The good fallout from Iraq

Michel Rocard, Project Syndicate

Reconciling morals with how a society is organized -- in other words, reconciling ethics with politics -- is one of humanity's oldest ambitions. Hammurabi, Raamses II, Solon, Confucius, and Pericles were among the first great figures to embark on this effort. The emergence of the nation-state in the eighteenth century, and the extreme level of barbarism reached in the twentieth century, may have created the impression that an ethical politics was an unrealizable dream, or that it was a dream growing ever more distant as it receded into the future.

Yet, despite the rivalry of nations and the bloodiness of modern warfare, democracy is spreading. Indeed, in but half a century, Latin Americans rid themselves of all of that continent's military and civilian dictatorships, and Africa has eliminated more than half of the despots that have blighted its era of independence.

Compared with all the other political regimes known to mankind, democracy represents ethical progress twice over: first, because it is based on respect for human rights; and secondly, because the universal suffrage that modern democracy embraces prohibits neglecting or oppressing minorities.

Of course, progress towards more democracy and morality in international public affairs remains extremely slow. Yet the year 2004 may leave to history some of the greatest progress in this area that humanity has seen.

Signs of hope and progress abound. A Spanish government was overthrown because it lied to its public about the origin of the terrorist bombs that ripped apart Madrid's train station last spring. Tony Blair and George W. Bush are having huge problems with their electorates, also because they lied about the reasons they gave to justify their war in Iraq.

Democracy is alive and well in the developing world, too. The electoral process in Indonesia is reaching a level of equity and accountability hitherto unknown in that country. Morocco and Algeria are working to strengthen women's rights. Turkey has committed itself to a vast legislative effort to improve human rights, freedom of thought, treatment of prisoners, and civilian control over the military.

Even China, though highly insensitive to democratic principles, is discovering, with the dangerous spread of AIDS, an obligation to listen to popular clamor, and the need for public support to justify government actions. The U.S., owing to its horrific treatment and torture of prisoners in Baghdad, has had no option but to search for international legitimacy after denying and defying it for so long, in order to extricate itself from the chaos and drama of what is now Iraq.

Israel has seen both the legitimacy of its "security wall," as well as the wall's proposed path through Palestinian territory, called into question -- differently, but in a parallel manner -- by both its own Supreme Court and by the International Court of Justice in The Hague. Israel will not be able to ignore completely the rulings of either court.

In replacing the Organization of African Unity with the African Union, Africa, for its part, is making a huge effort to control conflict on the continent, as well as to spread observance of human rights and pursue the struggle against poverty.

Moreover, capitalism itself is feeling pressure in every direction. It sees ever increasing anger against bloated payments to bosses, risky speculation, and outright fraud.

The creation of the International Criminal Court strengthens all of these efforts to bring abuses of power by the powerful to book.

So, despite the Iraq war and the seeming impotence of world institutions, the beginning of the twenty-first century could well bring faster global improvement in political ethics than at any time in the past. But for this trend to truly take hold, good politics needs something more than morals alone. States must begin to explain their toughest actions, those deeds that the search for security and the inevitable mistrust among states make necessary. "Reason of State" will not disappear entirely. But for democracy to continue its march of ethical progress, reasons of state must be submitted to greater public accountability and justification.

The writer is a former Prime Minister of France and leader of the Socialist Party, is a member of the European Parliament.