'Salaries, benefits should be cut'

Mixed reactions have poured in over the decision of the People's Consultative Assembly (MPR) leaders to return the luxury cars they are entitled to and start the campaign of a modest life. The Jakarta Post talked to some residents of their opinion about the campaign.

Diana, 26, works for a consultant company on Jl. Sudirman, Central Jakarta. She lives with her family in Pulomas, East Jakarta:

I think it's good that some leaders have tried to show a little bit more sense. The cars can be a starting point and they should take it further than that.

I know some people think of it as lip-service and an 'insignificant' saving for our country.

First of all, I don't think it's insignificant. Let's say one MPR member saves Rp 200 million (US$21,978) from renounce the Volvo car. There are hundreds of members, so the savings could be over Rp 100 billion. And that's only from the cars.

Secondly, money is besides the point. If all councillors in the regions follow suit, and truly keep their word -- however doubtful that may be -- perhaps people will start believing in the elites of this country again.

Carla June Nathan, mid-30s, works for a non-governmental organization in Cempaka Putih, Central Jakarta. She lives near her office:

If they want to promote a modest lifestyle, they should not only cut back on the cars. Their living costs are really high, with all the allowances and benefits that they get.

I think it would be ridiculous if they gave up the cars but then got more benefits from other sources.

If the target is to make this republic better, they should get their salaries cut. They should calculate what an appropriate salary should be for a suitable lifestyle, and get that much only.

The MPR should establish a policy about what is appropriate for its members in the current economical condition. He (Hidayat Nur Wahid, the MPR chairman) could start with his Prosperous Justice Party (PKS) and its coalition.

I approve that he is making this breakthrough. But, if he is really committed for the next five years, there should be a change in the MPR's internal policy on its members' salary and facilities.

-- The Jakarta Post