9.3 million streams over the same period.
The scheme harmed not only streaming platforms but also musicians who rely on royalties from song plays.
The DOJ said Smith took a share of the royalty pool that should have been distributed to music rights holders, reducing the income received by musicians.
In addition to the 18-month prison sentence, the court ordered Smith to repay US$8,091,843.64 that he had claimed through the scheme.
The DOJ said Smith used increasingly deceptive tactics to keep manipulating streams and lied to police when he came under investigation.
“For years, Smith orchestrated a sophisticated fraud scheme that stole millions of dollars in music royalties from rights holders,” the DOJ said, as quoted by Ars Technica on Monday (12 October 2026).
The DOJ also asked the court to impose a sentence that would deter others from committing similar offences.
“The court should impose a sentence that adequately punishes the defendant for his fraudulent scheme and sends a message to others that streaming fraud will be met with serious punishment,” the DOJ said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/54-year-old-makes-so-many-songs-that-he-beats-taylor-swift-then-ends-up-in-prison-1791777062)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/tech/20261012085237-37-775213/pria-54-tahun-bikin-lagu-sampai-taylor-swift-kalah-ujungnya-masuk-bui), translated from Indonesian