Wed, 27 Jul 2005

'Why teach freedom of religion in schools?'

Even though the Indonesian Ahmadiyah Congregation (JAI) had not caused any disturbances, its center in Parung, Bogor, was attacked by thousands of people earlier this month. The government forced the congregation's members to leave the compound, raising debate over freedom of religion in the country. The Jakarta Post asked residents for their thoughts on the issue.

Andry Asmoro, 28, is a researcher with the Institute for Economic and Social Research at the University of Indonesia's school of economics. He lives in South Jakarta:

I don't agree with any group that labels itself as a group of believers but in reality disrupts the activities of people of another faith.

A person does not have the right to attack another over a difference of opinion. If they are critical of a belief system, they should approach the matter with sensitivity.

No religion teaches hostility. Prophet Muhammad spoke of tolerance. He did not allow his people to attack women and unarmed enemies.

Many Indonesians are fanatics. In my opinion, this shows they are uneducated.

Sarah Imelda, 25, is a public relations officer at a hotel in Central Jakarta. She lives in West Jakarta:

Freedom of religion is discussed in schools, so everyone should know having a religion is the right of every citizen.

As we get older, it becomes apparent that tolerance is not present in society. So, what is the point of teaching children to be tolerant, when adults set such a bad example?

It is unjust for people to be forbidden to practice their religion.

In Indonesia, I think, only 60 percent of people believe in freedom of religion. Some groups that consider themselves to be the majority engage in conflicts with minority groups. This must have a negative effect on the country's image internationally. The world probably sees this country as being an unsafe place to live.

-- The Jakarta Post