Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

1. ANALYSIS: 1 X 45

1. ANALYSIS: 1 X 45

TNI top job sets politicians bickering

President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono's request to annul his
predecessor's request for lawmakers to discuss the replacement of
the Indonesian Military (TNI) chief, which was announced during a
plenary meeting of the House of Representatives last Wednesday,
was a controversial move by the new president.

It is controversial because logically it is TNI chief Gen.
Endriartono Sutarto himself who should withdraw his letter of
resignation, which was tendered to then president Megawati
Soekarnoputri on Sept. 24, 2004.

Megawati appointed Army Chief of Staff Gen. Ryamizard Ryacudu
as acting TNI chief and at the same time sent a letter endorsing
Endriartono's resignation to the House for its approval a few
days before her tenure ended on Oct. 20, but the House could not
respond to it as the commission mandated to discuss it had not
yet been formed.

The Constitution requires the president to seek the approval
of the House in the selection of the TNI and National Police
chief.

Meanwhile, Susilo said his request for the withdrawal of
Megawati's letter "was nothing personal" either in connection
with Endriartono or Ryamizard.

And the way Susilo treated the case, which was later included
in the agenda of the new House despite disagreement whether or
not to accommodate his request, gave the impression that the
President wanted Endriartono to retain his post.

Cabinet secretary Sudi Silalahi confirmed that the President
had talked to Endriartono, who agreed to stay on as the TNI
chief.

Meanwhile, Endriartono himself had briefed all chiefs of staff
and told them that he had decided to retain his post as TNI chief
upon the request of the President, who is also the TNI Supreme
Commander.

The question would then be why the President chose to maintain
Endriartono and not to pick another candidate, Ryamizard, for
example.

To answer the question, it would be good to flash back to the
period when Endriartono submitted his resignation to Megawati in
late September.

National media have widely reported that Endriartono's
decision to quit his post was triggered by Megawati's move to
grant the four-star general status to State Intelligence Agency
(BIN) chief A.M. Hendropriyono and then Minister of Home Affairs
Hari Sabarno, who were both previously retired Army lieutenant
generals.

Although granting a rank promotion to TNI generals is not a
new practice for a president in this republic, Megawati's
decision was indeed controversial as she granted the status to
the generals, who in the eyes of many had not made such an
extraordinary contribution during their term in office to warrant
a promotion to four-star general.

However, Endriartono's move to submit his resignation letter
before the end of Megawati's term and at the time when then
president-elect Susilo was putting together his Cabinet was
equally controversial.

Many in political and military circles have expressed the
belief that Endriartono's move was part and parcel of the
selection process being carried out by Susilo to fill in the
Cabinet posts.

It was also mentioned that Endriartono was once offered the
post of coordinating minister for political, legal and security
Affairs, but he had to let it go as Susilo was in favor of Adm.
(ret) Widodo A.S., who is more senior than Endriartono. Widodo is
a 1968 graduate of the Naval Academy and the TNI chief during the
presidency of Abdurrahman "Gus Dur" Wahid, while Endriartono is a
1971 graduate of the National Military Academy.

And it was not possible for Endriartono, a four-star general,
to accept the offer of the post of home minister, a Cabinet post
which has traditionally been held by officers from the TNI
headquarters, because the post is intended for three-star
generals only.

After it was clear that Endriartono could not get a Cabinet
post, the idea emerged of asking for the annulment of Megawati's
request to the House. And constitutionally speaking, Endriartono
could get his post back as the House had yet to make any decision
on his resignation letter.

The decision whether to elect a new TNI chief or retain
Endriartono would then be in the hands of the House.

Pro-Susilo factions are pressing for the annulment of
Megawati's letter on the dismissal of Endriartono and the
appointment of Ryamizard as acting TNI chief.

Factions affiliated to the Nationhood Coalition plus the
National Awakening Party (PKB) instead insisted on responding to
the letter sent by Megawati. The Nationhood Coalition comprises
the Golkar Party, the Indonesian Democratic Party, the Prosperous
Peace Party and the Reform Star Party.

Some of the House members mulled exercising their right to
summon the President to seek an explanation for his letter. They
also suggested an alternative candidate for the post, Deputy Army
Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Djoko Santoso.

However, in terms of strategy, it will be more appropriate for
Susilo to keep Endriartono as TNI chief rather than appointing
Ryamizard or Djoko as the new chief.

By keeping Endriartono in command, it will be easier for
Susilo to gain support from the TNI headquarters, although he
himself is a TNI general.

And by keeping Endriartono, it will also reduce potential
resistance from the Navy and the Air Force.

There was an agreement made during the presidency of
Abdurrahman Wahid that the post of TNI chief would be rotated
among the three TNI forces. But after the ouster of Abdurrahman
in October 2001, Megawati appointed Endriartono to replace
Widodo, instead of granting the post to an Air Force officer.

And if Susilo appoints Ryamizard, a 1973 graduate of the
National Military Academy, or Djoko, a 1975 graduate of the
academy, it will be difficult to deal with the Navy and the Air
Force, as the Navy Chief of Staff Vice Adm. Bernard Kent Sondakh
is a 1970 graduate of the Naval Academy and the Air Force Chief
of Staff Vice Marshal Chappy Hakim is a 1971 graduate of the Air
Force Academy.

2. BANK: 2 X 18

Future may not be so
hot for banks: Experts

The country's commercial banks have booked strong third quarter
profits, thanks mainly to low cost of funds that allowed them to
enjoy fat net interest margins.

But analysts warned that as pressure on the central bank to
increase interest rates intensifies, banks may no longer enjoy
this kind of good fortune next year without working hard to
revive lending to the corporate sector.

"I think this kind of profit growth will not be sustainable,"
said banking analyst Fendi Susiyanto.

