House questions new haj program
Dewi Santoso Jakarta
The accountability of Minister of Religious Affairs Said Agiel Al Munawar's planned haj savings program was questioned during a House commission on Tuesday.
Beginning in 2005, the government will require those who wish to go on the pilgrimage to deposit money at designated banks every month until their savings reach Rp 20 million (US$2,298). The designated banks include Bank Mandiri, Bank Muamalat and Bank BNI.
Said said the pilgrims would not earn interest on their accounts. The savings would remain in the banks until the pilgrims left for Mecca, he said.
A member of the House's Commission VI for the people's welfare, Syahrul Azmir Matondang, questioned whether the policy would lead to corruption as it was not clear what would happen to the money after it was deposited. Any interest the banks or religious ministry earned on the money should also be considered haram (forbidden by Islamic law), he said.
"What will happen to the interest on the accounts, then? Will it go into the ministry's account? If that is so, then what is the compensation for those who save the money?" Syahrul said.
Jakarta Consumers Institution executive director Zaim Saidi said a policy requiring people to deposit money in banks in order to go on the haj was detrimental to them.
"It's a dilemma for them because on one hand, they are morally required to deposit money for their haj pilgrimage. On the other hand, they can receive no interest because it is considered haram," said Zaim.
"Can anybody say where this interest would go? No, because there are no clear systems to really define or trace it, and that's what makes this policy unfair," Zaim told The Jakarta Post.
The only beneficiaries of the policy were the account holder -- the religious ministry -- and the banks, he said.
"It's clear the Ministry of Religious Affairs has the power to do anything it wants with the money -- or interest. It would be very easy for the ministry to misuse it," he said.
A total of 205,000 pilgrims a year are officially allowed to visit Saudi Arabia for the haj under a bilateral quota system. The quota for next year has already been filled. For 2006, 3,122 people have been registered with the ministry for the haj trip.
At about Rp 24 million ($2,775) per pilgrim, the country has around Rp 5 trillion per annum in haj savings, earning billions of rupiah in interest.
Zaim suggested that the pilgrims be required to save gold dinars that could be changed into rupiah to finance their trip.
"One gold dinar has an international standard of 4.5 grams of 22 carat gold. And as far as I can recall, the price of gold has never decreased. This system will benefit Muslims," he said.
Malaysia has had a similar program running since last year, he said.
"The problem is that no banks will be willing to apply this system. Therefore, the government should encourage the establishment of a new private institution that will operate the program," Zaim said.
The next haj begins in January.