5 Refuted Jewish Claims Over Palestinian Land
There are various misleading and incorrect claims put forward by the Zionist movement and the Israeli occupation in an attempt to distort and erase the rights of the Arab nation and the Islamic community in Palestine.
This is being carried out through media propaganda funded by Western parties, which has accumulated over decades with the aim of convincing the Jewish people first, and subsequently global public opinion, that they possess exclusive rights over Palestine.
Quoting from the official website of the Secretary-General of the International Union of Muslim Scholars, Sheikh Muhammad ash-Shalabi, on Thursday (24/9/2026), Zionist propaganda in justifying their occupation of Palestine and surrounding territories (the Eastern Arab region of the Middle East) relies on several rights created by the Jewish people themselves. According to the author, these claims have no basis in scientific, political, historical, or social dictionaries at any period (Al-’Unshuriyyah al-Yahudiyyah, Ahmad az-Za‘bi, 2010, volume 3, p. 521).
- Historical Right
What is meant by historical right is the claim that the Jewish people resided in Palestine in the past and established a political entity there, during relatively short and intermittent periods (Filasthin fi Dhau’ al-Haqq wa al-’Adl, Henry Catatan, p. 149).
According to the author, this claim fails for the following fundamental reasons:
- The Arab people were the first group to settle in Palestine, and their presence in the region has never been interrupted throughout history up to the present day.
The earliest migration to Palestine recorded in history is the migration of the inhabitants of the Arabian Peninsula, namely the Canaanites. When droughts began to spread across desert regions, they were forced to move towards areas with abundant water and natural resources.
They subsequently migrated to Palestine and surrounding areas, both to the east and the west, because at that time the region was among the most fertile and rich in agricultural produce and mineral resources.
The Canaanites, according to the descriptions in this manuscript, are descendants of Canaan bin Ham bin Noah (PBUH). They are attributed to the inhabitants of the Arabian Peninsula and, according to the most closely accepted estimates, migrated to Palestine in the first half of the third millennium BCE.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/5-refuted-jewish-claims-over-palestinian-land-1790229519)
Originally published by Republika (https://khazanah.republika.co.id/berita/tlurau320/5-klaim-yahudi-atas-tanah-palestina-yang-terbantahkan), translated from Indonesian