He said that current economic developments, such as rising oil
prices, rising interest rates in the U.S. and elsewhere, and
inflationary pressures at home, indicated that Bank Indonesia
would likely increase interest rates, a move that would increase
the interest expenses paid by banks to depositors, and eat into
their profit margins.

He said that this would erode the profits of banks if they
continued to solely depend on lower cost of funds.

The strong third quarter profits earned by publicly listed
banks, in some cases reporting a doubling of profits compared to
the same period last year, was not caused by hard work on the
part of the highly paid bankers, but rather the effects of the
aggressive cutting of central bank benchmark interest rates,
which in May fell to a record low of 7.32 percent compared to
over 13 percent in 2003.

The lower benchmark rates forced interest rates on time
deposits and savings to fall as well, but interest rates on loans
remain high as the banks are still reluctant to channel their
excess funds to the corporate sector due to lingering risks as
reflected in a relatively low loan to deposit ratio (LDR) of
around 50 percent, compared to 80 percent prior to the late 1997
financial crisis. This situation had allowed banks to enjoy net
interest margins (NIM) of as high as 8.5 percent.

"The current (interest rate) spread is still too wide (about
8.5 percent), and should be narrowed to at least 4 percent," said
Fendi.

Seconding Fendi, economist Faisal Basri said the situation
here was different from neighboring countries such as Malaysia,
Thailand, the Philippines and Korea, where NIMs were below 5
percent.

Ideally, banks should be charging much lower interest rates on
loans than they are doing now, and could still make good profits
though increased lending activity.

Fendi, however, said that major banks would not immediately
pump up their lending rates even if the Bank Indonesia benchmark
interest rate started to climb as these banks had better sources
of funding compared to smaller ones.

"Only around 15 large banks control up to 70 percent of our
banking industry. They won't have critical problems in offsetting
losses in NIMs unlike dozens of smaller banks, and possibly won't
raise lending rates, at least as long as the SBI rate remains
below 8.5 percent," said Fendi, referring to the interest rate on
Bank Indonesia SBI promissory notes.

Given these considerations, one of the biggest challenges
ahead will be how to preserve profit levels, whether or not the
SBI rate moves up, based on more sustainable sources.

"Banks can maintain profits by accelerating lending and
maximizing their fee-based income, which is even more essential
in improving their profitability. For example, by being an
investment advisor or upgrading their service sector. Banks need
to increase the contribution of fee-based income to profits from
the current average of 7 percent to about 16 percent," Fendi
said.

3. JAPAN: 1 X 32

Japan says it will keep troops in Iraq

(Original heading from Reuters: Japan vows to stay in Iraq after
hostage beheaded)

Japan on Sunday condemned the beheading of a Japanese hostage in
Iraq as a despicable act of terrorism and vowed to keep its
troops in the country on their reconstruction mission.

Japanese officials confirmed that the body and severed head of
a man found wrapped in a U.S. flag in Baghdad on Saturday was
that of 24-year-old Shosei Koda, a civilian who apparently took a
bus to Iraq from Jordan last week.

He was the fifth Japanese to be killed in Iraq since the start
of the U.S.-led war in March 2003.

"I once again feel anger at this cruel and inhuman act," said
Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi, a close ally of U.S. President
George W. Bush.

He told reporters that Japanese troops would stay in Iraq,
where they are on a non-combat mission that is nevertheless the
military's riskiest since World War II.

Other Japanese leaders confirmed that stance.

"Our country will never forget this sorrow and pain and will
continue to be firmly committed to fighting terrorism," top
government spokesman Hiroyuki Hosoda said.

"The Self-Defense Forces (military) will continue to provide
humanitarian and reconstruction assistance as a friend of Iraq."

A militant group headed by al-Qaeda ally Abu Musab al-Zarqawi
had said in an Internet video on Wednesday that it would behead
Koda within 48 hours if Japan did not withdraw its troops.

Iraqi police found the body on Saturday around Haifa street, a
dangerous area in central Baghdad where insurgents are active.

A news agency pool video obtained in Baghdad showed a corpse
in a white, blood-soaked shirt and the severed head of a
Japanese-looking man with a thin beard.

The killing poses a political challenge for Koizumi, who sent
troops to Iraq despite opposition from most voters. Some critics
say the mission violates Japan's pacifist constitution.

Analysts said the immediate fallout would be limited because
many ordinary Japanese blamed Koda for putting himself at risk.

But the news could complicate a decision on whether to extend
the troops' mission after their mandate expires next month.

Members of Koda's family had begged for the life of a young
man they said had no ties to Japan's military, no political
agenda and was not in search of personal gain.

"We have caused trouble for everyone. We are praying that
peace will come to the people of Iraq," local government official
Masatoshi Norimatsu quoted Koda's brother, Maki, as saying after
news of his death.

Many Japanese had questioned why Koda went to Iraq without any
real preparation and with no clear purpose.

Meanwhile, the parents of late Daniel Pearl -- a Wall Street
Journal reporter who was murdered in Pakistan in 2002 -- called
on the world community to harness all possible efforts to repel
killing of innocent hostages.

"Two-and-half years ago, when the world reacted with shock and
indignation to the brutal murder of our son, we were hoping that
the lives of innocent people would never again be used as a
bargaining chip. We also hoped that the civilized world would
mobilize and unite to protect itself against the strand of evil,
one that boasts in cruelty and ritualizes inhumanity. We were
wrong," Judea and Ruth Pearl, the parents of Daniel, said in an
appeal published in the International Herald Tribune on Friday.

More than 150 foreigners have been abducted so far in Iraq ,
and more than 35 of them killed.

Related story on Page 12

More from 1 November 2004 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/1-analysis-1-x-45-1447899208-1451234)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print