Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

520-Page Plea: Bali Tidak Diam Activist Tomy Wiria Seeks Acquittal

| Source: detikBali Translated from Indonesian | Legal
520-Page Plea: Bali Tidak Diam Activist Tomy Wiria Seeks Acquittal
Image: detikBali

The legal counsel team for activist Tomy Priatna Wiria has refuted all charges brought by the Public Prosecutor through a 520-page defence plea. In addition to the team’s plea, the Bali Tidak Diam activist also read out a 42-page personal defence and requested to be acquitted.

Tomy’s legal counsel, Ignatius Radhite, argued that the six-month prison sentence demanded against his client was not proven when linked to the facts that emerged during the trial. One of the main points of the defence team’s argument concerns the application of Article 247 of the Criminal Code on incitement.

“Article 247 on incitement as charged by the prosecutor is not proven. Article 247 or the incitement article has been interpreted by the Constitutional Court and is clearly a material offence,” said Ignatius after the hearing at the Denpasar District Court on Thursday (20/8/2026).

According to Ignatius, the consequence of a material offence is that the prosecutor must prove the existence of a real consequence from the alleged act. In the context of Tomy’s case, he said, it must be clear who is considered the inciter, who was incited, and the causal relationship between Tomy’s statement and the actions of the party said to have been incited.

“What is important and must be proven by the prosecutor is who is considered the inciter, who was incited, and what the causal relationship is,” Ignatius added.

The legal team assessed that Tomy is not an inciter. According to Ignatius, the content of the ‘Bali Tidak Diam’ poster during the August 2025 demonstration, which became one of the bases of the case, did not contain an explicit call to commit violence. He stated that there were no calls such as to burn, throw, storm, or steal in the poster.

“The content of the Bali Tidak Diam poster contains no explicit call, no call to burn, no call to throw, no call to storm, to steal and so on. There is no explicit call. He only spoke about fighting state violence,” said Ignatius.

Ignatius then linked this to the principle of legality in criminal law. According to him, if a statement is to be categorised as incitement to commit arson or violence, then the call must be stated explicitly.

“If the end result is arson, then for the poster to be considered incitement it must call for ‘let’s burn’, ‘let’s throw’. That does not exist,” he asserted.

No Party Was Incited

The next point highlighted by the legal team is the absence of any party that could be proven to have been incited by Tomy’s statement or poster. Ignatius said that the testimony of witnesses presented during the trial actually showed that the violent acts that occurred during the demonstration were not related to Tomy’s poster.

According to him, a number of actions such as throwing, the use of Molotov cocktails, and arson occurred due to spontaneous situations in the field or as a response to other actions, not as a result of the poster made by Tomy.

“No party was incited. The witnesses presented by the prosecutor clearly stated that the acts they committed during the demonstration had no connection to Tomy’s poster,” said Ignatius.

“The demonstrators who previously threw, carried Molotov cocktails, and burned did so spontaneously, due to the situation in the field or provoked by other throws. There is no connection to the poster,” he added. On that basis, the legal team assessed that the main element of incitement was not fulfilled.

Consolidation Poster Said to Be Unrelated to the Riots

Tomy’s legal team also refuted any connection between the consolidation poster that became the basis of the case and the violence and riots that occurred during the demonstration. Ignatius explained that there is a difference between a poster inviting consolidation and a poster calling for action.

According to him, the consolidation poster only relates to consolidation activities, while the riots occurred during the demonstration. “The consolidation poster has no connection to the action call poster. The consolidation poster only applies to the consolidation event,” he said.

According to Ignatius, the prosecutor made a logical leap by linking Tomy’s consolidation material with the violent events that occurred at a different time and forum. He admitted that he found no causal relationship between the material delivered by Tomy and the riots that occurred.

“The violence and riots did not occur during the consolidation forum, but occurred during the action forum. So there is a very far logical leap that the prosecutor is trying to show,” said Ignatius.

“There is no connection, no causal relationship, no intention, no motive,” he continued.

Alleged Human Rights Violations Raised

In the plea, the legal team also raised allegations of human rights violations experienced by Tomy during the legal process. Ignatius stated that Tomy experienced intimidation and violence.

The legal team also questioned the examination process, which they said was marked by torture, violence, manipulation, and direction by investigators. Therefore, the legal team requested that the panel of judges not use the statements in the examination report that they disputed as a basis to prove Tomy’s guilt.

“Tomy experienced human rights violations, including intimidation and violence. The statements in the examination report were obtained through torture, violence, manipulation, and direction from investigators, so they cannot be used as evidence,” said Ignatius.

Based on all these arguments, the legal counsel team requested that the panel of judges declare Tomy not proven to have committed a criminal act as charged by the Public Prosecutor and acquit him. “The consideration is clear, Tomy is not guilty,” he said.

Previously, the Public Prosecutor demanded a six-month prison sentence for Tomy for being proven to have violated Article 247 of the Criminal Code. The prosecutor stated that all elements of disseminating information containing incitement with the intention of making it publicly known had been fulfilled.

The prosecutor also stated that Tomy’s actions disturbed security and order as an aggravating consideration. Meanwhile, his polite attitude during the trial was a mitigating consideration.

The next hearing will enter the next stage.

More from 20 August 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/520-page-plea-bali-tidak-diam-activist-tomy-wiria-seeks-acquittal-1787223129)
Originally published by detikBali (https://www.detik.com/bali/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-8627285/pledoi-520-halaman-aktivis-bali-tidak-diam-tomy-wiria-minta-dibebaskan), translated from Indonesian
Print