President Susilo must stamp out terrorist groups

President Susilo must stamp out terrorist groups

W. Scott Thompson, Sukawati, Bali

How do we measure the real cost of the three bombs in Bali
this past weekend? Of course anyone would go past the tragedy of
the dead and wounded and add to that the economic cost of lost
business that inevitably will follow. After all, the 2002 bombs
cost the fabled isle over half its tourism in the first year,
adding up to billions of dollars in losses. But what do those
added costs really amount to?

Is it sufficient just to add up the losses of income almost
every Balinese family suffered? Or should we add the medical
costs from the resulting inability to buy medicines? And add in
the lost cost to society from educational programs abandoned? It
all depends on how comprehensive we wish to be. But let's be
clear: The real costs of such trauma as this is always far
greater than assumed.

Let us consider Indonesia as a whole. If President Susilo
Bambang Yudhoyono does not show leadership and the casualty list
exceeds one hundred, it is possible that Bali will lose another
year of tourism, in the sense that for two years half its
prospective tourists will change plans; and that the economic
growth rate of Indonesia as a whole will be cut by two percentage
points.

So we're well above US$5 billion now in losses. But add in the
opportunity costs -- the things that might have been done with
that growth money -- plus the human costs in Sumatran villages
where just a little bit less income, in already poor regions,
means more babies die in childbirth, more academic programs are
aborted, and so on. Would it be about right to say we are talking
not 100 casualties but 50,000 -- and almost all of them, like the
casualty list last weekend in Bali, Muslim! it simply isn't fair
for good Muslims to bear the vast costs of a fringe of fanatics.

The economic question now is whether the new Bali bombs will
be a tourist blip or another catastrophe. We don't know the final
numbers, but they will be substantially less than 2002's.
however, tourists might just say "this is the third big one for
Indonesia," and given the bureaucratic hassles imposed on
tourists -- the long lines to pay the "visa on arrival" for a
shortened period, compared with Malaysia and Thailand, both
greatly outdrawing the archipelago -- the cut in tourism may be
as bad as in 2002.

The big difference however is in leadership potential. In 2002
President Megawati Soekarnoputri was at her calm best -- or
worst. It took quite a time for even to go out and inspect the
damage, let alone say anything meaningful to rally the nation. It
seemed as if she was just carrying on as usual, despite the
explicit warning western intelligence services had given her of
the imminence of an attack.

President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono is cut from sturdier cloth.
He went right to the site on Sunday. But quite possibly the
biggest challenge he will have in his presidency, even possibly
in his life, is how he motivates Indonesia in the next weeks.

He already had a big enough crisis on this hands. Like low-
paid city folk throughout the third world, the masses of
Indonesians dependent on cheap transportation don't get it that
oil has to be paid for, and the price is not determined by cabals
of crooks in Jakarta, but by world market supply and demand.

Indonesia has had the cheapest gas at the pump of any country
in the world save Iran, because government was paying half the
price and running up huge deficits. these deficits were in turn
cheapening the currency (the rupiah had been at 8500 to the
dollar for several years before turning south this year to as low
as 11,000).

President Susilo was firm, very firm, with the first increase.
He told the parliament that it could debate all it wanted, but
the decision was made and final. Now he's pushing the price up
nearer its real price, to cut that $11 billion subsidy and lower
the deficit. The street doesn't like it.

If he shows real leadership, addresses the country about
reality and what must be done to get the economy moving, by
getting foreign investment and new oil fields pumping, and what
must be done finally to end the scourge of terrorism, and gives
the message in visits all over the country, he'll have made a
good first step.

It will be standing tall, the way Mahathir did in the Asian
economic crisis, in freezing the Ringgit and defying foreign
economic forces. It will be like President Kennedy rallying
America for the Cuban Missile Crisis. It will be like President
Charles de Gaulle defying all the constraining political forces
of France and creating a path to a new republic.

But it will take more. He is going to have to ask for special
powers during what he must call an emergency. It wouldn't be
unjustified among democracies to declare martial law for Bali,
for a limited period, in order to root out the cadre behind the
bombers. Tourists wouldn't mind. Balinese wouldn't mind. My
Balinese employees reported that everyone wanted to storm the
Kerobokan jail where the 2002 bomber-prisoners are; calmer voices
prevailed. And then things must start to happen. Sentences have
to be carried out swiftly against terrorists.

But I remember precisely the title "let the monsters swing." I
suspect that until the JI knows that Susilo will maintain that
tough stance, and will show that he and the vast majority of the
country won't be intimidated, like Thatcher, the bombs will keep
coming. Leniency will be interpreted as precisely that: As
weakness. Indonesia happily astonished the world last year with
its fair and honorable elections. It's the biggest state in the
region and has to show strength or the region loses confidence
too.

The writer is adjunct professor of international politics at
the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy. He resides part time in
Bali.